Tools 'leaking rust' after cleaning
-
I cleaned a Vic Handyman last month, and just finished cleaning a PST II, and both had a phenomenon happen where after cleaning, as the WD40 was pulling out of the tool, the oil was rust colored. can I assume this is simply because not taking the tools apart, or using a sonic cleaner, that there is small amounts of rust between tool layers and it's drawing out?
-
It seems the mineral oil I put in my wave has turned to black gook that is now leaking out. I guess I should look into getting some victorinox oil instead
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I cleaned a Vic Handyman last month, and just finished cleaning a PST II, and both had a phenomenon happen where after cleaning, as the WD40 was pulling out of the tool, the oil was rust colored. can I assume this is simply because not taking the tools apart, or using a sonic cleaner, that there is small amounts of rust between tool layers and it's drawing out?I've noticed the same phenomenon after cleaning some older LM tools that I bought on ebay. I've never had that problem when I completely disassemble a tool before cleaning/oiling, so I came to the same conclusion as you, Lynn.
My suggestion* would be to wipe the tool clean (as well as you can) and continue to give it a healthy dose of WD40 periodically. You should start seeing less and less rust/discoloration with time, but I don't think it will get completely clean unless you disassemble the tool.*Please note that this is just based on my personal experience, and not any special knowledge, research, or skills of any sort. :D
-
I'm not going to preach my method, but I can't honestly see why it shouldn't work.
Up to now I have disassembled none. My usual method is to use whatever means I have lying around around to clean it. When I'm happy with the result I usually finish off with hot soapy water then final rinse with just hot water.The oven has already been running for 10mins to get up to temperature. The tool is left fanned out and shoved in on the racks.
20mins later I remove and take into the garage, place on a block of wood and then just smoother with WD40 - ensuring I turn the tool over, into the pivots, working the joints etc etc.
Up to now, that method has been foolproof. I'm beginning to suspect its the heat expanding and the WD40 soaking and coating that's prevented rust.
Works for me

-
For some reason I have a similar problem with LM micras. Once they have rusted a bit, independent of how much I clean them and how much rust I remove they allways seem to have some rust leaking out when you oil them.
I just do not worry too much about it.
-
It might also be old oil that has gone brown as it dried with age. I have some tools that ooze brown gunk when the components are moved, but the tool doesn't have a speck of rust on it anywhere you can see.
-
@gregozedobe said:
It might also be old oil that has gone brown as it dried with age. I have some tools that ooze brown junk when the components are moved, but the tool doesn't have a speck of rust on it anywhere you can see.+1
You are correct. It is old oil leaking out. Leathermans, swisstool etc will leak some junk out of the plier pivit when freshly oiled as will regaluar pliers. It is where the pivit slowly wears and gunk build up from using them. New tools will do this also from where they where freshly michined.sent from Nate's mobile
-
If there is brown stuff coming out a a SAK, I think it still needs more cleaning. SAKs don't rust. On real dirty ones I do a WD-40 soak then dawn. If it is still dirty, redo the WD-40 soak and then dawn again. I have even used acetone to get stuff out. When done any oil used should stay they same color as applied. Leathermans rust. To me a whole different animal than a SAK.
-
I did have a LM tool developed many rust spots all over(sitting in a dry closet for a year), even after drenched in WD40 for cleaning and oiling. Personally, I do trust Tuf Glide for rust prevention better than WD40.
-
While it's certainly not easy to accomplish with highly-polished SAK tools, no stainless steel is fully rust proof.
@comis said:
Personally, I do trust Tuf Glide for rust prevention better than WD40.Yes, I find Break-Free CLP to be better than WD-40 also. I only use it for stored tools though--I use food safe oil on my carry knives.
-
Out of the 500 or so SAKs I have owned, I have never seen rust. I have probably opened over 100 SAKs. The liners corrode and screw up the knife, but that is white usually. True no stainless is rust proof, but SAKs are darned close. I have seen brown gunk, but if you keep cleaning, it will go way.
-
@GigaHz said:
Out of the 500 or so SAKs I have owned, I have never seen rust. I have probably opened over 100 SAKs.Like I said, it's not easy to accomplish, but rust can occur. I've owned a few SAKs myself, and none of mine have rust. However, I have seen rust on SAKs. I just wanted to point out that it's not impossible, that is all.
-
The only rust I have seen on a SAK was on the file of an old Champion and staining from it on the other tools. Once I broke it down and soaked it in WD40 it all wiped off the other tools without a trace.
From this
<a href="http://s1309.photobucket.com/user/Peter_Thorpe/media/20130304_155119_zpsdf3edb6c.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i1309.photobucket.com/albums/s640/Peter_Thorpe/20130304_155119_zpsdf3edb6c.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>to this...
<a href="http://s1309.photobucket.com/user/Peter_Thorpe/media/20130306_164553_zpsfa6febec.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i1309.photobucket.com/albums/s640/Peter_Thorpe/20130306_164553_zpsfa6febec.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
<a href="http://s1309.photobucket.com/user/Peter_Thorpe/media/20130306_164339_zpsd2418375.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i1309.photobucket.com/albums/s640/Peter_Thorpe/20130306_164339_zpsd2418375.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>okay, it's a replacement main blade, but all the other tools are originals
hmm, just noticed this doesn't have a fish-scaler but it does have the mag-Phillips layer.. is this actually a Champion or something else?
-
Good example, Peter.

The worst damage I have is on an old Wenger. It had a bit of rust when I got it but it cleaned up and never came back so I'm not sure what caused it. (Pics taken with quite a bit of magnification, not as visible with naked eye) No other tools or even the other side of the knife blade show any signs of it though.




We had someone, Dunc I think do a long Vic rust test in sea water. Tied a Vic blade in the see for weeks to test rust resistance. I'll try to find that one. And I remember a member posting about a SAK they dived out of the see that was crusted shut.
They can rust but it takes some serious neglect/abuse to achieve that.

some other brands on the other hand rust if you look at them the wrong way. ::)
-
-
OK SAKs rust. But 99.99% of the time they don't. I still think Lynn's just needs more cleaning. Non stainless files rust like Leathermans.
-
Its hard to rust a SAK. The easiest tool to rust though is the old metal file. It rusts easy, but its not stainless. I think to rust the normal shiny SAK tools you'll need a maritime salt water environment.
-
Thanks for that link, Enki. That was an awesome rust test.
And yeah, I don't think it's rust, just old oil and crud.
-
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
