Leatherman vs SAK
-
They are two different things.
In general, Leatherman (and Swisstools) win in the pliers & wire cutters section. Some versions offer also twin blades (plain/ serrated) and some of them are one hand opened. Most plier centered Multitools have locking tools. And some of the tools of 4.5" multis are longer and wider than those on 91mm SAKs (but around the same as on 111-130mm SAKs. LMs have bit holders but Cybertools have also and you can use an adapter or ratchet/ wrench from Victorinox with SAKs.
SAKs have a greater selection of tools. They come in layers and one can choose as many layers as he wishes. Most SAK tools are better than those on Leathermen, like the scissors. Swisstools usually have the same or similar tools one finds on SAKs. But magnifying glass, hook, fish scaler, coke spoon etc only come with SAKs. Scale tools only come with SAKs (except tweezers with some Leathermen). SAKs are cheaper. Most SAKs are UK friendly. They have a long history and greater collectability. The general population has a better tolerance for SAKs. Quality is Swiss here. Nothing bad with US quality but Swiss is Swiss. SAK springs are legendary. SAKs are prettier. Scales give personality to standard SAKs and can be exchanged easily. Great variety, celidor, translucent, alox, bone, wood etc, stamped or engraved.
Bottom line: 4"-4.5" Leathermen can be compared to Swisstools and they are about equal. Small Leathermen (Juice, Squirts) can be compared to SAKs and SAKs win hands down. IMHO of course. -
Easy answer is buy at least one of both and try them out. Only way to know which one is for you.
Of course when speaking about tools saying that something is better than something is like the old ford and chevy war, it just has nothing to do with the tools at all, you can list 100 reasons then other will list 101 reasons and so on.
-
The best answer to this is that a SAK complements a Leatherman!
Eg,Rebar and Climber; Farmer and Fuse;
Both are very capable,and can stand individually. United though? They can face just about anything.
-
Luckily there is no rule that you have to chose. Get both. No really, they are very different.
-
If it was me I would go with a Leatherman, it's a harder use tool and the one hand opening features are a winner.
-
-
Saks and Leatherman are equals and both have strong and weak points.
that's us mobile
-
No reason to choose. They are entirely different animals. I carry both. Like mentioned above. They do well together.
-
If it was me I would go with a Leatherman, it's a harder use tool and the one hand opening features are a winner.
I'll go along with the OHO thing, but you are absolutely going to have to qualify "harder use."
Leatherman makes stronger tools and stronger equals harder use.
If you needed a stronger tool which would you pick, the SwissTool or a Supertool 300? -
I believe you do need to try out a tool to really get a feel for what that tool can do and where it falls short for you . There is no competition between a SAK and plier based MT as they both fill the needs of their owners. It's kinda like asking should you get a dog or a cat. The cat lovers will tell you all the great things about them and the dog lover will tell you how great dogs are.
What role are you looking to fill with the tool you are contemplating? Is this for camping? I have come to the conclusion in my world that a SAK and a Plier based MT need to be paired and a dedicated knife is an added layer. I kept hearing about the Swisstools and how amazing they are, THEY ARE. I heard that once I got one I'd understand how they are built to a higher standard, true yet again. I decided I needed to have one a got a Swisstool and carried it for a while and was amazed, I now have several ( 7 ) and while initially I really thought the Spirit and Swisstool were gonna boot my LMs out of my pocket but I was wrong and the Surge and Wave occupy that space. They are great tools no doubt but for my needs the Wave then the Surge really do it for me. ( SEE MR WHIPPY's thread about his Spirit and LM ALX ).
Its so hard to tell anyone what to get or what tool is best because like dogs and cats there are so many options once you do decide what you want, dog or cat. I have a mut dog and he is perfect for me. I like to think a larger dog would be awesome but I know my little guy ( 3 lbs ) is perfect for me.
I have a Swisschamp and a Explorer and a Deluxe Tinker that see a lot of pocket time. These last few weeks/months I have come to realize I really like the Deluxe Tinker vs Explorer but not as much as my Swisschamp. I had a Champion Plus but it never saw pocket time so I traded it. I have many other SAKs but they dont see much pocket time as a result of getting the SwissChamp.
I sure hope after some time you pull the trigger on something so you can begin the process or figuring out what tool works for you. Are you somewhere that these tools are hard to come by or expensive?
-
If it was me I would go with a Leatherman, it's a harder use tool and the one hand opening features are a winner.
I'll go along with the OHO thing, but you are absolutely going to have to qualify "harder use."
Leatherman makes stronger tools and stronger equals harder use.
If you needed a stronger tool which would you pick, the SwissTool or a Supertool 300?There. We can qualify the statement by adding that Leatherman makes some stronger tools, which is a reasonable point.
I'm a fan of either, anyway. The best tool is the one you enjoy carrying, because that means it's always with you. Even though I carry a Victorinox Climber these days (which covers about 99.9% of my tool needs), I always keep a Leatherman Rebar nearby (along with a Victorinox OH Forester), because every once in awhile I could really use some pliers or a saw in a hurry.
-
It's like saying is a claw hammer better than a ball hammer. You can to 80% of the same stuff with both, but each has their specialties.
Just have both :P I pocket carry a Leatherman and have a SAK in my backpack as a backup.
-
I must have a screw loose (no pun), because I agonize over this kind of stuff. So I have an Explorer Plus in my pocket for the SAK half of that equation, and a Style PS for the (mini) plier component.
-
So let's vote. Leatherman vs Swisschamp. Don't explain anything. Just +1 for Swisschamp or Leatherman. If you just want to say "get both" or "no reason to choose", thì phắn đi
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Maybe you want to add a poll to the topic and that would be easier.
-
Phắn đi
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
I agree with many have said earlier, and as long as they are good tools, there will always be a supporting camp for each tool.
And quoting what Lynn said in another thread, it is after all what do you need and what are your tool using habit that will dictates the outcome. Whatever most popular is just...errr..popular, doesn't mean it is the best match for you.
Would you mind to share with us exactly how you would intend to use your tools? Or is it more for collecting purposes? :D
-
@MRVictorinox said:
Phắn điSent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Does this mean differentiate? Google translate lets me down once in a while. If so, what are you trying to find the difference between?
-
An interesting question... that's like Left vs Right, Mom vs Dad, bacon vs cheese...
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
