Leatherman SIDEKICK / WINGMAN Owners Club
-
I think the Wingman is a great tool but compared to the mass numbers of other MTs we have, it doesn't stand much of a chance.
-
Just because it doesn't suit YOUR needs doesn't mean it doesn't meet other folks' needs, and at a great price,
In it's price range, I think it's an excellent tool. Are there tools with more features? Sure. And you pay for them. And if you don't NEED those features, then you're just paying for nothing useful.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Just because it doesn't suit YOUR needs doesn't mean it doesn't meet other folks' needs, and at a great price,In it's price range, I think it's an excellent tool. Are there tools with more features? Sure. And you pay for them. And if you don't NEED those features, then you're just paying for nothing useful.
+1

-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Just because it doesn't suit YOUR needs doesn't mean it doesn't meet other folks' needs, and at a great price,
In it's price range, I think it's an excellent tool. Are there tools with more features? Sure. And you pay for them. And if you don't NEED those features, then you're just paying for nothing useful.
+1

What they said. And a big fat
for ripping on my favorite multitool... :D -
@Lynn LeFey said:
Just because it doesn't suit YOUR needs doesn't mean it doesn't meet other folks' needs, and at a great price,
In it's price range, I think it's an excellent tool. Are there tools with more features? Sure. And you pay for them. And if you don't NEED those features, then you're just paying for nothing useful.
+1

What they said. And a big fat
for ripping on my favorite multitool... :DThat's right!

-
@CanadianLMfan said:
I think the Wingman is a great tool but compared to the mass numbers of other MTs we have, it doesn't stand much of a chance.Maybe as a direct comparison, from people like us (MT nuts), no. I don't have one yet, but will be getting one in the near future. Will it be as well made as my SwissTool? No. Will it get more carry time? More than likely it will. It may even getting more carry time than my favorite carry, my TTi.
For the market it's aimed at, I think it stands the best chance.@Lynn LeFey said:
Just because it doesn't suit YOUR needs doesn't mean it doesn't meet other folks' needs, and at a great price,In it's price range, I think it's an excellent tool. Are there tools with more features? Sure. And you pay for them. And if you don't NEED those features, then you're just paying for nothing useful.
Quoted for truth.

-
I think the Wingman is a great tool but compared to the mass numbers of other MTs we have, it doesn't stand much of a chance.
Maybe as a direct comparison, from people like us (MT nuts), no. I don't have one yet, but will be getting one in the near future. Will it be as well made as my SwissTool? No. Will it get more carry time? More than likely it will. It may even getting more carry time than my favorite carry, my TTi.
For the market it's aimed at, I think it stands the best chance.I agree Derek. I find it funny that of all the MTs I have, the cheapest and probably lowest quality (in comparison to the others, but still good quality imo), is the one I have carried the most out of any of them. I never expected that the Wingman would up-end my whole rotation. I expect that once I have the Sidekick, these two MTs will be my primary rotational carry, each paired with a SAK of course. I feel bad about not carrying my other two faves, the Rebar and Spirit, more frequently, but I just can't deny the convenience of the OHO blade and basic design. I prefer how they carry clipped in one of my back pockets as I don't feel the weight.
-
I cant see the issues with these mt's, as ive said before,its pretty much does all i need a mt for plus its not a bad looking thing,will it replace my surge at work nope,will it get carried more than my other plier based mt's yep,i class myself as a mt/SAK nut and for the great price i dont think this has many rivals,oh the gerber suspension

-
Just wait till the driver folds on you, then come talk how great it is .

-
@colt 1911 said:
Just wait till the driver folds on you, then come talk how great it is .
That would be my main potential issue, as I do prefer locking tools. However, I don't really use them enough to the point that it would happen enough to become an annoyance issue for me. While they don't exactly lock, they do snap into place fairly solidly, at least for my use so far
I know I used to consider myself to really need locking drivers, etc., and that was my main gripe with the PST, but those don't snap into place as solidly as the Wingman's tools (or at least that's the case for me). As always though, everyones' usage varies, and not all can get along with non-locking tools, especially if you use them frequently. -
@colt 1911 said:
Just wait till the driver folds on you, then come talk how great it is .
Hey they dont lock so expect that now and then,my original wave does it paratool plus its pliers,kick,and many more hence why my surge is my work mt,mt's are to get you out of a jam not as good as a dedicated tool but handy when needed

-
@Zed said:
[quote author=colt 1911 link=topic=32239.msg812111#msg812111 date=1386609062]
Just wait till the driver folds on you, then come talk how great it is .
Hey they dont lock so expect that now and then,my original wave does it paratool plus its pliers,kick,and many more hence why my surge is my work mt,mt's are to get you out of a jam not as good as a dedicated tool but handy when needed

[/quotOh I understand completely, they just are not for me. There sure is a market for them.
Swiss Army knives .
-
@colt 1911 said:
Just wait till the driver folds on you, then come talk how great it is .
I guess this means we throw out the PST as well? It must be useless, the tools don't lock... right?
However... The retention on the Sidekick/Wingman seems to be considerably stronger than on the PSTs I've had, and all but the oldest PST have drivers designed to push the tool OPEN under pressure.
No, wait. Here's a better idea. I'll test it.
Here's the Sidekick's flat driver after being pressed into pine with about 100lbs of force (makes about a 1/8 inch dent)(EDIT: probably closer to 75lbs, see below). It didn't collapse, until I TRIED to make it collapse by pulling it the wrong way, then it... hit against the other handle. No problem. That, under what I'd call ABSURD levels of force.

So, under WAY more force than I'd ever put on a screwdriver, while INTENTIONALLY TRYING to get it to collapse, I succeeded, with no ill effect whatsoever. I'm calling that a complete BS argument. Sorry.
EDIT: trying this against a block of wood on my bathroom scale, I was able to get a reading of 118lbs of force.
EDIT part II: Also, I don't recommend trying this. it's like trying to do a pushup onto a screwdriver point. My palms are all bruised and mangled now.
-
Wow, great impromptu test there Lynn
I doubt any of us should be applying that much force on any screw with any multitool as they aren't necessarily designed/intended for that (at least I assume so anyway). -
I COULD get the driver to collapse on that second test, just by flipping it to face a different direction, but then it also just safely hit the other side of the tool. My first measurement on the pressure was around 75lbs, which is about what felt like my first trial (not the 100 lbs I reported). But yeah, it held open at 118lbs, and that was a stupid amount of force that no one will actually ever apply to a screw. Maybe if you were trying to wedge something, but even then, not likely.
However, at anything like reasonable forces, it held solid.
Now that I'm thinking back on it... geez, I put over 100lbs of force on that joint pin. Wow. I'm impressed.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I COULD get the driver to collapse on that second test, just by flipping it to face a different direction, but then it also just safely hit the other side of the tool. My first measurement on the pressure was around 75lbs, which is about what felt like my first trial (not the 100 lbs I reported). But yeah, it held open at 118lbs, and that was a stupid amount of force that no one will actually ever apply to a screw. Maybe if you were trying to wedge something, but even then, not likely.However, at anything like reasonable forces, it held solid.
Now that I'm thinking back on it... geez, I put over 100lbs of force on that joint pin. Wow. I'm impressed.
Thanks for the testing Lynn
I think that helps show that these two tools aren't just throwaway entry level MTs. Certainly not heavy duty MTs, but they seem capable of handling the type of work for which a MT is intended 
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I COULD get the driver to collapse on that second test, just by flipping it to face a different direction, but then it also just safely hit the other side of the tool. My first measurement on the pressure was around 75lbs, which is about what felt like my first trial (not the 100 lbs I reported). But yeah, it held open at 118lbs, and that was a stupid amount of force that no one will actually ever apply to a screw. Maybe if you were trying to wedge something, but even then, not likely.
However, at anything like reasonable forces, it held solid.
Now that I'm thinking back on it... geez, I put over 100lbs of force on that joint pin. Wow. I'm impressed.
Thanks for the testing Lynn
I think that helps show that these two tools aren't just throwaway entry level MTs. Certainly not heavy duty MTs, but they seem capable of handling the type of work for which a MT is intended 
+1 :D
-
I also noticed the design of the tool is such that the drivers are on the shorter handle. IF they collapse, they don't fold as far, and never get near your hand. The tools on the longer side will fold farther, but except for the small flat driver are tools that you'd never put force on that would cause a collapse. They're being pressed open in their function. And one would assume the small flat driver won't be subjected to massive force loads, so no huge concern.
It's a pretty fail-safe setup.
-
It is a smart design now that you mention it. I never really paid attention to that, but it's another good point

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
