Gerbers are C-R-A-P !!!!!!! (A warning for Flik fans)
-
I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on Gerber then, i like them you don't :)
But there is this:
/topic/4867 that is a run of Leatherman's top end tool with quite a big problem, so leatherman aren't all good. -
The thing you've got to remember is that most of the MT manufactures make the odd foul up (apart from Vic obviously, but then they've had more practice than all the others). It would be a shame to dismiss the whole Gerber line, have a play with a MP series tool, and you'll see there not at all bad :)
-
My opinion for what its worth: Gerber is starting to reap what it has sewn.
After years of producing some damn fine multitools based on the 400 and the 600 frames, right here in the US of A, there has been a corporate decision to move production to east Asia. As such, the quality once associated with Gerber's good name has suffered. Already a new Gerber knife or tool does not command the premium price folks used to be willing to pay. It will only get worse if they do not overhaul their poor quality Chinese products and cheap designs.
-
J-Sews has it right. I can be seen once and a while as a gerber hater. However it sems to only be the China made products. I have yet to have my MP 600 fail at anything and the tool is most likely the most abused tool that I own. I just feel that the USA made ones are the only ones that seem to have a quality control person that knows what to look for.
-
E-mail sent.
I wasn't nearly as "direct" as I was planning to be (flies and honey vs. vinegar and all that), but I did "firmly" get the point accross.
I'll keep you posted...
-
I am sorry for your luck with the Gerber.I think that all the brands have a glitch or two with their products.
I hope everything works out for you.
Dtrain
-
@EM745 said:
The green outline shows the undamaged side. The red one shows a couple of TINY little indentations left by the pawl. As you can see, it's not much. But it's more than enough to allow the pawl to slip, rendering the pliers virtually useless.yes its a complex design and probably has a few bugs in it but thats what you get for pushing your designs forward.
Seems to me that this is a design that was "pushed" to market about 6 months too early. Given the high forces those little notches must endure even during moderate squeezing, they should've made them out of a separate piece of HARD stainless, and then bolted them onto the main pliers casting.
Thanks EM745, for an excellent description and clear photos of this failure.
I almost ordered a Flik, but decided to wait a while longer to see more MTO reports on how they were working out.
Didn't realize the Flik design was so complex - which in itself provides more failure modes.
I agree that the Flik looks as if it might have been rushed into production without sufficient durability testing. If more people report this same failure we'll know that was the case. It could be that your Flik's failure was due to a manufacturing defect that is relatively uncommon.
.
-
@EM745 said:
The green outline shows the undamaged side. The red one shows a couple of TINY little indentations left by the pawl. As you can see, it's not much. But it's more than enough to allow the pawl to slip, rendering the pliers virtually useless.yes its a complex design and probably has a few bugs in it but thats what you get for pushing your designs forward.
Seems to me that this is a design that was "pushed" to market about 6 months too early. Given the high forces those little notches must endure even during moderate squeezing, they should've made them out of a separate piece of HARD stainless, and then bolted them onto the main pliers casting.
Thanks EM745, for an excellent description and clear photos of this failure.
I almost ordered a Flik, but decided to wait a while longer to see more MTO reports on how they were working out.
Didn't realize the Flik design was so complex - which in itself provides more failure modes.
I agree that the Flik looks as if it might have been rushed into production without sufficient durability testing. If more people report this same failure we'll know that was the case. It could be that your Flik's failure was due to a manufacturing defect that is relatively uncommon.
.
After reading EM's initial post, I took my Flik and repeatedly squeezed the snot out of it. No problems whatsoever.
However I do agree that the mechanism is overly complex and delicate. A great deal of plier force is bearing on two very tiny components. :(
-
Gerbers are largely made up of castings which, in my experience, just don't hold up. Castings are great for making complex shapes but have the distinct disadvantage of not being work-hardened like stampings and forgings. This aspect of their design/manufacturing is a weakness no matter which country its built in. I gave my early 'made-in-the-good-old-USA' Gerber away for this reason (yes, this was a problem even in the USA-built models).
-
Castings are great for making complex shapes but have the distinct disadvantage of not being work-hardened like stampings and forgings.
Casting does not negate the ability to harden the steel properly. There are a few different ways to accomplish this with fairly similar results depending on the beginning material. The problem is we don't know if Gerber is hardening the cast items or how they are doing it.
Comparing my MP series and Diesel/Freehand to other tools I think that they are about on par with the industry standard for use of casting.
As near as I can tell on the MP series the only cast items are the plier head, philips driver and maybe the saw coupler. These items are typically cast by other manufacturers as well. On the Diesel/Freehand the only obvious cast parts are the plier heads, the rest of the implements appear to be stamped and finished.
I think the problem is not the production method since any given method can be used to produce a fairly equal level of strength in our use. The problem is most likely different steel composition and heat treatment (or lack thereof.) Nobody knows for sure what Gerber is doing to their steel or what exactly it is made of, this information has proven to be almost impossible to obtain from other manufacturers as well. Another issue with the "felt strength" of Gerber implements may be the fact that the MP series is significantly wider than comparative tools, allowing the user to exert more torque on the implements, creating more bent and broken drivers compared to the reasonably thinner tools.
Remember that casting in production is a tried and true method for producing tough, uniform shapes. Turrets for tanks were cast throughout WW2 and certain parts of armor are still cast today.
Overall I would be remiss to relegate the higher-end Gerber tools to the junk drawer. I have used them extensively and have had no issues with the tools due to construction or materials used.
Then again, I'm fairly lucky. ;)
-
It's a shame to see ALL of Gerbers products rubbished again down to another breakage. :( All tools can break and every brand has the odd dodgy tool every now and then, but I don't think Gerber should be intantly ruled out because of it.
I'm with Roadie on this one, Gerber DO make some good tools. :)
-
@Spoonrobot said:
......Then again, I'm fairly lucky. ;)This coming from the guy who Fragged his Charge..... ::) :D

-
......Then again, I'm fairly lucky. ;)
This coming from the guy who Fragged his Charge..... ::) :D

I've not seen this pic before , so thats another bust charge then .
Dunc
-
@Benner said:
It's a shame to see ALL of Gerbers products rubbished again down to another breakage. :( All tools can break and every brand has the odd dodgy tool every now and then, but I don't think Gerber should be intantly ruled out because of it.I'm with Roadie on this one, Gerber DO make some good tools. :)
Your right and I agree with you but I'm still glad I chose a Spirit over the Flick ( I came so close to getting one ) .
Dunc
-
It's a shame to see ALL of Gerbers products rubbished again down to another breakage. :( All tools can break and every brand has the odd dodgy tool every now and then, but I don't think Gerber should be intantly ruled out because of it.
I'm with Roadie on this one, Gerber DO make some good tools. :)
Your right and I agree with you but I'm still glad I chose a Spirit over the Flick ( I came so close to getting one ) .
Dunc
TBH, I would (and will) do exactly the same thing, but that isn't because I have been put off of Gerber because they are apparently all "crap".
-
Yes, but not only did I not get dinged in the eye but I was able to find both pieces of the bit driver. A miracle considering how random their flight pattern was. ;)
so thats another bust charge then .
Pfft. I think it was the first reported Charge bit driver bust.
-
@Spoonrobot said:
Yes, but not only did I not get dinged in the eye but I was able to find both pieces of the bit driver. A miracle considering how random their flight pattern was. ;)so thats another bust charge then .
Pfft. I think it was the first reported Charge bit driver bust.
So there have been more since then ;) and of course the springs flying off the holder .
Dunc
-
Sorry to hear about your bad luck with the Flik- and after you were so fond of it originally! I can see why you'd be disappointed.
I have to say, I was somewhat concerned about that with my Flik when I got it, and so I purposely gripped it as hard as I could in hopes of breaking it, and nothing happened. Yours may have been from an earlier run, a defective model, or your friend has much stronger hands than I do, because I didn't feel any weakness at all, let alone a catastrophic one like yours.
My suggestion is, get a replacement from Gerber (Fiskars) and trade it to someone else here for something you would like. It's unfortunate, but I seriously doubt Gerber will refund your money on it- warranties are designed so the companies don't have to put out any actual cash.
I still like the Flik, and I'll continue to use mine for medium duty tasks, but I will keep this in mind every time it clears the sheath. This is also why I wrote what I did last week about the SwissTool RS- simple, well made designs are their own reward.
Def
-
I agree with you 100% Def!

-
@Leatherman123 said:
I agree with you 100% Def!
Where was that butt kissing smilie again? :P
Only joking. ;)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



