Wenger/Victorinox prototypes
-
Can I speak my mind on this?
I've been pondering on this for months.
And, now having seen the so-called prototypes.... I'm just stunned!!
Seriously, what the hell is it?
It certainly doesn't look like a victorinox, it can't be wenger because they've been killed off. So what's left??To me its grotesque, nothing short of victorinox parading in dead mans clothes.
I'm so glad I managed to collect both victorinox and wenger when they were in their prime. This "thing" does absolutely nothing for me...NOTHING!! -
@tosh said:
Can I speak my mind on this?I've been pondering on this for months.
And, now having seen the so-called prototypes.... I'm just stunned!!
Seriously, what the hell is it?
It certainly doesn't look like a victorinox, it can't be wenger because they've been killed off. So what's left??To me its grotesque, nothing short of victorinox parading in dead mans clothes.
I'm so glad I managed to collect both victorinox and wenger when they were in their prime. This "thing" does absolutely nothing for me...NOTHING!!Sure you can speak Your mind, feel free

I forgot to mention about the Wenger Ranger AP Blaze 50 and also the Snow model. For many years people did use the EKA SwingBlade. But with the Ranger 50 People got a very good knife + a gutting blade + a saw. This is maybe the best Wenger model ever made. So i hope this model stay with us!
-
@tosh said:
Can I speak my mind on this?I've been pondering on this for months.
And, now having seen the so-called prototypes.... I'm just stunned!!
Seriously, what the hell is it?
It certainly doesn't look like a victorinox, it can't be wenger because they've been killed off. So what's left??To me its grotesque, nothing short of victorinox parading in dead mans clothes.
I'm so glad I managed to collect both victorinox and wenger when they were in their prime. This "thing" does absolutely nothing for me...NOTHING!!I don't quite understand this opinion. For the Ranger line, it looks like it gets the Vic can opener (which I prefer and is one of the reasons I don't generally carry a Wenger on the farm) and the upgraded tweezers and toothpick.
It looks like they may be keeping the Wenger scissors (which I like) and the 85mm format (which I like better than most of the 84 range of Vic).
So far this looks like all win to me.
-
Can I speak my mind on this?
I've been pondering on this for months.
And, now having seen the so-called prototypes.... I'm just stunned!!
Seriously, what the hell is it?
It certainly doesn't look like a victorinox, it can't be wenger because they've been killed off. So what's left??To me its grotesque, nothing short of victorinox parading in dead mans clothes.
I'm so glad I managed to collect both victorinox and wenger when they were in their prime. This "thing" does absolutely nothing for me...NOTHING!!Sure you can speak Your mind, feel free

I forgot to mention about the Wenger Ranger AP Blaze 50 and also the Snow model. For many years people did use the EKA SwingBlade. But with the Ranger 50 People got a very good knife + a gutting blade + a saw. This is maybe the best Wenger model ever made. So i hope this model stay with us!
Crap. I wish I'd seen this Wenger before I bought my Vic Hunter XT. That's a great knife.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Can I speak my mind on this?
I've been pondering on this for months.
And, now having seen the so-called prototypes.... I'm just stunned!!
Seriously, what the hell is it?
It certainly doesn't look like a victorinox, it can't be wenger because they've been killed off. So what's left??To me its grotesque, nothing short of victorinox parading in dead mans clothes.
I'm so glad I managed to collect both victorinox and wenger when they were in their prime. This "thing" does absolutely nothing for me...NOTHING!!I don't quite understand this opinion. For the Ranger line, it looks like it gets the Vic can opener (which I prefer and is one of the reasons I don't generally carry a Wenger on the farm) and the upgraded tweezers and toothpick.
It looks like they may be keeping the Wenger scissors (which I like) and the 85mm format (which I like better than most of the 84 range of Vic).
So far this looks like all win to me.
That's fair enough Mr Whippy
But for me, having read how protective victorinox are of their " brand" name.
All I see is a company that didn't have the balls to try something radical, yet are quite happy to kill off a rival and consume their identity.That's how "I" see it.
I'm not trying to be argumentative, just saying I don't buy it, and nor will I BUY it. -
@Mr. Whippy said:
Can I speak my mind on this?
I've been pondering on this for months.
And, now having seen the so-called prototypes.... I'm just stunned!!
Seriously, what the hell is it?
It certainly doesn't look like a victorinox, it can't be wenger because they've been killed off. So what's left??To me its grotesque, nothing short of victorinox parading in dead mans clothes.
I'm so glad I managed to collect both victorinox and wenger when they were in their prime. This "thing" does absolutely nothing for me...NOTHING!!Sure you can speak Your mind, feel free

I forgot to mention about the Wenger Ranger AP Blaze 50 and also the Snow model. For many years people did use the EKA SwingBlade. But with the Ranger 50 People got a very good knife + a gutting blade + a saw. This is maybe the best Wenger model ever made. So i hope this model stay with us!
Crap. I wish I'd seen this Wenger before I bought my Vic Hunter XT. That's a great knife.
Oh Oh.... the cat has been let out of the bag. To be fair though the Hunter XT is also a great knife and it's smaller size often is nice. However for the best folder for serious hunting, I'd have to give the award to the Ranger 50. Still I think the Vic is more vesatile because it can be more easily carried in different situations.
Unfortunately Victorinox depends on volume production to make money in the Knife market. At this time I don't think the market for working knives is large enough to support the large number of models they once made, and to appeal to the largest audience they may have to make more middle of the road, or less specialized knives to get the volumes they really need.
2014/2015/2016 will be interesting to see how things unfold. Maybe if China chooses to take a Swiss Knife into space, like all sensible astronauts, we'll have a renewed interest in SAKs as the carry knife of choice. If the new 21st Century Space race really gets started, Victorinox might want to be sure they are again on the official equipment list of at least a few nations. Maybe the SAK can help win the new space-race?
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Although its great to see the wenger is still produced, albeit under the Vic logo

I'm kinda stunned, but not in the least bit surprised they didn't release a new design concept, its basically what we all simply expected. A wenger without its logo!!Hmm, how very original Vic.

yes maybe

The Wenger Brand have in the last years made it well here in Norway, it seems the knives could fill a role that Victorinox did not have, most know that Victorinox took over Wenger from 2005 and that they got the same quality. Only Victorinox can say how independent Wenger has been, I was told that Wenger was independent with knives. What we do know is that some of the Rangers started to outperform Victorinox and other brands.
To me, the Ranger line far and away out performs the traditional Vic 111 mm line (although I do like the Hunter XT). The Ranger line is a completely different level of performance. I could see the 111 mm line dwindling down.
Totally agree, the wenger 120s are much better overall than the Vic 111mm.
-
@Gareth said:
Really good to see these, cheers for sharing North Man.
I'm rather surprised to see the 120mm Rangers, I thought that line was a goner for sure.It might sound odd, but I am rather sorry to see the Wenger can opener gone. :-\ Yes, the Vic style one adds the screwdriver, but I liked the Wenger one for it's sharp edge and point. Ah well.
+1 to this. I've found the Wenger can opener to be a great multi-purpose pokey thing (MPPT), and also a bit easier for me to use as a lefty. As a can opener it gets used atl least once a day at the store to open tint cans. The loss of the small screwdriver didn't bother me one bit as I've had a Craftsman 4-way driver on my keys for ages. As to the 120mm line, I've yet to handle one that was lefty-friendly in terms of OHO.....
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Can I speak my mind on this?
I've been pondering on this for months.
And, now having seen the so-called prototypes.... I'm just stunned!!
Seriously, what the hell is it?
It certainly doesn't look like a victorinox, it can't be wenger because they've been killed off. So what's left??To me its grotesque, nothing short of victorinox parading in dead mans clothes.
I'm so glad I managed to collect both victorinox and wenger when they were in their prime. This "thing" does absolutely nothing for me...NOTHING!!Sure you can speak Your mind, feel free

I forgot to mention about the Wenger Ranger AP Blaze 50 and also the Snow model. For many years people did use the EKA SwingBlade. But with the Ranger 50 People got a very good knife + a gutting blade + a saw. This is maybe the best Wenger model ever made. So i hope this model stay with us!
Crap. I wish I'd seen this Wenger before I bought my Vic Hunter XT. That's a great knife.
Oh Oh.... the cat has been let out of the bag. To be fair though the Hunter XT is also a great knife and it's smaller size often is nice. However for the best folder for serious hunting, I'd have to give the award to the Ranger 50. Still I think the Vic is more vesatile because it can be more easily carried in different situations.
Unfortunately Victorinox depends on volume production to make money in the Knife market. At this time I don't think the market for working knives is large enough to support the large number of models they once made, and to appeal to the largest audience they may have to make more middle of the road, or less specialized knives to get the volumes they really need.
2014/2015/2016 will be interesting to see how things unfold. Maybe if China chooses to take a Swiss Knife into space, like all sensible astronauts, we'll have a renewed interest in SAKs as the carry knife of choice. If the new 21st Century Space race really gets started, Victorinox might want to be sure they are again on the official equipment list of at least a few nations. Maybe the SAK can help win the new space-race?
Interesting
I do like the sound of a Swiss Army Knife in the new space-race -
I find it interesting that the photo shows a rebadged Esquire just below the Clipper. Surely the Esquire is a direct competitor to the Classic? Is this the end for the "best selling pocket knife in the world"? Can't see that myself so what's the go?
-
Really good to see these, cheers for sharing North Man.
I'm rather surprised to see the 120mm Rangers, I thought that line was a goner for sure.It might sound odd, but I am rather sorry to see the Wenger can opener gone. :-\ Yes, the Vic style one adds the screwdriver, but I liked the Wenger one for it's sharp edge and point. Ah well.
+1 to this. I've found the Wenger can opener to be a great multi-purpose pokey thing (MPPT), and also a bit easier for me to use as a lefty. As a can opener it gets used atl least once a day at the store to open tint cans. The loss of the small screwdriver didn't bother me one bit as I've had a Craftsman 4-way driver on my keys for ages. As to the 120mm line, I've yet to handle one that was lefty-friendly in terms of OHO.....
I'm another one that mourns the loss of Wenger's can opener. The extra driver is nice but I much prefer the usefulness of wenger's opener, I also dislike the lack of the locking cap lifter/flat head ...
-
Maybe Victorinox will incorporate a liner-locking cap-lifter/pry-tool in to the 130mm Rangers... now that would be an advancement. That's a killer features of their 111mm line.
-
At the North American Meetup, I'm going to supply a bunch of cans and have people try opening with a Vic opener (after a tutorial on usage) and the Wenger opener. I believe all righties and a significant number of lefties will end up agreeing the Vic is the superior opener.
I open a #10 can of green beans nearly every day with a SAK. The Vic is significantly faster, using the right technique (cutting the lid on each up and down stroke).
-
Interesting. I must say I'm not too good with the can opener. Yesterday I opened to small tins of mushrooms, and still found it difficult once beyond 1/2 way or so and the lid gets floppy. I've never tried cutting on both strokes though. I'll try to see if I can do that on the next can I open.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
At the North American Meetup, I'm going to supply a bunch of cans and have people try opening with a Vic opener (after a tutorial on usage) and the Wenger opener. I believe all righties and a significant number of lefties will end up agreeing the Vic is the superior opener.I open a #10 can of green beans nearly every day with a SAK. The Vic is significantly faster, using the right technique (cutting the lid on each up and down stroke).
I remember you mentioning this before, did you have a video of your method? Im ok with the opener, but certainly not going to win any speed trials. :D
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
At the North American Meetup, I'm going to supply a bunch of cans and have people try opening with a Vic opener (after a tutorial on usage) and the Wenger opener. ** I believe all righties and a significant number of lefties will end up agreeing the Vic is the superior opener.**I open a #10 can of green beans nearly every day with a SAK. The Vic is significantly faster, using the right technique (cutting the lid on each up and down stroke).
Nope, a righty here, plenty of usage of both can openers and I still prefer the wenger one. :P
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
At the North American Meetup, I'm going to supply a bunch of cans and have people try opening with a Vic opener (after a tutorial on usage) and the Wenger opener. ** I believe all righties and a significant number of lefties will end up agreeing the Vic is the superior opener.**
I open a #10 can of green beans nearly every day with a SAK. The Vic is significantly faster, using the right technique (cutting the lid on each up and down stroke).
Nope, a righty here, plenty of usage of both can openers and I still prefer the wenger one. :P
This size can?

The gauge of steel is much greater than a standard #2 (like a typical can of soup) and the Wenger opener ends up leaving a raggedy edge as well as taking longer.
-
I like both can openers. For me, vics can opener belongs on there frame, and the old type belongs on a wenger.
sent from Nate's mobile
-
For everyone's viewing pleasure :D:
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
At the North American Meetup, I'm going to supply a bunch of cans and have people try opening with a Vic opener (after a tutorial on usage) and the Wenger opener. ** I believe all righties and a significant number of lefties will end up agreeing the Vic is the superior opener.**
I open a #10 can of green beans nearly every day with a SAK. The Vic is significantly faster, using the right technique (cutting the lid on each up and down stroke).
Nope, a righty here, plenty of usage of both can openers and I still prefer the wenger one. :P
This size can?

The gauge of steel is much greater than a standard #2 (like a typical can of soup) and the Wenger opener ends up leaving a raggedy edge as well as taking longer.
I'll try to do a test myself soon. Maybe not the same size as we probably have different sizes here but I'll try to make it as close as I can.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

