SAK's - Corkscrew or Phillips?
-
Phillips all the way for me, even going as far as wanting to mod my otherwise faves to get rid of the corkscrew. I will have a few corkscrews lying about going spare so if anyone's desperate for one, let me know!
I don't drink often, any very rarely wine so I have no use for the things.. I use the toothpick for de-linting etc so don't miss the mini screwdriver really. :)
-
i have never had a need for a cork screw. worse, they don't feel right during normal use of an SAK. for that matter i have found no use for the hook on my super tinker but at least it's out of the way. the corkscrew looks and feels uncomfortable to me.
-
Through my entire life I can not recall ever needing or having used a corkscrew. Phillips for me all the way!
2xTap
-
Myself, I prefer the corkscrew. Whether for yourself, a friend, or a fine lady, it's always nice to be able to pop open a nice bottle of wine!
-
Hi
I was going to start a new thread on this topic - Then found this one - So started a reply.
.... Then the forum told me I should consider a new thread as this is so old!
However - The post has to be here - As it is all about this topic.However I do prefer the titlle I was going to use: Are you a Tinker or a Drinker?
Corkscrew for me - Ever since I used to go to student parties and no-one ever had a corkscrew.
I was the most popular guy at every party I attended.
Most other reasons have already been posted.I started collecting SAKs only this year and of course had to get a Tinker.
I already prefered the Corkscrew - But really wanted to give the Phillips a chance...
However I find the backtool Phillips pretty difficult to use.-
The head does not always seem to fit the screws very well
-
It's difficult to apply pressure
-
Spinning the screw (and tool) once the screw is loose is very very awkward
-
You cannot get in tight places
So Inline Phillips for me always - Which has none of these problems
I managed to pick up a very nice Woodsman recently....
Its quite wide - But I get all the tools of my beloved Hunstman.
Plus the Magnifying Glass and an In-Line Phillips :)Of course wine bottles with corkscrews are becoming less and less common these days
- However if you ever need a corkscrew what else can you use (easily and neatly!).
And as per this post - There are many other uses for the Corkscrew.
And one final word - As some of you have pointed out
- The Corkscrew pretty much defined the original 'Officers Knife' - So you have to have one on your SAK!
-
-
Just make a new thread!
If you're scared ask Def for permission or something. :D -
That's some necro thread but we're fine with that.

I'm drinker by that definition.
Only own one SAK with a backlayered phillips. All the others have a corkscrew, as any proper SAK. should. :P -
I like thread resurrections so this gets a
from me.I prefer to have the corkscrew just because I really hate using backside tools. You can't get half decent pressure on them, and they almost always close on you.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Mostly I am a drinker, then, as I generally prefer the corkscrew.

The fact that the corkscrew holds the eyeglass screwdriver is yet another point in its favor.
The only exception to this is my current work EDC, a Centurion. I actually do get enough use of the back spring phillips at work to make it worth having, and no one is allowed to drink wine there anyway, so...
-
I'm a tinker, so I carry one (deluxe). I drink cheap beer and expensive scotch - don't need corkscrew for either.
Rich
-
Im very clumsy, that Philips folded on me a couple of times. Id go with the Drinker group.
-
Although there are reports that phillips are not strong enough to be useful, I still will choose the phillips over the corkscrew. Felt more comfortable to hold the tool and I rarely drink.
-
Of course the phillips, but only the old one with nailfile. ;-)
-
Tinker for me,the CS is handy for holding the micro screwdriver but never actually use the CS,the tinker is my favourite lightweight sak options
nice resurrection 
-
Corkscrew all the way

The CS opens wine bottles, untangles knots, and holds the little precision driver, and you can tackle many of the screws the Phillips can handle with the can opener
-
Phillips!
Never used the CS for a cork,and Havnt even found the use for the micro driver on those SAKs I carry that do have a CS
-
The Phillips is more useful than the corkscrew.
-
I'd say Phillips but you can't really crack down on the back tools
-
I would have to go with the corkscrew, even though I never need it for wine bottles, and all it really does is hold the mini driver. However, it is potentially more useful in misc ways in comparison to the phillips. Plus, the phillips isn't easy to use as a back spring tool. It's hard to get into tighter spaces and turning it can be clumsy at times. The inline is much better :D
-
Neither! Viva alox 93s!
In my opinion the only backtool on a 91 that makes sense is the awl. But thats inline on an alox.. so.. I dont have much use for T handled tools. I know some people actually use the corkscrew, but Ive never had a need.
If anyone has phillips backside tools they wish were corkscrews, Id happily mod those for free. :D I have about 10 million corkscrews, but much prefer having the phillips for mods.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

