Ducttapetech's MT.O Challenge Coin.
-
It's certainly a lot more doable. After laser/water cutting, all the required machining can be done on a manual lathe with a turn-table. Whether the required accuracy could be achieved is debatable, but engraving the graphics in the correct place would no longer be an issue. I wouldn't recommend stamping, as it distorts the surrounding material, ruining the precision of the surfaces. Also i'd move the text off and away from the working surfaces.
For the sake of simplifying the machining process, this is probably how the upper face should look.
<a href="http://s194.photobucket.com/user/Toftylicious/media/Coins/Design2a_zpsd884bda7.png.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i194.photobucket.com/albums/z42/Toftylicious/Coins/Design2a_zpsd884bda7.png" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
(the thinnest cut is at the top right, there's no real reason why i did it this way round)
The machining cuts pass right across the tool, this is a lot easier for the operator as they don't have to cut in more than one plane at a time and can use a much larger diameter mill cutter, than if they had to cut into the tool and then along it.This would still work out not to be cheap, but much more achievable
-
Thanks for the input Tofty!
that's us mobile
-
When I first saw the initial drawing I thought "Cool, a rolling ruler!"
That might be different than what you thought of, but a circular rolling ruler with English (or is it Imperial?) on one side and Metric on the other would be a neat idea. and likely handy for more people.
-
That is a cool idea. Never thought about anything like that.
that's us mobile
-
@n4vgm said:
When I first saw the initial drawing I thought "Cool, a rolling ruler!"That might be different than what you thought of, but a circular rolling ruler with English (or is it Imperial?) on one side and Metric on the other would be a neat idea. and likely handy for more people.
I thought about this for a tool coin, but inches and metric dont match. 1 inch is 2.54mm.

-
When I first saw the initial drawing I thought "Cool, a rolling ruler!"
That might be different than what you thought of, but a circular rolling ruler with English (or is it Imperial?) on one side and Metric on the other would be a neat idea. and likely handy for more people.
I thought about this for a tool coin, but inches and metric dont match. 1 inch is 2.54mm.

2.54 cm. ;)
-
Why do they have to match? If you are rolling a distance from zero you just use whichever side you like.
I don't know how usable it would be in the field. It would almost require a round hole in the center to roll around your finger/thumb. Wait, if you had a 1/4 inch hex in the center you could then use a bit as the "handle" as you rolled across something to measure it. :D
Anyone ever seen a tool like that before? I can't remember seeing one. The edge of a metal disk may be too slippery for any kind of accuracy.
-
I wondered that too, but I think the "match" idea is for simplicity and flat sides. If the design is a simple hexagon or octagon it would be simpler to find a more "even" size to make use easier. If the design went with rounded edges then the argument is moot, and a round coin would indeed measure well enough.
To that end, it might be interesting to put a notch in the 12 o'clock position so that you know by feel that there has been a complete rotation. That way if the circumference of the coin is three inches you will know without even looking that you have rolled it all the way around four times, so the thing you are measuring must be a foot long.
Def
-
"put a notch in the 12 o'clock position so that you know by feel that there has been a complete rotation. That way if the circumference of the coin is three inches you will know without even looking that you have rolled it all the way around four times, so the thing you are measuring must be a foot long."
Doing it that way makes it work for both measuring systems on either side whereas putting a wee bump every inch does nothing for the metric crowd.
Again, sorry to hijack the original concept especially since I'm only an "armchair challenge coin designer!"
-
@n4vgm said:
"put a notch in the 12 o'clock position so that you know by feel that there has been a complete rotation. That way if the circumference of the coin is three inches you will know without even looking that you have rolled it all the way around four times, so the thing you are measuring must be a foot long."Doing it that way makes it work for both measuring systems on either side whereas putting a wee bump every inch does nothing for the metric crowd.
Again, sorry to hijack the original concept especially since I'm only an "armchair challenge coin designer!"
Not really, so I roll the coin three times which results in 9" I then have to multiply it by 2.54 or I have to add up 3 times 7.62. The beauty of the metric system is that it always comes in tens. So for the metric crowd, the reasonable circumference would be 10 cm ( = 3.9 inch) (coin diameter 3.18 cm).
That said I prefer the different thickness design. I can see many uses for this other than measuring spark-plugs.
-
I think in the past some coins have been made in different materials. Why not in (slightly) different sizes? One for metric and one for imperial? Or finding a "round" number where both measurements coincide (no fractions on either side).

This last option might be better, only one size/model to be made.
-
@pfrsantos said:
I think in the past some coins have been made in different materials. Why not in (slightly) different sizes? One for metric and one for imperial? Or finding a "round" number where both measurements coincide (no fractions on either side).

This last option might be better, only one size/model to be made.
The obvious one is 4 inches vs 10 cm. Etherealicer said 10 cm, but I think it's pretty arbitrary for practical purposes whether you go for 10 cm or 4 inches:
4 inches = 10.16 cm
10 cm = 3.94 inches = 3 15/16 inches.1 / 16 inch is a tad below 1.6 mm, so if choosing circumference from where the error will be the least "in the other system", it won't matter much whether choosing metric or American.
That's not too bad, either way. Not like you'll be able to roll a coin with only a mm accuracy anyway, at least not without quite a lot of effort.
And since this is a family friendly forum, I won't write exactly what I think about the Imperial/American/utterly outdated system of measurement. ;)
-
"the reasonable circumference would be 10 cm"
We Americans were supposed to have embraced the Metric system decades ago anyway so if you do this just go Metric on one side and motto(s) on the other.
-
When I first saw the initial drawing I thought "Cool, a rolling ruler!"
That might be different than what you thought of, but a circular rolling ruler with English (or is it Imperial?) on one side and Metric on the other would be a neat idea. and likely handy for more people.
I thought about this for a tool coin, but inches and metric dont match. 1 inch is 2.54mm.

2.54 cm. ;)
my bad

-
@n4vgm said:
"the reasonable circumference would be 10 cm"We Americans were supposed to have embraced the Metric system decades ago anyway so if you do this just go Metric on one side and motto(s) on the other.
We were supposed to, but we didn't. I'm good either way. I tend to prefer the standard system a tad better. But I grew up with it. The US will go Meteric, but it will be slow. I learned both when I was in school, but a lot of people only learned the standard system only while they where in school. For them it will be hard to switch.
that's us mobile
-
J-Sews once told me it was a nightmare to be a machinist these days because he had to quickly convert in his head not only from metric to Imperial/US but also from fractions of inches to decimal points of inches when putting design points into the CNC machines.
I always comment that Canada, officially being metric but being so close to the US and heavily influenced by it, is the only place in the world where you can give directions like this and they make sense:
First, you follow this road for two miles, then make a left and go for another ten minutes, then hang a right, go for two kilometers and you are there.
Def
-
This is my final entry. I cleaned up the design. I was thinking about the ruler. But some of us use metic and some of us use standard.
Mine has a .25 inch driver in the center and a spark gapper on the edges. I don't have a CAD program nor am I talented enough to use it. Best I can do is pencil and graphpaper.
Thanks for looking.

live from Nate's mobile
-
@ducttapetech said:
This is my final entry. I cleaned up the design. I was thinking about the ruler. But some of us use metic and some of us use standard.
Mine has a .25 inch driver in the center and a spark gapper on the edges. I don't have a CAD program nor am I talented enough to use it. Best I can do is pencil and graphpaper.
Thanks for looking.

live from Nate's mobile
I like it!

-
@ducttapetech said:
This is my final entry. I cleaned up the design. I was thinking about the ruler. But some of us use metic and some of us use standard.
Mine has a .25 inch driver in the center and a spark gapper on the edges. I don't have a CAD program nor am I talented enough to use it. Best I can do is pencil and graphpaper.
Thanks for looking.

live from Nate's mobile
Nice, I'm not to big on the spark plug gapper, but what if you made open center? And made a hollow strip made it kinda look like a worm? One side measured out metric other standard, and call them the inchworm and centipede? JR
-
This is my final entry. I cleaned up the design. I was thinking about the ruler. But some of us use metic and some of us use standard.
Mine has a .25 inch driver in the center and a spark gapper on the edges. I don't have a CAD program nor am I talented enough to use it. Best I can do is pencil and graphpaper.
Thanks for looking.

live from Nate's mobile
Nice, I'm not to big on the spark plug gapper, but what if you made open center? And made a hollow strip made it kinda look like a worm? One side measured out metric other standard, and call them the inchworm and centipede? JR
Neat idea.
live from Nate's mobile
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login