Appreciation for the Explorer
-
@Luna Knife said:
I much prefer my 2 explorers(grey mag glass and clear mag glass with plus scales) to the yeoman Ive owned for a few hours. So much is to be said about the 2 tools instead of the combo tool.
After carrying knives with a combo tool for years, recently my opinion has changed to reflect yours. It's three tools, BTW...don't forget about the awl.
+1
And small blade. So much better SAK with just 1 more layer Explorer is apsolute winner. -
@Luna Knife said:
I much prefer my 2 explorers(grey mag glass and clear mag glass with plus scales) to the yeoman Ive owned for a few hours. So much is to be said about the 2 tools instead of the combo tool.
After carrying knives with a combo tool for years, recently my opinion has changed to reflect yours. It's three tools, BTW...don't forget about the awl.
+1
And small blade. So much better SAK with just 1 more layer Explorer is apsolute winner.
Indeed.However, I do find that the Yeoman is noticeably more pocket friendly than the Explorer. If I am pairing the SAK with another multitool having an awl and screwdrivers, I will carry it instead.
-
@Luna Knife said:
I much prefer my 2 explorers(grey mag glass and clear mag glass with plus scales) to the yeoman Ive owned for a few hours. So much is to be said about the 2 tools instead of the combo tool.
After carrying knives with a combo tool for years, recently my opinion has changed to reflect yours. It's three tools, BTW...don't forget about the awl.
+1
And small blade. So much better SAK with just 1 more layer Explorer is apsolute winner.
Indeed.However, I do find that the Yeoman is noticeably more pocket friendly than the Explorer. If I am pairing the SAK with another multitool having an awl and screwdrivers, I will carry it instead.
The scientist on the other hand, is as about as slim as a waiter and compared to the yeoman, you only lose the scizzors and awl
-
@Luna Knife said:
I much prefer my 2 explorers(grey mag glass and clear mag glass with plus scales) to the yeoman Ive owned for a few hours. So much is to be said about the 2 tools instead of the combo tool.I also prefer the two separate tools. They're infinitely more useful than a combo tool.
-
@Luna Knife said:
I much prefer my 2 explorers(grey mag glass and clear mag glass with plus scales) to the yeoman Ive owned for a few hours. So much is to be said about the 2 tools instead of the combo tool.
I also prefer the two separate tools. They're infinitely more useful than a combo tool.
I agree. Except for the 108 mm. combo, it simply looks somewhat flimsy to me.
-
@Luna Knife said:
[quote author=Luna Knife link=topic=42876.msg839391#msg839391 date=1391303514]
I much prefer my 2 explorers(grey mag glass and clear mag glass with plus scales) to the yeoman Ive owned for a few hours. So much is to be said about the 2 tools instead of the combo tool.After carrying knives with a combo tool for years, recently my opinion has changed to reflect yours. It's three tools, BTW...don't forget about the awl.
+1
And small blade. So much better SAK with just 1 more layer Explorer is apsolute winner.
Indeed.However, I do find that the Yeoman is noticeably more pocket friendly than the Explorer. If I am pairing the SAK with another multitool having an awl and screwdrivers, I will carry it instead.
The scientist on the other hand, is as about as slim as a waiter and compared to the yeoman, you only lose the scizzors and awl
[/quote]True, or you could go the Passenger route and, compared the Explorer you only lose the scissors and hook, and keep the openers and awl.
Yeoman, Passenger, Scientist... These are all some of my favorite SAKs, and it's a shame that the Explorer is the only one still produced from the same family!
-
@Wilfried said:
I agree. Except for the 108 mm. combo, it simply looks somewhat flimsy to me.I really liked the Compact when I first picked it up. The combo tool made an excellent can opener, which I needed almost every day. Unfortunately, the first time I really cranked a tough screw...
Anyway, now that I'm comfortably out of the construction labourer business, I'm trying to talk myself out of carrying a Victorinox with a saw. I love the saw to pieces, but have only used it twice since September, and my satchel has a Rebar and Forester in it anyway. I'm thining of an Exporer or a Climber. I've always kind of liked the idea of having the magnifying glass...
-
Like some others on here my thinking as evolved on the Yeoman a bit from use of many different SAKs. However for me the Yeoman is still a great knife, and I still love it for what it is.
For one, I've never been impressed with the drivers on a SAK. I've grown up from electronics to computers and general tinker'r. I've always used quality hand tools, and my tool kit is stocked with really nice drivers, and I recently even updated a few of them and replaced a couple I had from when I was a kid in my early teens as the edges were damaged from my own heavy use, and sometimes abuse. The SAK flat screwdriver is several times too wide for any screws I tend to want to fiddle with.
As mentioned also if the SAK is paired with another tool, the considerations can change quite a bit. The real sad thing is the reduction in the number of different models which means they each become a bit more homogenized making them less ideal in more situations even if they cover a wider variety of situations.
One thing I've really come to appreciate is the small blade on a SAK. So to me this might be the most important difference. In fact, as mentioned in by others in other threads, I'm coming to think that Victorinox should offer models with the option of a serrated small blade. If there is any one simple change to the Explorer than would improve it, it would be a small serrated blade. It would have been so cool if the C.E. Explorer had both a Damascus main blade and a serrated small blade... or even a serrated Damascus small blade.
The inline Phillips driver on a SAK while too soft and not good for precision equipment, does get some use by me and since the world has not outlawed this rediculus drive system and while the incompatible variations continue to expand the original out-dated version continues to be used. As such having such a driver handy can be useful.
The larger driver is also so outdated and too soft, but other than the blades and the cap-lifter I feel all the other SAK tools are just tools to be used as is required at the time. In this light, the cap-lifter is a useful tool, an it can be modified into more specific tools more easily as needed. The combo tool is a much better cap-lifter, but not as good a general thing-a-ma-jig tool for other uses.
The magnifier is also a less versitile tool, but I like it for what it is. I tend to like SAKs with a Magnifier even though it fits in a rather wide layer.
A reamer (even the 91mm version) is a very useful tool, the 93mm version is the best. In fact I used the 93mm version a lot, more like a small blade for package opening and other stuff. It actually taught me how useful the small blade on a 91mm SAK would be as I often use to carry those without one. When I didn't have a 93mm Alox on me I missed the small-blade or Reamer.
So the summary is that I like my Yeomans, they pair great, and they are quite slim when that is what I need. Often a Yeoman is all I personally need. Based on other knives I've carried and used I believe I will like the Explorer, although I've never EDC'd one before and never even used one much as I tended to use the Champion plus or other lage knife when I needed a mag glass or I used a Yeoman. Since I have the best Yeoman in the world (custom Bushido's Ti) it's hard to not pick that up when I need a mag glass.
I was planning on writing about my year+ with the Battle Series Climber that some how ended up replacing Alox as my EDC, and now ending up with the C.E. Explorer as my EDC for at least a year. However; I'm not likely to get to that, because it just sort of happened I didn't plan it that way it was not a choice based much on needs at all. Except I need scissors, my EDC must have good scissors. I also almost always have a Spirit with-in reach, I always have my keychain vagabond. At least 1/2 the year I probably have a 111mm Soldier on me in my coat pocket. It's possible I might have others on any given day. MY EDC though is in my pants pocket, usually dedicated pocket. Anyway I forgot what i was going to say that was actually on topic, it had something to do with why I'm carrying the Explorer, and why I'm quite sure I'll be happy with it, and that is even though I love the Alox knives... in fact I'm going to go open a package from Syph007.

-
@ICanFixThat said:
The combo tool is a much better cap-lifterHow so? My experience with the two tools over many years has shown that the dedicated cap lifter works better for me.
-
Also the less layers you have, the more the Sak flexes when you use the screw drivers. For me any less than 4 layers and the Sak feels a lot less solid.
-
The combo tool is a much better cap-lifter
How so? My experience with the two tools over many years has shown that the dedicated cap lifter works better for me.
My experience is the standard cap-lifter usually takes two passes to complete the job, the combo tool seems to slip less often more often getting it done in one go.
-
The combo tool is a much better cap-lifter
How so? My experience with the two tools over many years has shown that the dedicated cap lifter works better for me.
My experience is the standard cap-lifter usually takes two passes to complete the job, the combo tool seems to slip less often more often getting it done in one go.
Oddly, my experience is exactly the opposite. It must be a difference in technique...
-
My alox explorer is on the way!
-
-
papercut

-
very cool

-
Looking good.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



