EOD Tools?
-
I thought of an interesting question in the Let's play a game thread: ???
@RT1969 said:
I have seen the Leatherman MUT EOD. But it is the normal steel. Is there a non-magnetic EOD Multitool?enki_ck suggested I post here, so I give it a try :)
Some mines and IED are triggered by changes in the magnetic or electric field surrounding the trigger. Prodders are therefore made from degaussed (non-magnetic) metal, so as to not trigger those mines.
I started to wonder: Is there a non-magnetic Multitool?
I can think of some other work areas where non-magnetic or non-conducting MT would be useful.Do you know of either special treated (e.g. degaussed) or made from special material (e.g. polymers) multitools?
-
@RT1969 said:
I thought of an interesting question in the Let's play a game thread: ???I have seen the Leatherman MUT EOD. But it is the normal steel. Is there a non-magnetic EOD Multitool?
enki_ck suggested I post here, so I give it a try :)
Some mines and IED are triggered by changes in the magnetic or electric field surrounding the trigger. Prodders are therefore made from degaussed (non-magnetic) metal, so as to not trigger those mines.
I started to wonder: Is there a non-magnetic Multitool?
I can think of some other work areas where non-magnetic or non-conducting MT would be useful.Do you know of either special treated (e.g. degaussed) or made from special material (e.g. polymers) multitools?
I have a vague recollection of seeing some photos of old (pre-leatherman) brass tools that were made for working with explosives somewhere here on MTo. IIRC brass was chosen because it doesn't make sparks.
-
@gregozedobe said:
IIRC brass was chosen because it** doesn't make sparks**.That is one of the specifics I did not find an english expression for. "nicht funkenschlagend" or "nicht funkenreissend" in german.
Thank you for this first answer. This sounds exactly like the kind of tools I am looking for here!
-
I used to work with flammables, and we bought and used a lot of spark-resistant tools (they were also non-magnetic, although that wasn't really important for us). Ampco (http://www.ampcosafetytools.com/) springs to mind. Of course, Mission Knives (http://www.missionknives.com/) and maybe a few others make (non-magnetic) titanium knives for EOD-type use as well.
That said, I don't believe I saw a spark-resistant MT in any of the spark-resistant tools catalogs I perused over the years. These tools are very expensive, but because the metal is not as hard or as tough as steel, they generally don't last very long relative to what a steel tool would under the same use, and may need to be beefier to achieve comparable strength to a similar steel tool. Thus, I think a non-sparking MT would be very pricey, heavy, not hold up well, and generally not sell in sufficient numbers to economically justify its manufacture.
Non-conducting (i.e. will not conduct electricity) tools are a separate topic altogether.
-
I thought of an interesting question in the Let's play a game thread: ???
I have seen the Leatherman MUT EOD. But it is the normal steel. Is there a non-magnetic EOD Multitool?
enki_ck suggested I post here, so I give it a try :)
Some mines and IED are triggered by changes in the magnetic or electric field surrounding the trigger. Prodders are therefore made from degaussed (non-magnetic) metal, so as to not trigger those mines.
I started to wonder: Is there a non-magnetic Multitool?
I can think of some other work areas where non-magnetic or non-conducting MT would be useful.Do you know of either special treated (e.g. degaussed) or made from special material (e.g. polymers) multitools?
I have a vague recollection of seeing some photos of old (pre-leatherman) brass tools that were made for working with explosives somewhere here on MTo. IIRC brass was chosen because it doesn't make sparks.
J-sews had that one in a what is it type thread.
-
The point of brass (or bronze) tools is that they are non-sparking, not that they are non-conductive in any way. They are used primarily around explosives that are initiated by sparks or static, and especially around such explosives that are not safed in their containment or incorporation into a complete explosive device. Although electricity is used to trigger most common explosive packages, it has to happen through a detonator that imparts a much higher charge to the explosive material than any low level of current would ever be capable of. This is done to protect in the assembly, transport, and use of these explosive items. You won't see artillery shells, for example, handled only around non-sparking metals, nor do most modern explosives trigger that way. Even trinitrotoluene (TNT) doesn't really trigger as easily as the movies make it appear.
As a result, an EOD typically uses basic steel tools. In plastic explosives a steel tool can create a seat for a detonator and can be used to strip, trim, crimp, etc. There's just no need to be either non-conductive or non-sparking. There are some specialized explosives, such as large cannon shells on old warships, that still use powder in bags, and those are susceptible to sparks, but they are specialty applications and almost all newer munitions including CWS, missiles, depth charges, torpedoes, etc., are made to be extremely stable. On any missile frigate, I can't think of anything that would require brass or bronze. And as for artillery shells for towed tubes, the kind of thing that are turned into IEDs regularly, they also are extremely stable without the correct type of detonator and the current required to trigger the detonator. Again, no real need for specialty tools. I've watched robots drag 150 mm artillery shells fifty feet over all kinds of metal debris as they are defusing large IEDs, and the shells don't explode. Think of all the handling those shells get and you'd understand why.
The only exception I might make comes with unexploded ordnance, which is sometimes very sensitive and unpredictable, but it's rarely defused with non-sparking tools. There are better methods that pose much less risk. A tool like the MUT EOD is made for someone rigging explosives, not really for the EOD who is responsible for deconstructing an IED or unexploded ordnance.
-
Thanks for all the insights!
I did not know that the main material for this tools would be brass. Now I see that a multitool would not be a wise decision over dedicated tools due to the soft characteristics.
@nate j said:
Non-conducting (i.e. will not conduct electricity) tools are a separate topic altogether.You are right, non conductiv was just me opening a can of worms that did not belong into this thread (Could be another thread, though).
@lanedecamp said:
The only exception I might make comes with unexploded ordnance, which is sometimes very sensitive and unpredictable, but it's rarely defused with non-sparking tools. There are better methods that pose much less risk. A tool like the MUT EOD is made for someone rigging explosives, not really for the EOD who is responsible for deconstructing an IED or unexploded ordnance.Wow. Thank you for the extensive insight into the usual EOD work

Some annotations to the bold parts:
Better methods for unexploded ordanance would involve controlled detonation, rather than defusing?
And the Leatherman MUT EOD is grossly misnamed, imho. As you said, it is just for someone working with C4.Do you have any experience with defusing mines, Anti-tank or Anti-Infantry? Seeing a doku and reading about those brought me to the question of a non-magnetic or de-gaussed tool. Some triggers seem to respond to magnetic fields. I gather modern explosives themselves do not care about sparking, magnetic or conductiv materials.
-
@RT1969 said:
Some annotations to the bold parts:
Better methods for unexploded ordanance would involve controlled detonation, rather than defusing?
And the Leatherman MUT EOD is grossly misnamed, imho. As you said, it is just for someone working with C4.Do you have any experience with defusing mines, Anti-tank or Anti-Infantry? Seeing a doku and reading about those brought me to the question of a non-magnetic or de-gaussed tool. Some triggers seem to respond to magnetic fields. I gather modern explosives themselves do not care about sparking, magnetic or conductiv materials.
You can't just blow up every IED you come across. Too often that blows up a road, an urban location, or structures that you don't want to lose. Plus they tend to come big these days and blowing them up messes up a lot of real estate.
If it's an IED, the standard method used by insurgents for detonating them is for the local insurgent to have a remote wireless trigger -- a model airplane control, a garage door opener, cell phone, etc. You try to jam these. Insurgents have responded with infrared triggers which are harder to block. Often an IED will be set weeks or months ahead, buried in a culvert or right under the road or plastered into the wall of a building, and so on. You can't clear every bit of debris or every structure when you come into a town or go down a road, after all. The most common IEDs in the Middle East have been 6-inch artillery shells, American ones. A large number fail to detonate after firing, and tend to be fairly stable once landed (we make them that way so they don't pose unnatural risk to civilians or to EODs after the fact), so large numbers of them are wired together and they make very effective IEDs because of the shrapnel they produce. New technologies can actually shut down any receiver on the IED so it can't be triggered by remote. That, plus jamming, plus other similar technologies help limit the risk. New sensors that can spot explosives help as well.
If it's unexploded ordnance, you can freeze the fuse so it can't move (an old technique from before World War II), etc. Frankly, most modern nations (who are dropping most of the ordnance) use devices that aren't particularly dangerous after they land because they know they will have to deal with them afterwards, and various conventions limit the dropping of ordnance that later poses a threat to civilians. Most are fairly easily defused and with relatively little risk. It's what insurgents do with them that is the bigger risk.
When a device (such as a mine) has a magnetic trigger, it has to be a fairly strong field disturbance to trigger it. Otherwise one mine could blow up one vehicle and all the shrapnel would trigger every other mine, plus you'd have large and expensive anti-vehicular mines blown up because an infantryman walked past it. That's (admittedly in a very crass way) a waste of a mine. The scenes in old World War II movies aren't really valid and mostly never were. And you can buy brass probes to look for mines, but frankly, nobody is seriously going to look for them that way. Most of that kind of stuff is part of the BS that people sell as real.
-
Nice contributions lanedecamp
welcome to mto. -
Thank you for all the infos, lanedecamp!

You cleared a lot of things up for me. As you wrote "Most of that kind of stuff is part of the BS that people sell as real". Sadly not all information is as unbiased and represantativ as what you typed here.
And a lot more thanks for your dangerous work to make the world a safer place!

-
Very nice thread, I learned a lot of new stuff here (not to mention a lot of new TLAs).
:D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login