I can't help it...
-
@AdmSlc said:
I always have a knife & MT on me. I like the knife for cutting tasks and prefer the comfortable handle as to the handle of the MT. I like switching it up in the knife/ MT variety world for fun. The biggest reason I carry a dedicated knife (tactical) is for self defense. Both MTs and Knives can cut, however only tactical knives (BENCHMADE , Spyderco CRKT, etc.) can be deployed in a blink of an eye, lock up solid, and go to work if you know what I mean. Can you imagine trying to open a blade on a SAK or Leatherman using the nail nick while a guy has you in a headlock and is trying to mess you up?-AdmSlc
I don't carry a knife for defense. I'll leave the knife fighting to the soldier of fortune crowd or the Walter Mitty's of the world. A knife is about as poor a defense weapon as you can get. If you use a knife on someone that is unarmed, because they have you in a headlock, then you will deserve the legal trouble you will get. Just learn how to fight and defend yourself. If you're in a headlock, just make peanut butter out of his family jewels or take his knee out. I grew up in the 50's learning that a knife is a punks weapon. Things haven't changed. Learning to depend on a knife for your feeling of safety is the wrong way to go. Take some krav maga classes. I spent 4 years on as a police officer before moving on to job that paid better, but I did earn that there's a hundred ways to counter a knife, all effective. As for going to work on someone, you need to grow up. And think about this; with 40 of the 50 states now having CCW, odds are that you pull a knife on someone and 'go to work' as you call it, there's a very good chance that his buddy may pull a gun and punch your ticket right there. And the law will do nothing about it. Soon as you introduce a deadly weapon into a disorderly situation, you become the criminal. Sometimes criminals get shot. Think about it. In any situation that is sketchy, pulling a knife will make things a hundred percent worse.
-
@Jothra said:
*P.S. - I agree with Lynn. The bottle opener makes an amazing prybar, and my own testing has proved it to be ridiculously durable. It is unquestionably the most-used tool on my Huntsman, beating out even the blade and the scissors. *I think I use the bottle opener more for light prying than for a screw driver. There's so many times that a thumbnail is just not strong enough, and you just need a little prying. Even a coin may do, but you don't have any change in your pocket. But there's always a SAK, and that wonderful bottle opener/screw driver.
I don't have a horse in that race either. I'll leave that to the armchair commando's.
-
Interesting topic, self defence. Where I live only the cops and the real bad asses carry guns, or have them at home. So we grow up more or less weaponless, maybe doing some boxing or karate in our teens and then getting fat and lazy...
Now that I have a family and a live in a house in the middle of nowhere, I do occasionally wonder what I'd do if someone broke in at night. I suppose I would instinctively reach for a SAK, even though they are fairly laughable in any kind of combat situation. Maybe the difference is purely psychological. But I would prefer to have a Climber in my hand than nothing at all. I think my battle cry would be louder, and more intimidating. (At least I hope it would be!)
The rules of self defence in one's home are, I believe, totally different than the rules of the street. Certainly I'd get in deep doo-doo if I pulled a knife outside somewhere. Even owning a One Hand Trailmaster(Trekker) is pretty much Verboten unless it stays at home.
-
I love my Explorer plus but having a little plier is great when fingers wont pinch hard enough. Case in point, my friend snagged her bracelet and the loop that connected it needed to be squeezed and twisted back into shape any my fingers just wouldn't do. I seriously find many uses for the mag glass and the pen. I have found I enjoy the Swisschamp a tad more these days and have begun to carry it more. I carry a folder when at work and will slip a Opinel into my pocket on off days. I used to carry a Recruit for work but like having a locking blade now for cutting thru thicker material and ease of deployment.
-
@Thunderpants said:
Interesting topic, self defence. Where I live only the cops and the real bad asses carry guns, or have them at home. So we grow up more or less weaponless, maybe doing some boxing or karate in our teens and then getting fat and lazy...Now that I have a family and a live in a house in the middle of nowhere, I do occasionally wonder what I'd do if someone broke in at night. I suppose I would instinctively reach for a SAK, even though they are fairly laughable in any kind of combat situation. Maybe the difference is purely psychological. But I would prefer to have a Climber in my hand than nothing at all. I think my battle cry would be louder, and more intimidating. (At least I hope it would be!)
The rules of self defence in one's home are, I believe, totally different than the rules of the street. Certainly I'd get in deep doo-doo if I pulled a knife outside somewhere. Even owning a One Hand Trailmaster(Trekker) is pretty much Verboten unless it stays at home.
I don't know what country you live in, but the state of Maryland here in the U.S. also does not allow for the private carry of firearms. It's one of the very small handful of states that does not. I also spend time traveling to places like New York city for the museums and restaurants and art galleries. So carrying a gun is out for me. But while I was in the police academy, we learned how to defend against a knife, and if the knife wielder had any idea how much he was handicapping himself, it would be funny. A stick of any kind, pool stick, lamp, beer pitcher, fireplace poker, jack handle, ski pole, large wrench, socket handle, Maglite flashlite, chair rung, bar stool, towel rack pulled off the wall, tightly rolled up magazine, piece of broom stick, mop bucket handle, frying pan, and many more objects around us can be used to block a knife and respond.
Any impact weapon is far superior to a knife. A knife cannot be carried into some places that have high security, like airports. But a stout walking stick/cane can be. On the police force I was with, we were issued a collapsable baton that when stowed, was only 8 inches long. But when flicked and extended was 18 inches of steel rod. It was very capable of breaking hand and wrist bones, making the retention of a knife in that hand impossible. Any stick gives you reach beyond the what the knife wielder will have. And it's effects will be instantaneous. It can take a while for a person to bleed out from a knife wound, and he can actually get more enraged by being cut or stabbed.
There is a very good reason Sir Robert Peel chose a wood club to arm the world first police department. He was at first going to use a short sword. But one of his first recruits was an ex british navy sailor. This was the early 19th century, remember? This sailor had been on some ship to ship action, and he advised Sir Robert that most sailors in a fight would actually prefer a belaying pin over a edged weapon like a cutlass. The oak belaying pin was more effective a close quarter weapon that a sword because it had instant shock effect. It dropped people right there. So even in the 20th century the bobbies carry a short wood club. If you were to defend your home without a firearm, I'd go with a stout club of some sort. Ax handle, ball peen hammer, iron fire place poker.
But to me, a knife is always a personal cutting tool. In the case of a SAK, it's a personal cutting tool with a some handy tools added. That makes it a must have edc item that I don't like to leave the house without.
-
@cbl51 said:
A stick of any kind, pool stick, lamp, beer pitcher, fireplace poker, jack handle, ski pole, large wrench, socket handle, Maglite flashlite, chair rung, bar stool, towel rack pulled off the wall, tightly rolled up magazine, piece of broom stick, mop bucket handle, frying pan, and many more objects around us can be used to block a knife and respond.Nicely put! Thanks for dispelling any notions I had of being a ninja.
And that's fascinating stuff about the old Peelers and their batons. Just imagine how the London coppers would look if they carried swords!
-
I have carried daily a SAK since 1983, midway thru my undergraduate/college years, when my dad gave me a Wenger. I found it to be really useful in my field courses in agriculture/horticulture (my major). Unfortunately, I misplaced it temporarily while doing an irrigation exercise in the field (installing irrigation shypons into furrows), and a classmate "took it" as a souvenir. I bought me immediately a Victorinox Huntsman and later on I graduated to a Champion, and since 1994 I have carried daily a SwissChamp (in handmade holster/pouch clipped to my belt).
I have used each tool in these SAK knives for countless things and projects, but nowadays I use quite a bit the small blade, scissors and magnifying glass. When I travel (locally and internationally) I always pack a Huntsman, but I miss the magnifying glass. I am currently modifying one Huntsman/Explorer hybrid for my travel pack.
Locally I also always carry a single locking folding knife (with pocket clip), rotating between titanium framelocks and lockbacks/axis locks. I am not that fond of linerlocks (I have had a couple of cuts on my index finger due to weak/faulty lock ups), but I still occasionally use them on my EDC rotation. -
I always have a knife & MT on me. I like the knife for cutting tasks and prefer the comfortable handle as to the handle of the MT. I like switching it up in the knife/ MT variety world for fun. The biggest reason I carry a dedicated knife (tactical) is for self defense. Both MTs and Knives can cut, however only tactical knives (BENCHMADE , Spyderco CRKT, etc.) can be deployed in a blink of an eye, lock up solid, and go to work if you know what I mean. Can you imagine trying to open a blade on a SAK or Leatherman using the nail nick while a guy has you in a headlock and is trying to mess you up?
-AdmSlc
I don't carry a knife for defense. I'll leave the knife fighting to the soldier of fortune crowd or the Walter Mitty's of the world. A knife is about as poor a defense weapon as you can get. If you use a knife on someone that is unarmed, because they have you in a headlock, then you will deserve the legal trouble you will get. Just learn how to fight and defend yourself. If you're in a headlock, just make peanut butter out of his family jewels or take his knee out. I grew up in the 50's learning that a knife is a punks weapon. Things haven't changed. Learning to depend on a knife for your feeling of safety is the wrong way to go. Take some krav maga classes. I spent 4 years on as a police officer before moving on to job that paid better, but I did earn that there's a hundred ways to counter a knife, all effective. As for going to work on someone, you need to grow up. And think about this; with 40 of the 50 states now having CCW, odds are that you pull a knife on someone and 'go to work' as you call it, there's a very good chance that his buddy may pull a gun and punch your ticket right there. And the law will do nothing about it. Soon as you introduce a deadly weapon into a disorderly situation, you become the criminal. Sometimes criminals get shot. Think about it. In any situation that is sketchy, pulling a knife will make things a hundred percent worse.
I disagree with you. I live in a state where CCW is allowed. I have had my firearm permit for 12+ years and always have a firearm on me(where legal obviously). Just because I have a 'tactical knife' as a form of self defense doesn't mean I don't know how to fight, have a gun on me, etc.. I like having options. 99.9% of the time calling the authorities and letting them deal with a bad situation works. The .1% is when SHTF and you need any and all means to defend yourself that you can get your hands on. That is way LEOs also carry a tactical knife. I'm not some punk ass kid running around looking to get busy on someone with a blade, I think you took my example of a headlock too seriously. I meant to give an example of how deploying a blade on a MT or SAK can be virtually impossible depending on the situation.
-AdmSlc
-
@Aloha007 said:
I love my Explorer plus but having a little plier is great when fingers wont pinch hard enough.This is a true fact. I'm willing to bet there are a lot of people who need pliers more than I do. It's probably worth mentioning that I keep a larger multitool in my satchel, which is always nearby, but the Huntsman owns my pocket.
-
@AdmSlc said:
I disagree with you. I live in a state where CCW is allowed. I have had my firearm permit for 12+ years and always have a firearm on me(where legal obviously). Just because I have a 'tactical knife' as a form of self defense doesn't mean I don't know how to fight, have a gun on me, etc.. I like having options. 99.9% of the time calling the authorities and letting them deal with a bad situation works. The .1% is when SHTF and you need any and all means to defend yourself that you can get your hands on. That is way LEOs also carry a tactical knife. I'm not some punk ass kid running around looking to get busy on someone with a blade, I think you took my example of a headlock too seriously. I meant to give an example of how deploying a blade on a MT or SAK can be virtually impossible depending on the situation.-AdmSlc
Modern LEO's carry a tactical knife because it is in vogue, and no other reason. In the years I was on a modern metropolitan police department I had use just twice for a knife. One was prying open a screen window to gain access to a home where the owner had not been seen for days. The deceased owner was found inside. The other time was a bad traffic accident where an overturned Datsun was starting to burn, and some seat belts needed to be cut. The blade on a tinker sliced right through the nylon web material. Cops, especially young cops, are just as influenced by media as the rest of us. When the tactical knives are glorified by the knife magazines that are the paid shills of the knife companies, to be the best thing since flint, they sell to a wide range of people. But in the 4 years I spent in the U.S. Army, then a [police force, I never had any need of a knife for defense. Police are issued a pistol, ASP baton, mace/pepper spray, tasters, to deal with criminals. Should a cop knife someone, I suspect it will be the end of his career. It means he was stupid, has lack of judgement, or didn't have his issued gear with him. A few of the officers on my department started to carry the Buck knife in it's black leather pouch on their belts, and was told by the chief to remove them ASAP.
As for you sounding like a punk ass kid, it was you said something about going to work on someone with a knife that could be got out in a wink. Your whole tone was of that ilk. You gave me the example of a headlock, and if you are indeed in a headlock, you don't have time to get out your tactical ninja knife, but just clobber the idiot where it counts. If you don't want to be taken as a wanna be kid, don't sound like one. This whole discussion was about the utility of a SAK, not street combat. There are other forums for the chairborne rangers.
Now back to the original program.
-
I have a feeling I may end up in the same mindset in the future. I've said more than once that I could likely get by just fine most days with just a SAK. It's not often I really need a plier based multitool, but it does happen. If I were to get a Swisschamp though, I would possibly be all set for 95% of the time. However, I have occasionally found the pliers on a MT handy, and the SAK pliers wouldn't have likely been as helpful in those situations.
-
@Monrogue said:
I have a feeling I may end up in the same mindset in the future. I've said more than once that I could likely get by just fine most days with just a SAK. It's not often I really need a plier based multitool, but it does happen. If I were to get a Swisschamp though, I would possibly be all set for 95% of the time. However, I have occasionally found the pliers on a MT handy, and the SAK pliers wouldn't have likely been as helpful in those situations.maybe a smaller plier like a dime or a LM squirt paired with a champion plus? I carried the champ plus but since I have the swisschamp I'd rather have the plier layer.
-
I have a feeling I may end up in the same mindset in the future. I've said more than once that I could likely get by just fine most days with just a SAK. It's not often I really need a plier based multitool, but it does happen. If I were to get a Swisschamp though, I would possibly be all set for 95% of the time. However, I have occasionally found the pliers on a MT handy, and the SAK pliers wouldn't have likely been as helpful in those situations.
maybe a smaller plier like a dime or a LM squirt paired with a champion plus? I carried the champ plus but since I have the swisschamp I'd rather have the plier layer.
I do have the Squirt PS4, which I do carry along with the MT/SAK combo during the day. I can't reach far with those though, which only really applies to one of the tasks I've encountered here at work where the MT pliers were helpful. I could maybe do with the Juice line's pliers though. I just can't bring myself to only carry one item at this point >:D
-
I have a feeling I may end up in the same mindset in the future. I've said more than once that I could likely get by just fine most days with just a SAK. It's not often I really need a plier based multitool, but it does happen. If I were to get a Swisschamp though, I would possibly be all set for 95% of the time. However, I have occasionally found the pliers on a MT handy, and the SAK pliers wouldn't have likely been as helpful in those situations.
maybe a smaller plier like a dime or a LM squirt paired with a champion plus? I carried the champ plus but since I have the swisschamp I'd rather have the plier layer.
I do have the Squirt PS4, which I do carry along with the MT/SAK combo during the day. I can't reach far with those though, which only really applies to one of the tasks I've encountered here at work where the MT pliers were helpful. I could maybe do with the Juice line's pliers though. I just can't bring myself to only carry one item at this point >:D
I don't remember if you have a juice or not. I'm not suggesting you only carry one item,heaven forbid, banish the thought :D.
-
You know, a Leatherman isn't the worst thing to carry sometimes. Admittedly, I usually just have the SI or the custom SAK in my back pocket, but for days where I'm out all day, a Charge AL sits next to my wallet pretty easily.
It's helped a few times, and so far it hasn't felt like I'm some tac-knife nut that is prepared for the fall of society on my way to play some paintball. :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
-
@Monrogue said:
I have a feeling I may end up in the same mindset in the future. I've said more than once that I could likely get by just fine most days with just a SAK. It's not often I really need a plier based multitool, but it does happen. If I were to get a Swisschamp though, I would possibly be all set for 95% of the time. However, I have occasionally found the pliers on a MT handy, and the SAK pliers wouldn't have likely been as helpful in those situations.I haven't had that much use for a plier in my everyday life, but it does happen. I tried a Leatherman wave, but found it much too bulky for edc. It lives in my car glove box. For the once in a while use for a pliers, I have found that stationing a pair around is a help. In the house there's a basic tool kit on each floor, and in my daypack is a pair of mini Vice Grips that I got at Lowes. They work out great with a very wide range of opening. With my Wenger SI and a mini Vise grips, you can handle darn near anything. Better than a MT. The Vise grips can be used as pliers, wire cutter, and tightened down so you can really clamp onto a bolt and use them as a wrench.
-
I can't help but to agree with the OP post. And honestly, my job does require a lot of cutting task and the chances of using on of the tools of my MT is just as likely, if not more often, as my blade. And I guess that's probably why Victorinox probably is the largest knife/MT company on earth.
My favorite EDC MT is Vic Spirit, and I find it's weight and size tolerable for my pocket carry and covers 99% of my needs.
@cbl51 said:
...in my daypack is a pair of mini Vice Grips that I got at Lowes. They work out great with a very wide range of opening. With my Wenger SI and a mini Vise grips, you can handle darn near anything. Better than a MT. The Vise grips can be used as pliers, wire cutter, and tightened down so you can really clamp onto a bolt and use them as a wrench.For the same reason, I recently discover LM Crunch which I really do like in my "urban tool kit". Basically it's a vice grip but with some multitool functions. The best part, it could even accept tool bits which just eliminate the need for additional bit wrench from the kit.

-
I have a feeling I may end up in the same mindset in the future. I've said more than once that I could likely get by just fine most days with just a SAK. It's not often I really need a plier based multitool, but it does happen. If I were to get a Swisschamp though, I would possibly be all set for 95% of the time. However, I have occasionally found the pliers on a MT handy, and the SAK pliers wouldn't have likely been as helpful in those situations.
maybe a smaller plier like a dime or a LM squirt paired with a champion plus? I carried the champ plus but since I have the swisschamp I'd rather have the plier layer.
I do have the Squirt PS4, which I do carry along with the MT/SAK combo during the day. I can't reach far with those though, which only really applies to one of the tasks I've encountered here at work where the MT pliers were helpful. I could maybe do with the Juice line's pliers though. I just can't bring myself to only carry one item at this point >:D
I don't remember if you have a juice or not. I'm not suggesting you only carry one item,heaven forbid, banish the thought :D.
I do have the KF4, and an S2 actually, that I never carry anymore, despite the fact it had all the basics covered really for normal tasks. The S2 paired with a Champion Plus would probably be all I'd ever need. I like the KF4 though, but it would be double saws and files (the KF4 has the diamond file though). Summer is tough for me outside of work because I only can carry one item most of the time since I'm in gym shorts. You can imagine my distress in that case :ahhh
-
@sticktodrum said:
You know, a Leatherman isn't the worst thing to carry sometimes. Admittedly, I usually just have the SI or the custom SAK in my back pocket, but for days where I'm out all day, a Charge AL sits next to my wallet pretty easily.It's helped a few times, and so far it hasn't felt like I'm some tac-knife nut that is prepared for the fall of society on my way to play some paintball. :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
This is how I typically carry my MTs
They usually don't interfere much with the wallet, so it works for me. -
You know, a Leatherman isn't the worst thing to carry sometimes. Admittedly, I usually just have the SI or the custom SAK in my back pocket, but for days where I'm out all day, a Charge AL sits next to my wallet pretty easily.
It's helped a few times, and so far it hasn't felt like I'm some tac-knife nut that is prepared for the fall of society on my way to play some paintball. :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
This is how I typically carry my MTs
They usually don't interfere much with the wallet, so it works for me.They interfere with my wallet being full all the time.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login