Surge pliers vs. Wave?
-
A lot of the time, the wave will work. But the Surge will make it easier. Like cutting heavy wire like barbed wire. Some cases the wave wont work just because it does not have the leverage that the Surge does.
-
Can you give me an example of some of those things where leverage is insufficient?
-
I had a bolt on a gate I tried to loosen and the wave pliers head just keep slipping because I couldn't get enough leverage on the handles themselves. I was just able to do it with the Surge because of the longer handles. I was able to get more grip.
But it is not just the size of the pliers that make the surge a nice tool. Longer blades, big scissors, and a blade exchanger. -
@ducttapetech said:
I had a bolt on a gate I tried to loosen and the wave pliers head just keep slipping because I couldn't get enough leverage on the handles themselves. I was just able to do it with the Surge because of the longer handles. I was able to get more grip.
But it is not just the size of the pliers that make the surge a nice tool. Longer blades, big scissors, and a blade exchanger.the sum total of the parts makes it better for me as a work tool. This by no means makes the Wave inferior as the Wave is quite the tool. I'd image the ST300 and Rebar and New Surge all are better given they have the replaceable wire cutters.
-
You are right, the Wave is by no means inferior.
-
@ducttapetech said:
You are right, the Wave is by no means inferior.Inferior, not by any means. Lighter duty, absolutely.
-
So mainly it's the handle length, like hypothetically if you swapped a rebar head into a new surge then you wouldn't really be missing anything by having the smaller plier heads.
Or if you just found a way to get longer handles on a regular wave.
-
Exactly what guys say. They can do the same thing, but I can do the chain link fence/barbed wire/farm fencing wire one handed with surge, where I had to really lean with both hands on my Charge.
Charge/wave for EDC and tough cutting/grabbing only in emergency. Surge for work where you do those things often.
-
By putting medium duty pliers in a heavy duty tool breaks your medium duty pliers more easily. Only cause of increased leverage. Old saying goes "Use right tool for the right job". Tools can only take certain amount of power, then they break.
-
@Crow said:
By putting medium duty pliers in a heavy duty tool breaks your medium duty pliers more easily. Only cause of increased leverage. Old saying goes "Use right tool for the right job". Tools can only take certain amount of power, then they break.So what would be an example that would cause the weaker pliers to break?
-
Heavy wire, bending too think of metal and so on. To much leverage on the plierhead because of longer handle. Much like using a cheater on a ratchet. To much power will bust the wrench or socket.
that's us mobile
-
It is about amount of material put in to the plier head. They are two different sized heads. Both are designed to handle certain amount of strength. Same design comes to handles.
Let us take Rebar. And rusted down bolt. You try to twist it open without luck. Cause you have not enough strength in your hands to hold it. But you did not do a scratch to the tool itself. Now you go and take two pipes that fit handles, length about one meter. Now you get good grip and great amount of leverage. Now you start to twitch screw, start to press pipes tighter. Aand snap. Was not twist motion, but leverage that you put in it.
Now, your friend has new Surge with that bigger plier. You take it and start to twitch. Good grip and leverage. Little puffing, and bolt loosens.
You did not overdo surge, as you did with rebar.That is right tool for right job.
-
In a situation like that, the right tool for the job is a wrench.
But I get your point.
-
In a situation like that, the right tool for the job is a wrench.
But I get your point.
You are right Jothra. I would not use pliers for this kind of job.
Mind you, I guess you never know when you'll end up in a situation in which your only choice is to pick the least wrong right tool for the wrong right job. Your original post makes sense when I think it through properly. Sorry about my contradictory post. Who hasn't been in a situation with nothing but a variety of multitools to choose from?
I'm not being facetious. It's happened to all of us.
Anyway, I agree that the longer Surge handles are what make it worthwhile, though a beefier set of plier jaws never hurt.
-
[/quote]
Mind you, I guess you never know when you'll end up in a situation in which your only choice is to pick the least wrong right tool for the wrong right job.
[/quote]
Hahahahahaha
-
Stupid question
does the surge use the st300 pliers head.
-
It does.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login