SAK... Why???
-
I like my Leatherman Rebar quite a bit, and got years of deadly effort out of my Wave, but it has always come down to pliers. I rarely need pliers, so Swiss Army Knives always end up in my pocket. I've been carrying one model of SAK or another since I was 8.
I am awfully tempted by the Spirit (for my bag). Mind you, I do have to get back on my Rebar Challenge first...
-
That was my issue as well. Always needing pliers & wire cutters. If the Spirit X can meet those two needs it'll prolly be #1
-
@Dale said:
That was my issue as well. Always needing pliers & wire cutters. If the Spirit X can meet those two needs it'll prolly be #1If you're used to ST300 pliers and cutters, you'll be sorely disappointed with a Vic. I have a full size swisstool, and while every other implement on it is top notch and really puts the ST300 in a bad position, nothing beats the shear strength and cutting ability of the ST300 (sog not included, I have those as well and while the cutters are great, the pliers excellent, the tools just aren't the same as LM or Vic).
I alternate between my swisstool and my ST300 for work (cable/telecom tech), and on swisstool days I always carry my dikes. ST300 days the dikes stay in my truck.
However, I never leave home without some form of SAK anymore. Swisschamp, super tinker, tinker or CT34. They're just too perfect for pocket carry.
Add a SAK with your ST300 if wire cutting is important, and you won't be disappointed. Get a set of good dikes if the spirit will be a daily thing and you cut wire as often as I do.
Edit: I never mentioned WHY I dislike the Vic cutters. They're far too short/shallow to cut coax cable (rg6) in one bite, it takes 2-3 bites to get through it completely, and then the dielectric is all smurfed up. Forget about cutting rg11 wire with a Vic, my sog had problems with it, but managed. Conversely, cutting cat3 or cat5 with a Vic is ok if the inner wires are still in the sheath, but if I'm trying to cut those same inner wires individually, there's too much 'slop' in the plier heads. Not so with the st300. Crisp, tight and strong.
-
That was my issue as well. Always needing pliers & wire cutters. If the Spirit X can meet those two needs it'll prolly be #1
If you're used to ST300 pliers and cutters, you'll be sorely disappointed with a Vic. I have a full size swisstool, and while every other implement on it is top notch and really puts the ST300 in a bad position, nothing beats the shear strength and cutting ability of the ST300 (sog not included, I have those as well and while the cutters are great, the pliers excellent, the tools just aren't the same as LM or Vic).
I alternate between my swisstool and my ST300 for work (cable/telecom tech), and on swisstool days I always carry my dikes. ST300 days the dikes stay in my truck.
However, I never leave home without some form of SAK anymore. Swisschamp, super tinker, tinker or CT34. They're just too perfect for pocket carry.
Add a SAK with your ST300 if wire cutting is important, and you won't be disappointed. Get a set of good dikes if the spirit will be a daily thing and you cut wire as often as I do.
+1

-
Basically it comes down to this:
If you need the best pliers and cutters, go with SOG
If you want great drivers, awesome blades and the best awl on the market, Vic.
If you prefer a great all-around tool, one of the higher quality LM tools.
However, your choice in the above should directly affect, but not cancel the carry of a SAK.
That's my sincere opinion, YMMV.
Oh, and then there's gerber.
-
I actually ordered a SOG powerlock three days before getting the X
-
@Dale said:
I actually ordered a SOG powerlock three days before getting the XI like my powerlock. Good tool. Just takes a backseat to my big LM stuff and my swisstool nowadays. I carried that powerlock for over a year and beat it to hell plenty. I even dropped it from a telephone pole once. Still works fine.
-
I actually ordered a SOG powerlock three days before getting the X
I like my powerlock. Good tool. Just takes a backseat to my big LM stuff and my swisstool nowadays. I carried that powerlock for over a year and beat it to hell plenty. I even dropped it from a telephone pole once. Still works fine.
Whats the little sprocket looking deal up by the pliers?
-
Well Dale i guess you have now met the Swiss Mob. I have a love hate relation ship with the Swiss stuff. My opinion is they are way rated. I own over thirty SAKs and like them all right but dont see what all the fuse is about. I have had several Swiss Tools that had loose plier pivots, tool componet lock up that had lots of vertical and horizonal play. I know that not all Swiis Tools were like the ones I've encounted. But that is my experience with them and I'm unimpressed with all the bravo sierra about swiss quality. I did not think your post was trolling but ome of the swiss folks here have thin skin as you have now found out. I hope they settle down and you can enjoy youself. MTO is a good place. :D
-
Thanks David, after rereading it I could see what they were saying. Not unlike the Surefire cult in other forums. But oh well... Live & let live,

-
I actually ordered a SOG powerlock three days before getting the X
I like my powerlock. Good tool. Just takes a backseat to my big LM stuff and my swisstool nowadays. I carried that powerlock for over a year and beat it to hell plenty. I even dropped it from a telephone pole once. Still works fine.
Whats the little sprocket looking deal up by the pliers?
That keeps the handles in time while opening. Makes for a smooth open/close. Contrary to popular belief that's actually NOT the compound leverage. The added leverage comes from the pliers having a second point of motion. There was a really good thread on it in the SOG forum not too long ago.
-
</topic/46265
-
Good article, very informative. Interesting how the two seperate pivot points increase leverage
-
@David said:
Well Dale i guess you have now met the Swiss Mob. I have a love hate relation ship with the Swiss stuff. My opinion is they are way rated. I own over thirty SAKs and like them all right but dont see what all the fuse is about. I have had several Swiss Tools that had loose plier pivots, tool componet lock up that had lots of vertical and horizonal play. I know that not all Swiis Tools were like the ones I've encounted. But that is my experience with them and I'm unimpressed with all the bravo sierra about swiss quality. I did not think your post was trolling but ome of the swiss folks here have thin skin as you have now found out. I hope they settle down and you can enjoy youself. MTO is a good place. :DWell put David. I personally have owned two brand new Swiss Tools and was not nearly as impressed with their quality as many others are. One of my Swiss Tools was very nice, it did have an impressive snap when closing the tools and it was an all around good tool. The other one that I had was a POS in my opinion! The primary knife blade on my brand new Swiss Tool Spirit X came in contact with part of the frame when the blade was closed which dinged the blade edge every sing time. Unacceptable for a tool that retails for over $110! Now I'm not saying that every Swiss Tool is junk, I just happened to get a lemon I believe. I'm sure the same thing happens with Leatherman, SOG, Gerber, etc, but it really turned me off on the Victorinox brand all together. I do also own a couple SAKs, one Wenger & one Victorinox, they are cute little knives and I can really see why people collect them. I tried carrying one daily and they just didn't do it for me. I much prefer one of my Leatherman Waves or Charges as my EDC tool. But, to each their own.

-
Swiss Mob?
I think the OP asked about SAKs and why people like them so they told him. Only one ? post found the post suspicious but that was cleared quickly.
The OP has bought a few multitools and should be able to decide what he likes.
I am not fond of the swisstools as I find them too nice looking but it does not mean that I can not see why some people like them. For me the ST300 is a better tool; for me.
The good thing about this forum is that, at least so far, there have not been any strong signs of fan-boys, mob culture etc. most people here own and use a variety of tools, appreciating each tool for what it is rather than where it is made and who told them to buy it.
-
I think the main points and cons and pros have been mentioned.
All I want to add is a friendly hello and welcome to MT.O.
My main MT at work is a Gerber MP 600, but I use SAKs alot as complimenting tool. It´s handy, can be used in public without raised eyebrows and packs a lot for it´s size. And it´s easier to slice fruit with it - and tastes better then with my MP 600 which has seen all sorts of dirt, grime and liquids.If you still don´t own one, PM me your address and I´ll send you a used Spartan.
It´s the same tool configuration as the first Swiss Officers Knife and somehow teh starting point of the SAK itself and of many collections.
Then you can decide for yourself if the followers are just raving or if you choose to become one of them yourself. -
Swiss Spirit is a good one. They are built well and will rarely rust. One warning, they are slick when wet, greasy or oily.
that's us mobile
-
Welcome Dale and nice to meet you
Why a SAK? "tool-box in your pocket" that has a lifetime warranty and super rust resistant and extremely compact that makes me feel "prepared" (boy-scout lingo) ;)I loved my Spirit for a long time but over time found I didn't need pliers or cutters and nowadays I just carry a SAK & flashlight in a pouch:

Champion Plus & Ultra Fire B3 (such a small bright little light) -
Yeah good choice kirky
although in my Backpack ive got my sidekick as backup to my s2 ,i really like the s2 as is a good urban edc and lies flat in my pocket on a dangler 
As for vic quality vs lm there is no competition vics are spot on,my s2 for example is functional but has a few issues like the tin opener needs pushing into place when closing, plus had to file the tin opener to make it cut better ,you dont get these issues with victorinox as for sog there files suck and lm's diamond file rocks

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login