Cogito/Higgins617
-
@Gareth said:
"I honestly believe that the comment was not intended to cause offence and so I don't see any point in asking Higgins to make any changes or apologize. One of the reasons we at Multitool.org have such a good reputation as an exceptionally friendly place is that we choose to operate under the assumption that if something can be taken multiple ways, we will normally choose to read it in the best light and move on. I have discussed the matter with all the other staff and we are all in agreement. I believe it's best if we all just let the matter drop here. It has been noted, and we will keep an eye out in case this continues. Please feel free to bring further matters to our attention, however I don't think one incident (which I believe likely was not an incident) is enough to judge by."A few suggested changes- sorry about the spelling changes, old habits die hard.
What you have is excellent, I just think a few wording changes could help. Feel free to ignore them though.Def
-
Oh yes, and feel free to mention that he is welcome to "escalate" his issue by taking it to the Head Turd Polisher and see what he (me) says. It's always nice to feel like you can take something higher if need be.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
"I honestly believe that the comment was not intended to cause offence and so I don't see any point in asking Higgins to make any changes or apologize. One of the reasons we at Multitool.org have such a good reputation as an exceptionally friendly place is that we choose to operate under the assumption that if something can be taken multiple ways, we will normally choose to read it in the best light and move on. I have discussed the matter with all the other staff and we are all in agreement. I believe it's best if we all just let the matter drop here. It has been noted, and we will keep an eye out in case this continues. Please feel free to bring further matters to our attention, however I don't think one incident (which I believe likely was not an incident) is enough to judge by."
A few suggested changes- sorry about the spelling changes, old habits die hard.
What you have is excellent, I just think a few wording changes could help. Feel free to ignore them though.Def
Cheers Grant, that reads better now. My only excuse is that I am still hung over.

Message sent.
-
@Cogito said:
Higgins made a reply to one of my comments that was disrespectful to me and instead of me escalating the situation I decided to report it.
The moderator Gareth who reviewed this report has considered it friendly banter and I don't believe that to be the case. He says he has discussed it with other moderators and he told me that if I wanted to push it further that I should ask higgins for clarification and I told him that if anyone should be doing that it should be him as a moderator. But instead he refuses and is telling me to leave it alone.
I reported it as a courtesy, but thus far Gareth's responses have implied that I don't deserve respect. I thought I should let you know that Gareth isn't doing his job as a moderator and should any funny business happen to my account it would most likely be a result of his doing.
This is something that could have been handled in 10 minutes, and yet here I am a week later.
I am not going to go behind anyone's back so I am also going to let Gareth know that I sent you this message.
I'm going to apologize in advance that this is going to be a long winded response. Unfortunately, I think it is necessary for you to understand how things are done here.
First up, unlike other forums where each Moderator has his or her on fiefdom we have Global Moderators, which means any moderator at any time can handle issues in any forum. We do this to make sure there is always a moderator online that can help with any issues. Gareth was the first one to respond to your Moderator Report, which is why he was the one who contacted you- in case you were wondering about that.
When it comes to member issues, which we take very seriously, Mods usually report/record any and all interactions in the Admin Forum, again for the benefit of members- that way all the moderator staff knows what's going on and can step in to help in case the original moderator isn't around when something else happens.
I'm telling you this because I want you to know that I have been aware of this issue since shortly after you first reported it, and Gareth has copied and pasted the discussion up to this point, so I have seen what has gone back and forth so far.
I'd also like to point out that if anyone here decided that other members didn't deserve some respect they wouldn't be here, whether they were a moderator or not. That having been said, if you feel that I may have missed something, please feel free to tell me- I have known to be wrong before, and I can pretty well guarantee it'll happen again at some point.
I am now going to recap, just to make sure we are on the same page- as I understand it, this is the issue you reported?
Your comment:
And the response that you felt was offensive was this:
@Higgins617 said:
So don't buy itPlease feel free to correct me if I'm looking at the wrong issue, but to be honest, to me it seems like it might be a tad on the harsh side, but it doesn't seem disrespectful, and certainly not worthy of the amount of effort you have put into being offended by it. If you read other posts by Higgins, this seems to be the way he communicates and I personally don't believe he means anything by it.
Long ago I had to deal with guys joining the forum with their shoulders pre-chipped as a result of the atmosphere of other sites. It got pretty bad for a while, so I had to step in and put my foot down and tell people that rather than be offended by things they read (which probably weren't meant to be offensive), assume that the person was just making the same kind of comments your friends would while sitting at the bar, having a few drinks. Chances are, with the casual atmosphere that we have developed here, that's the mindset that pretty well all of these posts are posted with, so why get upset about them?
I don't think Gareth was out of line or being disrespectful either- in fact, I wrote part of that last message he sent you. No one, not Gareth, not me, and not Higgins are suggesting that you do not deserve respect. I would suggest that you are perhaps reading too much into this- the fact that people are not agreeing with you and you are considering it a bigger sleight kind of lends legitimacy to that theory. It is precisely because I do respect you as a member of this site that I am taking the time to discuss all of this with you. If I didn't, it would take a lot less time for me to send you a "suck it up princess" message, which I don't believe in.
If you would like, I would happily start a PM discussion with you, Higgins and Gareth (or any combination) so we can get this sorted out, but I have a feeling this is going to just result in dragging this out further.
I would also like to point out that all of the mod staff is aware of this issue, and should there be any further problems with Higgins (or anyone) taking shots at you, they will be dealt with accordingly. One incident that may or may not have been intended is hardly a reason to go after someone. If it happens again then it shows an actual intent to disrespect another member, and that will be unacceptable and Mod staff will take action.
My advice? Don't read too much into it. This is just an internet forum, and you can't get that upset over what someone you don't know and will probably never meet says.
Def
My guess is that he will completely miss the point, assume we are ganging up on him, throw down his purse and leave the forum since everyone in the world is disrespecting him. If he stays I'll be happy that he does and I won't worry about this. If he sends me a smurf off letter and storms off the forum, I won't lose any sleep over him.
Def
-
This is the message I got from him. I don't think he's thin skinned any more, I suspect he's smurfing nuts. ::)
@Cogito said:
-
If you don't want to do your job as a moderator don't tell me to do it for you.
-
Higgins was blatantly disrespectful to me, how you see it as friendly banter is beyond me and makes me believe that you aren't familiar with American English.
-
You and the other staff can discuss what you like, but don't tell me what to do, I deserve more respect than that and your messages have implied that I don't which is shameful.
-
I won't go behind anyone's back so I'm letting you know that I've sent a message to Grant documenting the situation with Higgins and our messages including your lack of ability as a moderator.
-
I don't know if your actions thus far have been intentional however, you've wasted a great deal of my time. In the future I would like a different moderator to review anything that I report if I choose to do so.
-
If that I've said thus far (which is completely truthful and factual) is not to your liking, consider it friendly banter.
BTW Grant, way to go on taking the effort writing that reply.

-
-
Looks good, but the last line kinda makes me wonder:
@Cogito said:
What Higgins said to me was a small sleight. Gareth telling me that what Higgins said was friendly banter even though I don't know him and then telling me that everyone agreed that the best course of action was to drop it was more offensive than what Higgins did specifically because in this case I wasn't considered as a part of everyone even though I was the only one effected.
Regardless of how I feel about the situation thus far, your response to me was well thought out and satisfactory. I appreciate the time you took to write it and I will use it to guide any further action if needed.
No problem man. I do not take member issues lightly. Please let me know if you have any other problems and I will personally address them.
Def
We'll see what happens from here.
Def
-
Can we accidentally delete him? I'm not even joking at this point. ::)
-
@enki_ck said:
Can we accidentally delete him? I'm not even joking at this point. ::)I think you have spent too much time at EDCForums...

Seriously, there's really only two ways this goes from here- either he lets it go and continues being a decent member or he freaks out at someone and we ban him. Either way we win, so there's no harm in us being gracious and leaving it alone.
Def
-
Gotta say I'm not remotely happy with his retelling of the event.
Did I tell him to drop it? No, I just said I wouldn't pursue it and that he wanted to he should do so in a friendly way (an attitude he singularly failed to show to me). Sorry but I'm sitting here really pissed off right now, I cannot stand this whiny crap and being told what my 'job' is by an idiot like this is very smurfing annoying. -
A waste is a terrible thing to mind Gareth. Maybe one of these days if you stop disrespecting people and learn English you'll figure that one out!

Seriously man, chill out. This does not matter. Some dude on the 'net being mean to you is funny, not upsetting. It's like a small child trying to punch you- there's no way they can hurt you, and you have every ability to utterly destroy them, but you don't because, well, it's a little kid and there's no real threat.
What do you think is going to happen? He's going to go public with "Gareth disrespected me and I think he's a mean person and he hurt my feelings" and people are going to respond with "Hell yeah, let's fry Gareth! I'm going to punish him by making him wear underwear under his kilt and burn down his local curry shop so he starves!"
I imagine folks would respond more like "Gareth is a good guy, suck it up Princess."
But even so, no one is going to actually be able to force you into underwear and if your local curry shop burns down it was likely for the insurance rather than an attempt at starving you.
Def
-
Sorry Grant, but this on top of the Tosh debacle has just really gotten to me. I don't think there is a single person who has ever met me in the real world who has ever had any kind of complaint about my attitude to others, but on this forum I'm once again the bad guy?
-
I'll just say sorry for the ranting folks.
This really has annoyed me far more than it should have. 
-
No worries man- rant away.

Def
-
What a little pissant. ::) I'm thinking about replying to all his posts from now on with So don't buy it.

-
Come on Bob, isn't it bad enough that Gareth doesn't speak American? You should be on his side or King George will come and take your guns away...

Def
-
You're right, I didn't think of it that way. Perhaps on second thought we should put "Friendly banter" into the swear filter so non-American-English speakers like Gareth won't be able to misuse it. ::)
@Cogito said:
5. I don't know if your actions thus far have been intentional however, you've wasted a great deal of my time. In the future I would like a different moderator to review anything that I report if I choose to do so.I'd be happy to volunteer.

-
In this case I think an American might be more beneficial, so I might take you up on that... you know, if you are around...

Def
-
Helping to educate and redirect our country's poor misguided youth has and always will be a priority to me.*

*translation: I'll come tell the little fvcker what an idiot he is and ban him as soon as you say it's okay to.
-
-
Wow.
@Higgins617 said:
Hey Def,
Don't want to pester you with foolish problems, but there's a member threatening me as if he can ban me personally saying he already discussed it with mods as well. I personally couldn't care less about the person to person issue as it really does not bother me. I would just rather not be banned for absolute nonsense. That isn't the case is it?
Thanks, KyleCan you copy the message here?
I'm assuming it's Cogito?
Def
I'm starting to reconsider a banning.
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login