Intro and Question
-
Welcome aboard!
@majinalchemy said:
I was wondering how common it is or how hard it is to close a nonlocking blade on your hand and cut it up or your fingers.With proper knife handling and maintenance, it would be very difficult to close a non-locking blade on your hand or fingers. With poor technique, it is easy.
edited to add:
@majinalchemy said:
Let's say I open the cadet and stab a slab of granite as hard as I can, would the force go into the tip of the knife or would it close on my hand?The answer depends on the angle at which the blade strikes the granite and the amount of force used.
-
Come on guys - SAKs just aren't meant as rock cutters. Use them for what they were
designed - general, utility knives, not rock cutters - for that use a steel chisel. In proper
use a SAK won't normally close up on you. Also, keep it sharp - it cuts easier. A dull
knife requires more force and therefore is more likely to close up and/or break.Also, when using a "stabbing/punchering" action always do it with any horizontal
force on the blade back against the backspring. Less likely to close up on you.
Of course you can always get a lockback SAK.Rich
-
welcome to the mad house ! pop in to the 'new members forum' and intro. yourself , we like personal details (being nosy b***ers ::))
and Rule #1 please don't stab rocks ....with anything !!! lol -
Welcome to our little corner of the internet!
That is a nice collection you've got there. I can tell you're an enthusiast because you've chosen some models that are popular mostly with collectors, rather than the general public: Manager, Evo S14, and Cadet spring immediately to mind.
I think most of us like to rotate them out, though sometimes, we get stuck in a rut with one model for many days or weeks at a time.
Check out the thread titles, and you'll see the huge thread where we comment on it.
Next up, I recommend you find either a Wenger or Victorinox old-style Soldier while they're still available. After that, maybe a locking Victorinox, like a (new) Soldier or One-handed Trekker NS.
Maybe a nice Explorer Plus or CyberTool 34...
Do yourself a favor now though: set your budget and stick to it or you'll be starving soon. ;)
@nate j said:
With proper knife handling, it would be very difficult to close a non-locking blade on your hand or fingers. With poor technique, it is easy.+1 to that ^
If we're going to get scientific, it would depend on the exact angle you stabbed the rock. If it was perfectly straight, you'd bend the tip. If it were angled one way, it would certainly fold up on you. If it were angled the other way, you'd dull it and bend the tip.
When you're using your knife blade to push through something, like cardboard, just angle the blade slightly with the sharp edge more toward the cardboard, and it will not fold.
For what it's worth, the only times I've had a non-locking SAK close on me were:
- When I was closing the blade with a finger while holding the knife in the same hand, and not having all of my fingers 100% clear. Specifically, I tried to close the small blade with my index finger while holding the knife with my ring and pinky fingers. But the ring finger was not 100% clear, so as the blade snapped closed, it sliced clean through. I felt stupid and bloody that day.
- When I was doing some spirited cutting of cardboard boxes one day, and I pulled the knife blade out of the cardboard, I didn't have it angled right. I was pulling against the backspring, instead of straight out, and the main blade closed part-way. It didn't bite me that time.
Learn from my mistakes.
-
New here my self, welcome.
As long as you use the tools as intended you shouldn't have to worry about any tool closing on you. The springs tension on even well warn in tools, well warn in, is usual more than stout enough to keep them in place. Even during pretty heavy use from my experience.You don't stab boulders or rocks or slabs of granite... You might break the tip. :)
-
I have to agree with what most say here. If you use it properly, you "shouldn't" get hurt. When I was 12 years old my uncle gave me my first SAK. I was using it to cut something, I don't remember exactly what it was. The blade closed on the tip of my thumb and sliced all the way down to the bone. I still have the scar 23 years later. Even to this day, I'm always aware of how I'm using a SAK.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N900A using Tapatalk
-
Why would you want to abuse a knife in such a way? I'm appalled at the question. And as for slip joints, there is always that possibility of them closing up on your fingers but then again, they're not meant for stabbing objects either.
-
I think it was a 'hypothetical' question ! (or at least hope it was
) -
I'm fairly certain it was a hypothetical. I doubt he's interested in stabbing granite, but gave the most extreme example to illustrate the curiosity. For folks who aren't too versed in slipjoints, that question is normal. It looks like Smaug explained it the best. I was going to try using some photos, but after reading the information here I really don't think it's necessary.
Welcome to the fun-land! I love this place, as I'm sure you will. You need to get some more alox SAKs in your posesssion...start off with a black Vic Pioneer, it will open your eyes to the glory of the 93mm SAKlandia.


-
Welcome - solid collection! I think the others have covered your question well - you probably wouldn't use a SAK, or even a heavy duty Leatherman for that matter, to stab, cut, or slice any kind of rock. Best to use a tool specifically designed for that application.
-
If you are looking to stab rock, use a proper chisel and don't forget some kind of eye protection

-
@majinalchemy said:
(...)Let's say I open the cadet and stab a slab of granite as hard as I can, would the force go into the tip of the knife or would it close on my hand?I sincerely hope it would close, so as to cut off your fingers and thus prevent you from again doing something as senseless as trying to kill an inanimated object.

Could we see pictures of the attempt?...
8) -
If you are looking to stab rock, use a proper chisel and don't forget some kind of eye protection

You're thinking about stabing The Rock with that?! Good luck...

-
Lol.. I thought the "Let's say I..." part was clearly hypothetical, extreme examples are the best kind. From reading here, a good solution seems to be whenever you're using the tip instead of the sharp edge, tilt it a little anyway so the force going into it keeps it open.
-
greetings and welcome,
slip joints have been used for some time now and can be quite hardy tho its happened even lock blades can fail so use caution. such a nice collection and some great color choices.
-
I've had an issue with the non-loking Leatherman Kick when I was cutting cable ties tight on to scaffolding - it can be quite hard to predict what the blade's going to do, especially if you're doing it without thinking, in a hurry whilst very tired.
If you're thinking, awake and careful you shouldn't have problems. If not, you might!
-
(...)Let's say I open the cadet and stab a slab of granite as hard as I can, would the force go into the tip of the knife or would it close on my hand?
I sincerely hope it would close, so as to cut off your fingers and thus prevent you from again doing something as senseless as trying to kill an inanimated object.

Could we see pictures of the attempt?...
8)+1
:D :DIn normal use, you'll be fine. If used stupidly you deserve to be hurt >:D
-
If you do something grossly stupid with a knife, you will get cut. Period. I wouldn't stab granite with a fixed blade.
I know this is hypothetical. And that's fine. But it illustrates the point that you must respect any blade and use it with care and in a manner appropriate to it's design.
I don't fret over using a slip joint because I don't use them in ways I shouldn't. I have some with such strong springs that I can't imagine what foolishness I would have to engage in to close the blade on my fingers. My Douk Douk comes to mind. As does my Flair.
I don't use locking blades with any greater sense of safety to be honest. Anything I might do that would cause a strong spring to slip could just as easily break or disengage a lock.
The only thing I could see someone doing with a knife that would be forceful enough to cause such a thing is stabbing. Hit a bone.. and..
But I don't have stabbing knives. At least I don't use them for that. Maybe you do. If so, I recommend you do all your stabbing with a fixed blade or at least a locking folder. Do not stab with a SAK.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
