SAK... Why???
-
As a pure functional pocket knife (i.e. considering only knife blades), a SAK is at least as good as any other pocket knife of comparable size. The stainless steel they use takes a good edge, is quite rust resistant, and is easy to sharpen. But (unlike a stockman, say) a SAK usually also has a number of other useful tools, including screwdrivers, bottle and can openers, etc., etc. I find SAK tools are well-designed and executed, and more than adequate for their intended functions (and then some).
With regard to quality control, I probably have 40 or 50 SAKs, and have not seen one come out of the box with F&F or W&T issues. Warranty is also top notch, as all real SAKs carry a lifetime manufacturer's warranty against any defects in materials or workmanship.
SAKs are also a tremendous value for the money. Many popular models can be had NIB for under $35.
I don't agree that SAKs are for light duty only. As DTT said, the only implements where a SAK is at a considerable disadvantage to some other MTs are the pliers and wire cutters. SAKs are serious tools, perhaps even surprisingly capable, especially 91mm size and larger. People have skinned and field-dressed game with them, and for a good thread on how much punishment a SAK can take, see Jothra's 30-day Huntsman Challenge ( </topic/46255 ). It is kind of a long thread, but an engaging read IMO.
-
Ivhave to agree about value. If they are as durable as stated. The prices seem quite reasonable
-
No. Not a troll post at all.
They don't panic hoplophobes, oversized children, and the weak minded as much a Leatherman (buddy of mine has been told by his boss to keep his "butterfly knife" at home, "the one with pliers in it"). The price is right. Form factor is smaller than a pliers based multi. They've been proven in peace, disaster and war by professionals and people who just want to go home at the end of the day. In short, they work.
Never mind that they also have a evolutionary importance, as the perfection of the pocket knife style of multitools as origionally developed as scout knives and soldier's knives.
-
not much else to add other than they are pretty great tools especially when paired as most do with a LM or any MT for that matter.
-
@ Ironraven, truth is not trolling... But I appreciate your input & agree. Because someone says something you don't agree with or like? It doesn't make it a troll post.
-
I can get my pliers from a 2 dollar set at the flea market. The BIG SAKS 130mm Wenger and 111mm Vic Can outperform any tool in their leage.
The small SAKs sit nicely in the pocket compared to a pliered tool.
I still love leatherman. I have 3 original PSTs and a sidekick on the way.
-

Maybe this will be of more interest to you. ST300 strength with swiss precision.
-
What? You survived without a SAK so far? And in West Virginia, one of the states where people live in balance with the natural enviroment?
I loved WV, the old houses, the little rivers and all the Americana of it. The only think I hated there were the giant mosquitoes of bomber/fighter, day and night, all weather class. But even a SAK can't do much against them. It can do most other things though. -
@nate j said:
Jothra's 30-day Huntsman Challenge ( </topic/46255 ). It is kind of a long thread, but an engaging read IMO.I just quoted this for emphasis.
Rust Resistance, something other MT can only dream off.
They are also little engines that can. You have an old SAK that does not have good snap anymore? Just clean it and it will be like new. Oh, and they have excellent scissors, best wood saws (Saw Test by Lynn) in business. -
Well, you folks sold me... I think the main reason I've never owned a SAK.. Pliers & Wire cutters. But being a open minded individual. Hey? Why not... I was talking to the Missus this morning as she was shoe shopping & mentioned it. She popped into Ebay & bought me this...

She knew I had been looking at them. I appreciate all the input from the members here. Guess we'll see how it stands up. Not sure if it qualifies as a SAK or not.. But it should be close.
-
Excellent choice, as I'm sure the majority here will agree
I look forward to your thoughts/impressions of the Spirit after you've had some time with it. Did you get the Spirit or Spirit X? -
The spirit is a GREAT MT.

-
The Spirit X has a plain edged blade with a spear point whereas the Spirit has a Combo edged blade.
-
@Higgins617 said:
The Spirit X has a plain edged blade with a spear point whereas the Spirit has a Combo edged blade.Thanks Higgins!

-
Excellent choice, as I'm sure the majority here will agree :tu: I look forward to your thoughts/impressions of the Spirit after you've had some time with it. Did you get the Spirit or Spirit X?
Victorinox Swiss Army Pocket Knife - Swisstool Spirit X
Being new, what's the difference?
Lots of variations. ;)
Here's the wiki page on it.
-
Excellent choice, as I'm sure the majority here will agree :tu: I look forward to your thoughts/impressions of the Spirit after you've had some time with it. Did you get the Spirit or Spirit X?
Victorinox Swiss Army Pocket Knife - Swisstool Spirit X
Being new, what's the difference?
Lots of variations. ;)
Here's the wiki page on it.
+1 Thanks
-
If you were interested in a SAK to compliment the ST300, then I would look at the Super Tinker or Explorer! Both are great SAK's and have excellent tools including scissors which like I said would compliment the Super Tool you have!
Neither one is very expensive either!

-
You start by saying it's not a troll post, then follow with a troll post? What parts exactly are people clowning on Swiss Army Knives?
This post confuses me.

Nothing trollish about this post. maybe its just me.+1
The guys hardly gone and joined the forum to simply leave a troll post!!I can't speak for everyone, but for me it was all quite by chance. I was more hooked on multitools than SAKs.
Is is it the gadget factor?
is it that they are soooo cheap?
Is it the cuteness
Is it childhood memories?
Or is it just something to collect that actually does have a use?I think its a bit of everything.

-
Anyone else think the evolution of this thread was pretty cool?? Goodluck with the new tool Dale let us know what you think.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login