New PST
-
If you've added your name to the PST petition,here's your chance to have your say as to what you'd like!
For me,I'd like a lock free Pulse.
-
I'm glad you started this thread John, as I didn't want to smurf up the other one. (For future proofing HERE is the other thread)
I've NOT voted in the other thread, but need a place to say ...Reality check! ..... WHY? WHY? WHY? :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
Other than the nostalgic feel, what are the redeeming features or aspects that you (everyone who wants a new PST) feel have been lost and are trying to rekindle here? To me the tool had it's place in time, and that place in time has gone. Here's my appraisal of the tool now that we have other options at our disposal, which might help explain my confusion ...
<u>Slim and lightweight</u> - ***Excellent ***factors if the tool integrity isn't compromised

<u>Inboard tools</u> - Always a disadvantage. Makes knives and saws less efficient and harder to work with on certain tasks as the opposing handle is an unwanted obstacle. Outboard tools are quicker and more efficient in use
<u>Ergonomics</u> - If you have a prolongued task to do, or are working with cold/tired hands, you need something that isn't going to add to the fatigue and discomfort. The PST format is notoriously uncomfortable, and is going to make the tasks harder to achieve, or worse - less safe - in a shorter time. Unfortunately ergonomics starts bulking up that slim profile and the additional materials mean additional weight
<u>Non-Locking tools</u> - OK that might sound odd coming from a Brit who thinks slippies are great and liner/frame locks are evil - but what about drivers, awls, and saw blades in sticky resinous materials. Tools CAN be fantastic without locks - just look at the 91mm SAK - but is this what you <u>all</u> want to see repeated? Remember locks add bulk, weight and complexity to the tool - so marginally bigger, heavier, and potentially more to go wrong
Everything that makes the tool great (size, weight, and simplicity) is also what makes the tool awful ...

I don't want to try and talk you guys out of what you'd love to see, I DO want to try and tune in to what you're looking for and see if there's a better way of doing it. After all, you're asking for a *NEW *PST, so you're obviously expecting some changes from the *OLD *PST.
For example: I personally think there may be potential for a PST/Juice hybrid - two tools I don't like, but which have merits we could learn from to make something good. Get the tools on the outside. Ditch the "bridge section" liner with anodised alu scale covers, and lets see some G10 or even FRN - it works for knives, there is no reason that with inginuity it couldn't work here. It keeps the colours (people friendly appearance) and lightness, and reduces manufacturing (and therefore retail) costs. Aim for the same tool density of the PST/Vic Spirit - pack 'em in tight to keep that space down. No indexable inserts which need reinforcing shoulders on the plier heads bulking up size and weight as per the newer tools - just a simple plier head shape of old. Good reliable backsprings keep the locks away but add weight, locks means it's not as unversally acceptable as well as adding space/weight/cost/room for failure, and the old "split frame" spring worked! Use the Schrade/old Supertool type lock, where there's a void in the spring plat to "latch" the tool - but NOT on the knife blades, all it takes is let the tang of the critical tools ride a solid section of that spring. Keep the knives two hand opening and non-locking and you maximise the amount of people who can use the tool. Keep it simple, reliable, ergonomic and affordable, and you maximise the amount of people who want the tool
There is potentially something there I could vote for (buy), but lets not just accept the awful aspects of the old ways, just for nostalgia. Bringing back the PST would be pointless! Embracing folks' needs and desires for something simple, honest, effective, reliable, cheap, legal, slim, lightweight, crowd friendly, WITHOUT having inefficient inboard tools, sore hands, and spontaneously folding drivers and awls is what gets my vote. Oh, and ditch the marketting BS - if the tool isn't good enough without hype and propaganda, send it back to the drawing board, don't sell us a load of horse crap to cover it up

End rant!
(Sorry Kirky Boy ... I had to)

-
The only thing I never liked about the original PST was that it wasn't very comfortable to use in plier mode. This would be fixed by having the tools open from the outside, so that when in plier mode you'd get smooth handles.
I did like how slim the original was though, great tool.
-
Hmmm, an outside opening PST, that I would buy in a heart beat.
Sent from my iPhone 5 using Tapatalk
-
No worries Al,as usual your
is well thought out and valid.For me,my desire for a new PST of some type goes as follows:
- The PST 2 has a near perfect tool set,with minimal redundancy.
- with the Pulse style rolled handles,the PST's biggest weakness is undone(ie it won't slice into your hands when applying pressure to the pliers
- I've no issue with locking tools,as long as I've a bladeless option in the range,or a modable chassis(unlike the proxy Rebar)
- An updated or improved PST has just got to be better than the Wingman/Sidekick.
-
non locking pulse...done and done.
id be down for an outside opening pst too
-
Excellent thread! Keep the ideas rolling! :D

-
PST - no saw, no scissors, no serrated blade, plenty of flat drivers
PST 2 - no saw, no awl, combo blade, abundant flat drivers
Neither has replaceable wire cutters. Both hurt the hands. No locks. To be honest, aside from nostalgia and a better finish (polished), I fail to see the appeal of a return to that.
This is what you'd like to see the Rebar replaced with? Really? Why? If the Rebar had the old style polish and perhaps a slightly thicker PE blade, it'd be the best thing they have ever made (in my opinion of course). The ST300 with polish would also meet that level for me. Hell, throw a scissor option on the Rebar if you must ala Spirit.
But replace it with a new PST? Isn't that what the Rebar is? How about we petition for an even better Rebar?
I'm confused here. Unless there just is a massive amount of MT users that just so happen to dislike saws, awls, locks, and love combo blades.
-shrug-
Maybe I'm out of touch.
-
Classic for me please. :)
-
In fairness to the naysayers,I've added a no option to the poll :D
-
All options for keeping it were inboard, so I had to say "rust in peace" ;)
-
I am a naysayer. My thinking is much like 50ft-trad...if you change the old design..it is no longer a PST. Lucky for anyone, there were so many PSTs made over its life that you can easily find them anywhere.
-
@Chako said:
if you change the old design..it is no longer a PST. Lucky for anyone, there were so many PSTs made over its life that you can easily find them anywhere.That is (both) true! But they could offer a PST 3 with the tools of the Pulse for example and upgrade the blade steel to AUS8/440C/154CM or anything like that. The design of the handles stays as it is/was.
But to be honest, such a version would only be interesting for collectors and I guess it wouldn´t sell well. ::)
-
Although I already have 2 PSTs. I would buy a new release of the original despite all of its' "faults".
-
Rust in peace vote here too. :-\
On the other hand a knifeless, fileless, basically toolless Mini. Just the full sized pliers with foldable handles, that I'd like. :D Sounds a bit nuts but it would pair nicely with a full sized SAK. ;)
-
classic, with a drop point knife!
-
I'm not sure what to vote here. Initially, I was all for bringing it back, but after reading the logical arguments here, I must say I'm not sure anymore. I think nostalgia would be the biggest factor for me, yet as someone else pointed out, we can get PSTs fairly easily, and for cheap in a lot of cases (depending on desired condition of course). The Rebar is basically a modern PST I would say. One thing the PST lacks is a saw, and while I may rarely use it, I do like to have one in my MTs that I carry just in case. I carry the Ranger Plus with my PST to cover the saw, but I would still prefer a tool like that to be on a MT. I also prefer locking tools, especially when it comes to the drivers, although the pivot-out drivers are an improvement.
As Al said, adding locks and better ergonomics will only add bulk/weight to the PST, and part of what I like about it is that very slim profile and light weight. I don't use my MTs heavily, so the primary gripes with the PST aren't a major deal to me for the most part. I happen to really like the original, and I have my doubts that Leatherman would re-release it with that same classic level of quality unfortunately.
So in closing, the more I think about it, I guess my vote would be letting it remain retired. Perhaps as someone else mentioned, they could focus on improving the Rebar. It's one of my faves, and one issue to me is the thinner blades. The PST's blade is thicker and just feels more solid to me.
-
I too agree with Al on this one. Like he says it had its time and place.
For me personally I'd like to see a real heavy duty MT - Surge proportions but built using exotic alloys to keep the weight down. And...and most important of all (for me anyway) proper blunt nose pliers. I would pay good money for a good tool that was fully dependable in real life situations. I'm damn well sure leatherman has gained enough knowledge and expertise to design and build such a tool. Why they don't is anyone's guess.As for the PST??? I'm almost sure that most on here could cannabilse various leathermans to create their perfect PST III.
-
Classics are classics for a reason.
There's no way they could bring back the PST/ make a PST3 without angering fans. It's best for everyone to just let it "rust in peace", imo.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
).