Victorinox
-
Hi MRV. Welcome aboard!

Check with felinevet. He typically has a lot of used SAKs at very reasonable prices; that lets you play around with different models without breaking the bank.
A personal favorite of mine for outdoor use is the Vic Huntsman, but think about what you'll be doing and what tools will come in handy.
http://www.edcsource.com/FELINEVET-SWISS-ARMY-KNIFE-STORE,name,100015,user_id,shop
-
OK, I'll take a stab at these one at a time.
@MRVictorinox said:
I like the Ranger and Swisschamp. But which should I choose for camping?Of the two, I would personally probably choose the Ranger for camping. The Swisschamp is about 60% heavier and 50% wider, but I don't feel this additional weight and bulk is justified (in a camping scenario) by the utility of the extra tools on the Swisschamp (pliers, fish scaler/ruler/hook disgorger, Phillips screwdriver, and magnifying glass) that are not on the Ranger. YMMV, however.
@MRVictorinox said:
Where can I get the best deal?It varies. The internet makes comparison shopping ridiculously easy though.
@MRVictorinox said:
Are there any other knives that are great for camping? Which one do you recommend?There are many good options, and in the end much of it comes down to personal preference. By way of a generally applicable approach, I'll suggest the concept of a modern Nessmuk trio. You can Google "Nessmuk trio" for much more information, but essentially the idea is that you have three cutting implements of varying sizes, at least one of which should theoretically be suitable for virtually any realistic cutting task while out camping:
-
folding/pocket knife (or MT) - A SAK is a great choice for this, IMO.
-
medium size (3"-5") fixed blade - One can easily spend a couple hundred dollars on a top quality blade in this category. If you're looking to start out with something serviceable that won't break the bank, I would recommend Mora knives.
-
hatchet, small axe, large fixed blade, machete, or folding saw - This tool is primarily for firewood processing, and specific selection depends on both personal preference and the flora in the area in which it will be used.
-
-
Hi MrV
Nice name - Although I am surprised you're are asking a question like this with a name like that!!+1 for the Huntsman from me - (Surprise, surprise)
Brilliant all round SAK - Great tool combination to size/weight ratio.
The saw is very useful in the backwoods.Big consideration is - Will you be carrying the tool (and the rest of your kit) a lot - eg back packing?
If so the Champ is probably way too big IMHO.If you are mainly driving to base camp and won't be carrying your tool you may want to consider something bigger like a Wenger Ranger (for the bigger blades). Great knives BTW
If you'll have other (mechanical) work to do at the campsite you may be better with a Multitool with pliers (eg fixing bent poles etc)
If you are ice climbing on your trips - you'll want a file to sharpen ice tools ::)As Fatts said - First check what tools are available (blades, tool types, size etc )
Then think about what you need on a tool by tool basis
Then find the make and model that has that toolset !! -
Personally, I am biased towards Swisschamp since it is such an iconic Victorinox flagship product. But Huntsman is more practical for day-to-day EDC purpose and you can't go wrong with it.
In terms of camping and outdoor, one of my favorite folding knife/tool is gonna be the 111mm One-hand-opening Plain-edge Trekker. It has all the tools I need and a lockable larger blade than the standard 91mm.
-
I got a ridiculous amount of hard use out of my Ranger, including many outdoor pursuits. It is an excellent tool.
-
-
I got a ridiculous amount of hard use out of my Ranger, including many outdoor pursuits. It is an excellent tool.
Oh,and he got a wee bit of use from a Huntsman called Vicky

Oh my yes.
But the tool density of the Ranger is phenomenal for such a relatively compact model. I used it for two years before circumstances led me to a slimmer carry.
-
@comis said:
Personally, I am biased towards Swisschamp since it is such an iconic Victorinox flagship product. But Huntsman is more practical for day-to-day EDC purpose and you can't go wrong with it.In terms of camping and outdoor, one of my favorite folding knife/tool is gonna be the 111mm One-hand-opening Plain-edge Trekker. It has all the tools I need and a lockable larger blade than the standard 91mm.
Well, let's see other comments before jumping in with a 111mm One-hand-opening Plain-edge Trekker
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
So that 2 or 3 for Huntsman, maybe 1 for Ranger and ( sorry Swisschamp): 0
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
So Swisschamp is out. Only two left: Huntsman and Ranger
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
I like the Huntsman. It's a good knife.
If you don't need or want scissors, then a Camper or Hiker still give you the wood saw.
If you want to consider a slightly larger (but surprisingly not much heavier) knife, maybe consider the Rucksack.
Also, keep this in mind. Until we know a lot more about your particulars, we're spitballing ideas. YOU will ultimately have to be the person carrying this thing, and YOU will know your needs/wants better than us. Once you have a list of possible models, then look into each of them more closely. Hope this helps.
And welcome to the forums!
-
Well, how about champion plus?
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Well, this is quite simple

for camping you would choose THE SAK - SwissChamp

SwisChamp is back in the game ... btw, never heard was out
:D
Comparising Huntsman & Ranger ...

... there are only 2.4mm (0.09 inch) width difference
and only 20 grams (0.7 ounces) weight difference,
for that you get: file, metal saw, chisel and small screwdriver:

Ranger is kinda "swischamp" without above pictured SwisCamp's tools
:D -
Well, if you say so. Swisschamp is back in the game. But than it is out again. I can only afford a 70 USD SAK. I need to save money for my new BMX.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
I'd also vote swisschamp. I like the OH Trekker as well since you get a large locking blade and large saw but between the two you originally asked about I'd still say the swisschamp gets my vote. You can snag one off the bay of fleas for a decent price and after your camping adventures you'd still have a very useable SAK for whatever else you may do. I've seen them go for less than $70 routinely so that should be very easy to do. Check on our sales threads there may be one for sale.
-
@Aloha007 said:
I'd also vote swisschamp. I like the OH Trekker as well since you get a large locking blade and large saw but between the two you originally asked about I'd still say the swisschamp gets my vote. You can snag one off the bay of fleas for a decent price and after your camping adventures you'd still have a very useable SAK for whatever else you may do. I've seen them go for less than $70 routinely so that should be very easy to do. Check on our sales threads there may be one for sale.+1

-
For camping go with a leatherman sidekick! One hand opening saw and knife, plus good sized pliers. Bring some decent tweezers on the side and you are good to go :)
-
heavens...swisschamp of course!
-
I cannot afford a Swisschamp. You see, I live in Vietnam and I have looked every where looking for the best deal. But the cheapest price for Swisschamp is 85 USD!
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
@MRVictorinox said:
I cannot afford a Swisschamp. You see, I live in Vietnam and I have looked every where looking for the best deal. But the cheapest price for Swisschamp is 85 USD!Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Well, if that is the case, then you should go with (your other option) Champion, which has all SwissChamp's tools except pliers, as you have already found out.
Anyway, whichever SAK you choose, you can't go wrong. The only mistake you can do is to not have one when needed :D :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login