Been done to death I know, but.......
-
I saw that film last night, well half of it.
Cast away (Tom Hanks).She asked me "which one of your "multys" would you need for that then" which basically ruined the film for me, as all I could think of was what she'd just asked.

I'm still undecided.
In the real world it wouldn't be a fire starter or an axe, would it??So, in that given situation what tool would have come up best. Don't say the one you had with you. Be a little more original please.
I'll go with the basic Surge, purely on the grounds of the spare file in the wallet to keep the saw sharp. Can't think of another standard tool that has such an accessory.
But would anyone seriously be edc-ing that beast.
-
Something by victorinox to resist rusting in salt water? :D
-
But would anyone seriously be edc-ing that beast.
Me.
sent from Nate's mobileYep me too

-
I'd take my Charge, I love my Vic swisstool but it is quite heavy and the weight would drag my trousers down as the seawater rotted my belt.

Seriously though, I don't EDC so I'd probably be in big trouble in the castaway situation.
-
I'd take that one that is built into an iPhone case so that I'd have a phone with me so I could call for help. After a suitable vacation on a deserted island of course.
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I'd take that one that is built into an iPhone case so that I'd have a phone with me so I could call for help. After a suitable vacation on a deserted island of course.Def
Sent from a digital multitool
Will there be any hula dancers there? I might volunteer.

-
Doh!! Silly me
There is only one and purpose built too.
The Vic SOS

Victorinox survival kit large (champ red)
Features Include:
Champ Knife - Sharpening Stone - Ruler (ins cm) - Pressure Pencil - Writing Paper - Knot Tying Guide and International Distress Signal - 3 Bandage Strips - Sewing Thread - 2 Sewing Needles - 5. Matches - 2 Safety Pins - 3M Nylon String - Signal Mirror - Compass with Spirit Level - MAGLITE Flashlight - Magnifying Glass - Thermometer - Small Fishing Kit - Comb - Tweezers - 2 Toothpicks - Distress Whistle. Complete in Black Leather pouch.A complete survival kit containing a SWISS CHAMP Swiss Army Knife combined with a Maglite Solitaire & a host of accessories all set in a double leather pouch.
- Large Blade
- Small Blade
- Corkscrew
- Can Opener
- Small Screwdriver
- Bottle Opener
- Large Screwdriver
- Wire Stripper
- Reamer Puncher & Sewing Eye
- Scissors
- Hook
- Wood Saw
- Fish Scaler Hook Disgorger & Ruler
- Nail File & Nail Cleaner
- Metal Saw & File
- Fine Screwdriver
- Phillips Screwdriver
- Magnifying Glass
- Ballpen
- Straight Pin
- Chisel
- Pliers & Wire Cutters
- Keyring
- Tweezers
- Toothpick
{Kit contents} -
- Maglite Solitaire Torch
- Thermometer (C & F)
- Liquid filled compass
- Spirit level
- Precision ruler (inches/cm)
- Magnifying Lens
- Pressure pencil
- Writing paper
- Knot tying guide
- Distress signal guide
- Signal mirror
- Distress whistle
- Small fishing kit
- Comb
- Spare tweezers
- 2 toothpicks
- 3 bandage strips
- Sewing threads
- 2 sewing neeedles
- 8 Matches
- 2 Safety pins
- 3 metre nylon string
What more does one need, I ask you.

-
I go with Def for my first choice :D but if the scenario is different, I would pick a MT with saw/blade and firestarter, like the +B farmer/firestarter or ToolLogic SL Pro with firesteel (although it doesn't have a saw...)
-
And remember that after his return when his (now ex) GF hands him the keys to his Jeep there's a SAK on it that he looks at with a sigh.
Other than that all I remember is that the ending was dumb.
-
I thought it was a great movie. (But then again, I think all Tom Hanks movies are great movies.) :D
Hmm, tough question though. On the one hand, if I were hopping a trans-pacific flight and DIDN'T know it was going to crash near a deserted island, I probably wouldn't have anything more useful than a pair of fingernail clippers on me. But on the other hand if I DID know my plane was going to touch down about 500 miles short of the runway, I probably wouldn't have gotten on it in the first place.
:DGuess I'll vote for the Surge though just to play along. Or maybe a SwissTool. Definitely something with pliers, a scissor, a knife, and a big saw.
-
I have never seen Philadelphia, Forrest Gump or Castaway. I think the last Tom Hanks movie I really liked was either Turner & Hooch (I liked the dog) or Bachelor Party. Ever since then I don't really find him all that funny. ::)
Although I might have been more tempted to watch Castaway had they not cut this scene.
Def
-
Of those I own?
Spirit X.
I also wouldn't feel terrible if all I had was my Farmer. Well... I mean, I'd feel terrible, but not tool-wise.
In that case, I might even go with the Bear Grylls Survival Tool Pack. Comes with ferro rod. The tool isn't my best, but getting fire on demand might trump anything else.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
In that case, I might even go with the Bear Grylls Survival Tool Pack. Comes with ferro rod. The tool isn't my best, but getting fire on demand might trump anything else.That was my first choice too Lynn, but then would I really be edc-ing one of those on a daily basis.
But as you rightly point out, it would be an ideal tool in such a scenario.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I have never seen Philadelphia, Forrest Gump or Castaway. I think the last Tom Hanks movie I really liked was either Turner & Hooch (I liked the dog) or Bachelor Party. Ever since then I don't really find him all that funny. ::)Although I might have been more tempted to watch Castaway had they not cut this scene.
Def

-
A Wenger Ranger with pliers and saw. Maybe the Mike Horn, but it has no saw! A Wenger Grip would be fine too i think!

-
Sorry no MT for me. All those screwdrivers and such are just weight. I take a lighter and a machete with a saw on the backside.
-
I think my mut or ranger 90 which i have always have one in my belt are more than up to the task. So if i would end up death with that its entirely my fault

Now i dont know whats more dangerous to your health, a deserted island or an island full of free drinks and ladies

-
@RamoN said:
I think my mut or ranger 90 which i have always have one in my belt are more than up to the task. So if i would end up death with that its entirely my fault
Now i dont know whats more dangerous to your health, a deserted island or an island full of free drinks and ladies

Well, there's only really one way to find out. I know it's risky, but if you'd like to conduct an experiment I would be happy to participate. If you want to take the deserted island, I would be prepared to take the island full of free drinks and ladies. All in the name of science of course.

I think I would take the SwissChamp. The magnifying glass would light my fire to cook the fish I prepared with the fish scaler. :D -
There is only one and purpose built too.
The Vic SOS

Victorinox survival kit large (champ red)
Features Include:
Champ Knife - Sharpening Stone - Ruler (ins cm) - Pressure Pencil - Writing Paper - Knot Tying Guide and International Distress Signal - 3 Bandage Strips - Sewing Thread - 2 Sewing Needles - 5. Matches - 2 Safety Pins - 3M Nylon String - Signal Mirror - Compass with Spirit Level - MAGLITE Flashlight - Magnifying Glass - Thermometer - Small Fishing Kit - Comb - Tweezers - 2 Toothpicks - Distress Whistle. Complete in Black Leather pouch.A complete survival kit containing a SWISS CHAMP Swiss Army Knife combined with a Maglite Solitaire & a host of accessories all set in a double leather pouch.
- Large Blade
- Small Blade
- Corkscrew
- Can Opener
- Small Screwdriver
- Bottle Opener
- Large Screwdriver
- Wire Stripper
- Reamer Puncher & Sewing Eye
- Scissors
- Hook
- Wood Saw
- Fish Scaler Hook Disgorger & Ruler
- Nail File & Nail Cleaner
- Metal Saw & File
- Fine Screwdriver
- Phillips Screwdriver
- Magnifying Glass
- Ballpen
- Straight Pin
- Chisel
- Pliers & Wire Cutters
- Keyring
- Tweezers
- Toothpick
{Kit contents} -
- Maglite Solitaire Torch
- Thermometer (C & F)
- Liquid filled compass
- Spirit level
- Precision ruler (inches/cm)
- Magnifying Lens
- Pressure pencil
- Writing paper
- Knot tying guide
- Distress signal guide
- Signal mirror
- Distress whistle
- Small fishing kit
- Comb
- Spare tweezers
- 2 toothpicks
- 3 bandage strips
- Sewing threads
- 2 sewing neeedles
- 8 Matches
- 2 Safety pins
- 3 metre nylon string
What more does one need, I ask you.
Beer.
sent from Nate's mobile
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




