Ethics of modding
-
I'm not much of a modder, so my opinion my not carry the same 'weight'.
Making a Yeoman, and selling it as a modded model is 100% fine.
Making a Yeoman, and selling it as an original Yeoman is perpetrating fraud, in my opinion.
Making e Yeoman, and selling it without SAYING one way or the other is... gray, morally. But I'd put it more toward the 'fraud' side.
-
I'm not a SAK modifier, but that's just fraudulent regardless of the specific item. Passing off a custom configuration as a factory original (which should then have factory warranty) is dangerous ground, and I'd also want no part of it. I also tend to shy away from business dealings with folks who use the phrase "big bucks" seriously. That's a personal preference, as it just creeps me out a bit.
I'd say you did the right thing.
-
I would have acted the same.
If I do sell something, I state the condition clear and truthful. I mention mods (as frar as i know of) or differences from the stock configuration. I have not that much experience with (modded) tools or SAKs, but have sold an bought my fair share of bikes and parts.
Morally, I think not mentioning it is a mod is fraud. It might be ok legally.
Sometimes you make less money that way, but I fell it´s the right way.
My Grandpa told me to treat people like I would like to be treated.
And while not everyone will treat you in the same manner, I try hard to stand by that. -
Sounds similar to a scenario involving me a friend and his overpriced shoes.
As far as this goes, no it' not acceptable. Sounds like a D bag move.
People are always trying to get over on people...Why I trust no one.Piecing together a SAK for $10, heck no!
Skill cost money. This person was wasting your time.
Tell him do it himself...Douche! -
You did the right thing. Good job!
sent from Nate's mobile
-
I agree with the others; you did the right thing. That bloke sounds like a bit of a t**t, for whatever my opinion is worth.
Sent from my nex s, using squiffy tart 4
-
I think it's plain and simple fraud. I couldn't consciously do that kind of modding. You, Sir, have good morals

-
If there was a big demand for a SAK with the configuration of a Yeoman I'd have no problem modding and selling them, with full disclosure that it was a modded knife. But I'd consider anyone who sold a modded knife as a genuine Yeoman to be a crook deserving of burning in the fire of a thousand suns.
-
yes, I agree with your call, good job.
I also want a yeoman config, but I do not want to pay teh price for a real one and get a custom.
I do not mind a custom, but I do not want to pretend it is real either
-
I made that exact mod last week for myself. If someone wanted to buy one from me knowing it was a mod fine. However to pass it off as an original would be wrong. In short yes you did the right thing.
Sent from my Hudl HT7S3 using Tapatalk
-
This is why I think people are crazy for buying a Scientist or Yeoman from ebay with out a box. The chances of it being an original are good, but not guaranteed. I sold a Yeoman I bought in a pile of crap knives for $60. I didn't make it but, I was also not taking the scales off to find out if it was a mod or not. Out of all the scales I have popped off, I can say I have seen 5 repairs or mods.
-
Its exactly this that makes me shy away from online purchases.
So let me thank you for not enabling that douche
. I think the only way to go is to declare a mod as what it is. -
@sawman said:
I think it's plain and simple fraud. I couldn't consciously do that kind of modding. You, Sir, have good morals
I could have picked any of the replies but this just says it for me.
It is nothing to do with the ethics of modding...it's the ethics of fraud (which is just a polite way of saying theft really)

-
@Metal Mickey said:
I think it's plain and simple fraud. I couldn't consciously do that kind of modding. You, Sir, have good morals

I could have picked any of the replies but this just says it for me.
It is nothing to do with the ethics of modding...it's the ethics of fraud (which is just a polite way of saying theft really)

I agree completely. You've done the decent thing.
It would be fraud in my eyes. I'm pretty sure it would be illegal under English law to sell it if you represented it as an original item. I'm not going to read the Forgery and Counterfeiting Act 1981, but I'd be surprised it that wouldn't make it an offence here. -
You did the right thing

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
-
"Making a Yeoman, and selling it as a modded model is 100% fine.
Making a Yeoman, and selling it as an original Yeoman is perpetrating fraud, in my opinion.
Making e Yeoman, and selling it without SAYING one way or the other is... gray, morally. But I'd put it more toward the 'fraud' side."
+1
-
This man was planning an illegal action (fraud) and it was good that you turned him down.

Seriously, modding a SAK voids the waranty and that alone should be enough reason for any seller to ever declare a mod or home-repair, imo.I have absolutely nothing against mods and like to try it out myself. But one should be aware of the cost!
-
I really enjoy the mods I own, they were done by others. They make make great casual saks with bonus tools. One thing that I have found over all of the mods is that the snap is usually affected in some way (especially in the alox mods). To me, this affects the safety of the knife as in my experience the positive pressure on the knife directly affects the ability of the knife staying open. This could be due to the missed tolerances on the scale hole and pinning technique. If I had to subject a sak to hard use, I would prefer a factory fresh knife as the snap and spring are undiminished.
I must state that all of the alox mods I have (from several different modders) are all peened, screwed alox may have higher performance- especially with Crackout's discovery that non countersinked screws have "monster snap." This would be akin to the bushings on the non alox models. Alas, screwed mods are a bit out of my budget, so I have no point of refernce.
Cheers
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

