Can Opener question
-
Then hypothetically if I managed to attach a P51 to a LM then that would be best?
-
Hmmmmm, interesting. I am not sure. It sounds good on paper anyways. I might have to try this. Might make a good replacement for the SOG can openers.
I think you are on to something.that's us mobile
-
Please let me know if you do, I would be really interested in the results :)
-
The fast take-away: No, you are not better off putting a P-51 in a Leatherman.
For the amount of time it takes to open a can, they are about equal.
In timed tests, it took me about 26 seconds with either. I could probably improve the time on the Leatherman with practice.
However, the can opener on the Leatherman is a good deal more robust. The P-38 and P-51 are almost 'flimsy'. I wouldn't trust either of them long-term, and while debating the merits of can openers has become something of a hilarious obsession for some of us, I think I could safely say that no one would want to try to use a P-51 long-term. The problem isn't just the improved leverage with the Leatherman, meaning less strain on the hand. It's also that the metal of the P-51 is thinner, more likely to fail, and the hinged joint is a real weak point in the design. The P-38 and P-51 are intentionally disposable, and not up to the standards of a Leatherman can opener.
My 2 cents. Take it as you will.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
The fast take-away: No, you are not better off putting a P-51 in a Leatherman.For the amount of time it takes to open a can, they are about equal.
In timed tests, it took me about 26 seconds with either. I could probably improve the time on the Leatherman with practice.
However, the can opener on the Leatherman is a good deal more robust. The P-38 and P-51 are almost 'flimsy'. I wouldn't trust either of them long-term, and while debating the merits of can openers has become something of a hilarious obsession for some of us, I think I could safely say that no one would want to try to use a P-51 long-term. The problem isn't just the improved leverage with the Leatherman, meaning less strain on the hand. It's also that the metal of the P-51 is thinner, more likely to fail, and the hinged joint is a real weak point in the design. The P-38 and P-51 are intentionally disposable, and not up to the standards of a Leatherman can opener.
My 2 cents. Take it as you will.
This is exactly what I needed to hear, the response was really detailed and complete, thank you so much. :)
-
Still gonna give it a try on my SOG. My dad has carried the same P38 for 30 years. He got that thing when he joined the USAF. That thing has opened more rations and cans that I can shake a stick at.
that's us mobile
-
ducttapetach, I'll be interested to see how it works out for you. Keep us posted.
Cogito, you're welcome.
Feel free to read some of the (almost hilarious in its intensity) discussions on can openers on these boards.
Can Opener Test
</topic/36802Can openers: Times on 15oz can
</topic/37059Can openers: Times on the #10
</topic/37059The vic can opener 'upstroke cut' tested
</topic/50122AND
Luna Knife's series
SAK Can Opener Test - DAY 1
</topic/50105Can Opener Test - Day 2
</topic/50119Can Opener Test - Day 3
</topic/50149Can Opener Test day 4 - and all future days
</topic/50177 -
hmm, that is very interesting. The videos of you and your friends opening cans didn't work for me. I've been sitting here trying to figure out why the LM openers leave metal spinters, but for the life of me I can't figure it out. Any ideas?
-
The videos in the 15oz can thread don't work because that youtube account has been deleted. It got deleted because I once logged into youtube on a friend's computer, who then named MY account after herself. Stupid. Anyway, nothing in them but me opening cans, and the times I came up with are listed in the text, so nothing of importance lost. Sorry for any confusion.
The metal splinters was also mentioned by Xelkos in this post (on the first thread I posted previously)
</post/715948>I think The reason the vic can opener doesn't leave as many marks on the can is due to the angle of the blade. I've had both Leatherman and vic mar the outside of the can (along the rim), although it's certainly more prevalent with the Leatherman.
-
Anyone tried sharpening the LM can opener to do other simple cutting tasks? Like ripping cardboard boxes, destroying random stuff. etc?
-
My buddy sharpened the inner flat on the can opener. Made it pretty sharp actually, and works decently as a cord cutter.
-
@sticktodrum said:
My buddy sharpened the inner flat on the can opener. Made it pretty sharp actually, and works decently as a cord cutter.can your buddy still use it as a can opener?
-
Yessir.
-
P51 will fit on a keychain and will always be there. Leatherman is stong and provides more leverage.:tool:
:D -
Personally I prefer the Victorinox can opener to the LM but I prefer the P38 over both. I have a P38 that I have owned since 1972. Don't know how many cans I have opened with it in the last 40 years but quite a few. While it does look and feel flimsy, it just keeps working!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login