Leatherman vs SAK
-
As many have said, the best way is to pair them up
I started off as a Leatherman guy, and they met my needs fine. Then I decided to try a SAK, and that was it for me. I would almost dare say at this point that I am more of a SAK person, but they lack pliers and there are other things about a Leatherman that I like to have nearby. Still, on a typical day for me, a SAK is more than enough, but I still prefer to have a Leatherman on me as well, for the pliers at the very least. -
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
My answer is that you need both. I carry a Wave and a Rambler and wouldn't leave home without either one. My favorite SAK is the CT41 and that is extremely capable! If you were to ask which makes the best MT however, I would say LM. Although the Swisstools are nice, they don't compare to LM, IMO.
-
@Dale said:
No reason to choose. They are entirely different animals. I carry both. Like mentioned above. They do well together.I have nothing substantial to add, but boy, did we spoil Dale good or what? :D
Came here what feels like only days ago, asking what the fuss about SAKs was about, and look at him now - enabling others...

and, although mentioned a few times: Get both is the usual answer around here. They are indeed hard to compare.
-
Actually, I can only afford one if I want to keep my budget in shape
Tommy Nhat
-
@MRVictorinox said:
Actually, I can only afford one if I want to keep my budget in shapeTommy Nhat
Yeah thats what you say now, if you want to keep your budget in shape get out of here FAST

If you want a better suggestion have you at least narrowed your preference to some specific leatherman and saks (vic or wenger) so it would be easier to suggest something.
-
No reason to choose. They are entirely different animals. I carry both. Like mentioned above. They do well together.
I have nothing substantial to add, but boy, did we spoil Dale good or what? :D
Came here what feels like only days ago, asking what the fuss about SAKs was about, and look at him now - enabling others...

and, although mentioned a few times: Get both is the usual answer around here. They are indeed hard to compare.
I have no idea what your talking about... enabler... PPSSSTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

My daily carry.... Missing the Gerber Flik on my belt...

-
So... what I'm seeing here isn't 'which is better?' More like 'If you could only have one tool, what would it be'?
Do I have that about right.
All things considered, price, mass, tool selection, ruggedness, everything.
Leatherman Rebar.
Unless there's a massive weight constraint.
But I stick with the answer. For the weight, tools selection, cost, value-for-dollar (when you really go hunting for a bargain price), Rebar wins.
It's not the cheapest tool out there that I think is good, but I think it's the cheapest tool that most everyone agrees is excellent.
An equal amount of money doesn't get you as much function from a Vic, IMO.
This opinion is of course not knowing anything about your needs.
Leatherman +1
EDIT: Holy Crap, a straight answer!

-
@Lynn LeFey said:
So... what I'm seeing here isn't 'which is better?' More like 'If you could only have one tool, what would it be'?Do I have that about right.
All things considered, price, mass, tool selection, ruggedness, everything.
Leatherman Rebar.
Unless there's a massive weight constraint.
But I stick with the answer. For the weight, tools selection, cost, value-for-dollar (when you really go hunting for a bargain price), Rebar wins.
It's not the cheapest tool out there that I think is good, but I think it's the cheapest tool that most everyone agrees is excellent.
An equal amount of money doesn't get you as much function from a Vic, IMO.
This opinion is of course not knowing anything about your needs.
Leatherman +1
EDIT: Holy Crap, a straight answer!

But no scissors or fish scaler :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
So... what I'm seeing here isn't 'which is better?' More like 'If you could only have one tool, what would it be'?Do I have that about right.
All things considered, price, mass, tool selection, ruggedness, everything.
Leatherman Rebar.
Unless there's a massive weight constraint.
But I stick with the answer. For the weight, tools selection, cost, value-for-dollar (when you really go hunting for a bargain price), Rebar wins.
It's not the cheapest tool out there that I think is good, but I think it's the cheapest tool that most everyone agrees is excellent.
An equal amount of money doesn't get you as much function from a Vic, IMO.
This opinion is of course not knowing anything about your needs.
Leatherman +1
EDIT: Holy Crap, a straight answer!

If you'd like pliers, I agree 100%. I think I even like the Rebar more than my old (substantially more expensive) Wave...and I loved that Wave.
Two! Two straight answers!
-
It may also be helpful to distinguish between needs and wants. I almost never "need" pliers, but I still don't want to be without them. There is much psychology going on here, but that's for another thread.
-
@powernoodle said:
It may also be helpful to distinguish between needs and wants. I almost never "need" pliers, but I still don't want to be without them. There is much psychology going on here, but that's for another thread.Try using pliers as an extension to your hand for 1 whole day :) Opening doors with pliers, eating using pliers, you'll have a lot of fun and learn stuff too :D
-
It may also be helpful to distinguish between needs and wants. I almost never "need" pliers, but I still don't want to be without them. There is much psychology going on here, but that's for another thread.
Try using pliers as an extension to your hand for 1 whole day :) Opening doors with pliers, eating using pliers, you'll have a lot of fun and learn stuff too :D
Peeing with pliers.. Wiping your bum with pliers..
Uh huh, no thanks.
-
It may also be helpful to distinguish between needs and wants. I almost never "need" pliers, but I still don't want to be without them. There is much psychology going on here, but that's for another thread.
Try using pliers as an extension to your hand for 1 whole day :) Opening doors with pliers, eating using pliers, you'll have a lot of fun and learn stuff too :D
Peeing with pliers.. Wiping your bum with pliers..
Uh huh, no thanks.
Try it, you'll have a lot of fun :D Typing on the keyboard with pliers and especially when you need to use a multi tool while using pliers as hands :D
-
I did a little comparison a few years ago: </post/197242>
-
@Gareth said:
I did a little comparison a few years ago: /post/197242Thanks Gareth. Good information. According to your review, I guess I will go with the SAK. I go camping anyway
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Well not everyone agrees with me, but I do indeed prefer a SAK as a compact camping tool. My Personal favourites are a Victorinox Huntsman or a Wenger Evo 17. :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

