How does Victorinox do it ....
-
@kent ct said:
I have thought about this too. I believe that when you reach a certain level of production more and more can be automated with specially built machines.To get to that level though a huge customer base is needed and Vic has spent 100 years getting that base and fine tuning production. It also does not hurt to have a product that appeals to large numbers of people and to foster that appeal with new products carefully thought out.
German mechanical clocks now are dominant. The Japanese tried. The South Koreans tried and they both failed, primarily with quality control.
American mid price watches were once the best by far in the world. Nobody could compete. The American watch industry invented revolutionary machines. The lathe collet and the precision grinder were two ideas that led to whole new machines. I think it was Gruen that first imported American watch tools to Switzerland and together with a skilled work force gradually caught up. It took about 50 years though. The English who were responsible for most of the major design improvements and once led the world could not keep up despite having genius's like Maudslay, Roberts and Whitworth who along with others launched the industrial revolution.
Everybody knows the story of Ford who once produced half the worlds cars. Alloy steel and the production line.
No matter how cheap your labor is or how skilled,a man with a file can't keep up with a milling machine.
Richard
Very interesting post
, and probably very true too, but let's not forget good ole fashioned pride and reputation :)I doubt Vic would even consider letting a bellow par tool off the drawing board, let alone out of the factory! :)
-
when I first got into MTs (seriously) I went to a store that had many brands and
tried them all out, got a feel for them and Swisstools really stuck out! I'm not knocking
the others (not here anyway) they all have good points but when something (or someone)
really impresses you, you gotta go for it/her! -
I have had hundreds of Victorinox knives here and have seen most from the inside out and am still amazed how well the QC department had done.
Out of maybe 500 or 600 knives I've taken apart, I have found exactly 2 with QC problems (both OHT's) with pins that didn't get peened on one side.
That's it! I have seen slight differences on blade edge grinds as well, but nothing that wouldn't cut well.
Simply amazing for the number of parts involved.
-
Wegner doesn't impress me much , aside from the S.I. , but Vicki. RAWKS !
Chris
-
I love the design and functional capabilities of Leathermans but am always in awe of the quality of Victorinox. Usually products that have the quality of a Vic should cost 2 or 3 times as much for the equivalent.
-
@ultimaonliner said:
Usually products that have the quality of a Vic should cost 2 or 3 times as much for the equivalent.Can't argue with that :)
-
No other company has magical dwarves that live under the Alps making knives for them like Victorinox does- that's how they can manage to crank them out that good!
Def
-
@Defender said:
No other company has magical dwarves that live under the Alps making knives for them like Victorinox does- that's how they can manage to crank them out that good!Def
So how do we get the magical dwarves to magically put a pocket clip on the Swisstool Spirit? I'll take mine in Black Oxide. :D
-
You need to make an offering of fresh fruits and buxom, bearded lasses, but beware, the dwarves can be a cantankerous lot when forced to speak the tongues of Man...
Def
-
They know what they're doing, thats for sure. I've owned vic s.a.k's for years and always have been impressed with their clever design and quality steel. Now I am in posession of a spirit and soon a swisstool rs after owning a couple of leathermen my admiration is at a new level for the product. The design, manufacture and quality is second to none, at a great price! If only they made other products. Imagine how good a victorinox rifle would be, or a car! ::)
-
The Swiss Army Rifle... not a bad idea.

Seriously, Vic would probably just rebrand a quality company (like they did with Inova)
-
Wegner doesn't impress me much , aside from the S.I. , but Vicki. RAWKS !
Chris
Vic owns Wenger now. You might want to give them another look.
Particularly the New Rangers and the Alinghi.Yes, Wenger has definitely started coming out with many products that are both very exciting and high quality. And I think they will just keep getting better.
Hopefully, the Vic / Wenger relationship will push both companies to aspire to new heights and a new golden age of SAKdom! :D
-
I can't wait until Vic decides to say "F--- it, let's just buy out Leatherman Tool Group" and start producing some awesome Leathermans :)
-
You mean like this?
-
I like my Spirits, but I think Tim Leatherman would have started drug testing his employees if somebody in his company recommended the butterknife shaped blade :)
I like Leatherman's designs, but love Vic's consistent quality.
-
@ultimaonliner said:
I think Tim Leatherman would have started drug testing his employees if somebody in his company recommended the butterknife shaped blade :)Hehe, let's not forget the Flair... :D
Personally, though, I think Vic does what they do by...
1-making a huge volume
2-having a worldwide reputation
3-having good management
4-not inovatingThat last one might seem a bit rough, but I do think it's a big part of how they keep their *cost down * and their consistancy up. Most of their knives are essentially the same pieces in different combinations. And their Swisstools were essentially a Swiss copy of someone elses design. The OH knives and the Spirit seem like the most inovation they've done recently, and even those take proven ideas and just tweak them a bit. If it hadn't been for the Spydercos and Leathermans, I highly doubt Vic would have inovated beyond the basic SAK design yet. This is not an insult by any means, I just think that it is definetely part of the answer as to how they can keep their prices as they do.
-
@NeitherExtreme said:
1-making a huge volume
2-having a worldwide reputation
3-having good management
4-not inovatingYou forgot polishing the life out of everything they make.
That ought to be #1.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login