Which option with scissors?
-
If you like the recruit and want to keep it, I would get a Micra or Rambler for the keys! If you want to carry only one, I would go with the Super Tinker as it is a great sak! :D
-
I'm lovin' my Super Tinker right now so that gets my vote!
-
Here's a link to my scissor test thread.
http://forum.multitool.org/general-tool-discussion/scissor-test/It REALLY depends on how much/how heavily you use your scissors.
The weight difference between adding the scissor layer to a 91mm SAK and carrying a separate Leatherman Style CS is about half an ounce. (a hair under an ounce for the SAK scissor layer, and about 1.5 oz for the Style CS).
At the low end of cutting. Paper, and day-to-day stuff, you'll notice little to no difference. However, the notch in my Climber's scissor blade showed me CLEARLY that SAK scissors are not made for the heavy duty cutting I was used to from Crosscut/Micra/Style CS. By the way, it was cutting a bread-tie wire that notched the Climber scissors (completely an accident on my part, but repeated with Crosscut and micra to no ill effect).
91mm SAK scissors do everyday tasks excellently. When it comes to the punishing level of work, you want an MT that's scissor-based. If you don't expect to need that, stay with a SAK. You'll also find the ergos on a Style CS much better if you have to do heavy cutting over a duration.
In the course of carrying scissor based tools, I find the 'heavy duty' aspect comes in handy maybe once a year. Might not be worth it to most folks.
That's the difference, in a nutshell.
-
I may be in the minority here, but I (have tried and) really don't like tools attached to my key chain (with the exception of flashlights). I feel having a bunch of keys hanging off the end makes the tool unwieldy to use. Of course, I could remove the tool from the key chain, use it, and then put in back on, but that adds two extra steps to the process. In the end, I'd rather just have it loose in pocket than attached to my keys, so if the only two options are those listed, I vote upgrade to Super Tinker. The Super Tinker will initially seem huge and heavy compared to the Recruit, but I predict you'll quickly grow accustomed to it.
-
I say Super Tinker. Another option could be the Wenger Evo16, same tool set as the Vic but on a frame only 1mm longer than your Recruit.
-
I think I am going to eliminate the Style CS (just due to the smaller lack of tools) and it's down to the Micra or Super Tinker..
-
This is a tricky choice to have to make. If you really can't decide you could always get both. >:D
-
I can't believe that no-one has been "helpful" and suggested a Vic' Compact, a Wenger Standard 1.04.03, or a Wenger Diplomat. All 2 layers with scissors.
Or a Recruit Plus Scissors mod. ::) -
How hard would a Recruit plus scissors mod be?
-
Yes, finding 84mm scissors can be hard. And even a beat up small climber usually isn't cheap. But sometimes you get lucky.
Cutting down 91mm scissors is not really that hard, just a little fiddly.
It is physically possible to mod Wenger scissors into a recruit but you need a second recruit as a donor and a pair of Wenger scissors. -
I think the Style CS is out of the running now. I have it narrowed down to a Recruit and a pair of Slip and Snip Scissors or my Craftsman Utility Knife and a Micra. I think the Micra has a good combo of tools and utility knife would provide a blade that could do lots of general cutting with no worry.
-
I think you wouldn't go wrong with a Micra. They're still selling it after so long for a reason.
-
No Recruit + Micra option?
-
I might be reconsidering carrying the Recruit. Carrying a Skeletool and also a utility knife somewhat makes two blades on the Recruit a redundancy. I have realized that I do have a need for scissors. I had a Micra a couple years and sold it due to it being in beat up shape. I kinda wished I kept it and cleaned it up so I have an urge to give one a second chance.
-
Here is another piece of thought I had. Between the Super Tinker and the Micra, which is going to be easier to sharpen when the time comes?
-
I like the scissors on the Micra better than any other SAK or multitool scissors I have encountered.
Micra gets my vote.
-
@ToolJoe said:
Here is another piece of thought I had. Between the Super Tinker and the Micra, which is going to be easier to sharpen when the time comes?I would have thought that the Vic scissors would be much easier to sharpen because you can open them up to maybe 150 degrees, whereas the Micra scissors will only open to about 40 degrees because of their spring mechanism.
-
My first SAK, like days ago... I bought the Climber expressly because these other gentlemen said SAK scissors are a cut above the rest. ( no pun intended )
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login