Been done to death I know, but.......
-
@Taxi Dad said:
ok so it has a 'BOTTLE OPENER' ! but how would you 'de-scale fish' ?
Believe you me, you would eat the fish, all of it!!
And you'd be grateful too.The beauty of my shovel over his axe - is my ability to bury my number 2's :D
<u>Question</u>: Why do these types of scenarios always portray a somewhat wretched individual ??
All that glorious Vitamin D given in double dosage from the lovely sun and plentiful fish, add to that the unpolluted air and clean drinking water.....
The man should be nothing short of magnificent. With a complexion to die for not a complexion that died!!Its about time these film makers depicted reality, that's all I can say...........

-
@tosh said:
<u>Question</u>: Why do these types of scenarios always portray a somewhat wretched individual ??
All that glorious Vitamin D given in double dosage from the lovely sun and plentiful fish, add to that the unpolluted air and clean drinking water.....
The man should be nothing short of magnificent. With a complexion to die for not a complexion that died!!Its about time these film makers depicted reality, that's all I can say...........

The drinking water may be unpolluted in the traditional sense but it will be full of salt, so you'd need a solar still or similar. There also wouldn't be any access to MTO which would be pretty bad, and man cannot live on fish alone - some fruit or other fibre would be handy.
-
@Taxi Dad said:
ok so it has a 'BOTTLE OPENER' ! but how would you 'de-scale fish' ?

Believe you me, you would eat the fish, all of it!!
And you'd be grateful too.The beauty of my shovel over his axe - is my ability to bury my number 2's :D
<u>Question</u>: Why do these types of scenarios always portray a somewhat wretched individual ??
All that glorious Vitamin D given in double dosage from the lovely sun and plentiful fish, add to that the unpolluted air and clean drinking water.....
The man should be nothing short of magnificent. With a complexion to die for not a complexion that died!!Its about time these film makers depicted reality, that's all I can say...........

Well, here's a few fun facts:
- In survival settings (like proposed), caloric deficit is pretty much a constant.
- Safe drinking water is a priority
- Anything that can penetrate your skin is worth being really careful with. Infection in a wound can be a bitch without antibiotics.
- Cooking food is a safety concern. The last thing you want is to pick up a fish tape worm or Vibrio from your fresh caught sushi.
Well that's about it for now. Survivalism. It's less fun than it sounds.
-
What comes to mind for me are water, shelter, fire would be my priorities initially. I'd imagine with the amount of salt in the air and presumably that would get onto the "tool" and of course depending upon how long one was stranded most tool would eventually get pretty fouled up. I thought about what I typically carry so I'd end up with a Spirit on hand and that should be a comfort in some respects.
-
Well,considering I keep my SwissTool in my bug out bag already...
-
No one can survive in the wild indefinitely.<u> No matter how good you are, the pursuit of food out in the wild takes in more calories than it brings in. </u> You will eventually succumb to calorie deficit, and then death.
Rescue is the priority, so my first choice in a tool would be a flaregun.
-
hold on a minute, there was a time before farming when we seemed to survive?
See also: Adrift: 76 Days Lost at Sea
-
@shamus said:
<u> No matter how good you are, the pursuit of food out in the wild takes in more calories than it brings in. </u>We did it as a species for centuries. And when I was in high school, I took a summer and lived "up on the mountain" on land my family owns for hunting. Only used the camp to stash gear that didn't live up to my expectations, and the bags of rice and jars of peanut butter my mother insisted on me bringing. I lost a couple inches off my waist, learned to hate trout with a passion, and proved that you can do it if you know a little about plants and put out a lot of dead falls, snares and the like. I had more than a knife with me, but I took about as much meat with sticks and stones and a frog/fish spear as I did with my .22.
Gods, I wish I could tell my life to sod off next summer and do it again.
-
@tosh said:
I saw that film last night, well half of it.
Cast away (Tom Hanks).She asked me "which one of your "multys" would you need for that then" which basically ruined the film for me, as all I could think of was what she'd just asked.

I'm still undecided.
In the real world it wouldn't be a fire starter or an axe, would it??So, in that given situation what tool would have come up best. Don't say the one you had with you. Be a little more original please.
I'll go with the basic Surge, purely on the grounds of the spare file in the wallet to keep the saw sharp. Can't think of another standard tool that has such an accessory.
But would anyone seriously be edc-ing that beast.
I currently EDC the Surge everyday for work and even around the house on the weekends in my Skinth OG sheath, before I bought my Leatherman Wingman a couple of days ago, now that rides in my shorts pocket when I'm at home. But love the Surge so I would have the Surge any day.


-
@shamus said:
<u> No matter how good you are, the pursuit of food out in the wild takes in more calories than it brings in. </u>
We did it as a species for centuries. And when I was in high school, I took a summer and lived "up on the mountain" on land my family owns for hunting. Only used the camp to stash gear that didn't live up to my expectations, and the bags of rice and jars of peanut butter my mother insisted on me bringing. I lost a couple inches off my waist, learned to hate trout with a passion, and proved that you can do it if you know a little about plants and put out a lot of dead falls, snares and the like. I had more than a knife with me, but I took about as much meat with sticks and stones and a frog/fish spear as I did with my .22.
Gods, I wish I could tell my life to sod off next summer and do it again.
Wow, hats off to you for that ironraven.

If it was as you say, then that takes Guts. Without sounding patronising - I suspect your folks saw a different person when you finally came down.
I'll be honest, I doubt I would ever actually put myself in that experiment. Its one thing surviving, quite another to take it on!!
Respect my friend
-
Another
to ironraven, I wish I have the knowledge and guts to do what you did.I think as life has became more convenient in the city, people did lose the wilderness survival/substantiating skill we used to have. And I tend to agree with people whom constructing their "survival kit" with the aim to 'survive till rescue' than to 'sustain in wild'. As Cody ludin said in his book, unless you trap for living and do posses the skill to trap, expecting yourself to trap food in wild is very difficult for survival situation.
I did construct a small/large wilderness 'survival' kit for the obvious reason, knowing that I will be long dead if I were to just rely on a tool in a survival situation. But if it means anything, I do include a 111mm trekker SAK in my large survival kit and do consider it my best choice for MT in the wild.
-
@shamus said:
<u> No matter how good you are, the pursuit of food out in the wild takes in more calories than it brings in. </u>
We did it as a species for centuries. Gods, I wish I could tell my life to sod off next summer and do it again.
Sorry for the lack of clarification: We did it a species in groups, not alone.
If I throw you out in the wild with nothing but the gear on your back (take whatever you want) you’ll survive for a while, but you eventually succumb to calorie deficit (you already were, as you had lost some inches on your belt by your own admission). Everyone alone in the woods, without resupply from the outside world, will die. Some folks can last longer than others.
Humanity survived out in the wild (ie, primitive conditions) for centuries by living in groups, with the vast majority of calories from gathering as opposed to hunting.
-
Additionally I assume we had very different needs back then as well- hardier, more efficient bodies, used to running longer on less fuel, plus the pre agricultural average lifespan was what, 30 to 35 years?
Not to mention the mental issues with being left alone for extended periods. I can't imagine anyone left alone that long remaining mentally stable long enough to live to a ripe old age.
Still, I'm thinking a semi-deserted island, with a bunch of women with coconut bras, skilled in farming and distillation might not be a bad way to go.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Additionally I assume we had very different needs back then as well- hardier, more efficient bodies, used to running longer on less fuel, plus the pre agricultural average lifespan was what, 30 to 35 years?Not to mention the mental issues with being left alone for extended periods. I can't imagine anyone left alone that long remaining mentally stable long enough to live to a ripe old age.
**Still, I'm thinking a semi-deserted island, with a bunch of women with coconut bras, skilled in farming and distillation might not be a bad way to go.
**
DefI'll take a one way ticket to that. :D :ahhh :ahhh
Howl...Howl...

-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Still, I'm thinking a semi-deserted island, with a bunch of women with coconut bras, skilled in farming and distillation might not be a bad way to go.Def
Chief,
That's like...the perfect new year wish! :D
@shamus said:
@shamus said:
<u> No matter how good you are, the pursuit of food out in the wild takes in more calories than it brings in. </u>
We did it as a species for centuries. Gods, I wish I could tell my life to sod off next summer and do it again.
Sorry for the lack of clarification: We did it a species in groups, not alone.
If I throw you out in the wild with nothing but the gear on your back (take whatever you want) you’ll survive for a while, but you eventually succumb to calorie deficit (you already were, as you had lost some inches on your belt by your own admission). Everyone alone in the woods, without resupply from the outside world, will die. Some folks can last longer than others.
Humanity survived out in the wild (ie, primitive conditions) for centuries by living in groups, with the vast majority of calories from gathering as opposed to hunting.
Shamus,
Your statement reminded me of Richard 'Dick' Proenneke, whom believed to have lived alone in Alaska for 30 years, only to rarely reunite with his family a few times over that period.
Dick is probably a rare case to find, and he doesn't just venture out to the wild all by himself(without any proper tools). By Dick case, I would say it is not entirely impossible to live by oneself, given the resources is abundant and you posses the skill and tool necessary for living in the wild. And if we were to be able to live out in the woods with just our tools, there is no better time than modern days, which technology has massively improved since primitive times.
However, with all the convenience we have nowadays, we might have lost what wilderness living skill we once used to posses, and become too technology dependent. So even with all the improved tools, most majority of people will probably just die or live much shorter lives in the wild with just their tools.
-
this'll probably stir up a 'hornets nest of testosterone' but after reading lots of true life survival stories and watching lots of TV programs ::) one of the latest being 'naked and afraid' on Discovery. I've come to the conclusion that 'modern MEN', especially 'western' men, are NOT well equipped to survive 'in the wild' due to our size and calorific needs. Also being used to extra food as a norm makes going without suck all the more. In the mentioned TV program the women seemed to fare much better. in part because they needed less fuel and in part because they didn't run about using calories trying to improve their 'predicament' and 'look' good in the eyes of others, women don't feel the need to impress as much IMO. this seems to me to be the case in a few other survival stories I've read about where the men have perished long before the women folk :o
-
Your statement reminded me of Richard 'Dick' Proenneke, whom believed to have lived alone in Alaska for 30 years, only to rarely reunite with his family a few times over that period.
Dick is probably a rare case to find, and he doesn't just venture out to the wild all by himself(without any proper tools). By Dick case, I would say it is not entirely impossible to live by oneself, given the resources is abundant and you posses the skill and tool necessary for living in the wild. And if we were to be able to live out in the woods with just our tools, there is no better time than modern days, which technology has massively improved since primitive times.
Ah, yes.. Dick Proenneke and "Alone in the Wilderness". I've read the book and watched the DVD. Proenneke was resupplied frequently from the outside by his friend, Babe, who would fly in with supplies. ;)
-
@shamus said:
Ah, yes.. Dick Proenneke and "Alone in the Wilderness". I've read the book and watched the DVD. Proenneke was resupplied frequently from the outside by his friend, Babe, who would fly in with supplies. ;)Shamus,
Thank you for the mytybuster! :D Honestly, I still haven't read the book/see the dvd yet, and always fantasize how he could have done it from the extracts that I have read. If good'o Dick still didn't cut it, then I am pretty clueless who else may have done it.
:DTaxi Dad,
"Naked and Afraid" just started showing in Asia(we are usually few months late for N. America made seasonal tv shows), and I can't help but to agree that men might do more on the show. I wonder was it because he was constantly facing a semi-naked woman and a camera crew, because I knew I don't look that impressive when my wife complained me either facing the tube or sitting in front of MT.O during my free time.

-
I'd carry either my Wave or my SwissChamp with a fire striker on a lanyard. Everything else could be improvised (although I don't think I'd be chopping down any trees:( )
-
Sacrilege perhaps, but if I could only have one knife/MT in that situation, give me a good quality fixed blade and a firesteel.
Sand in the pivot(s) + rust from constant exposure to salt water/sea air = major problems for a folding tool
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




