Multi-tool or knife?
-
I used to carry and use a Leatherman multitool everywhere when I worked as a maintenance guy at a college, now I'm not doing that job I carry a Wenger or Victorinox knife w/tools............ I go for Leatherman as a professional and a Swiss army knife w/tools as a non-professional...... I just think the dedicated multitool types are more solid and less breakable.
-John

I think you should read this thread....

-
Hi bmot,
a lot of the jobs I did included useing the pliers of the leatherman, I used to abuse the heck out of the leatherman without a problem.I carried a 1981 Vic soldier from1981 until I lost it on the job (boss bought me 2 more soldiers because I was so heart broken). Maybe it is just me wanting to be kind to a lovely SAK?
I love SAKs but never want to be brutal with them if there's another option.
cheers,
-John -
@av8r1 said:
I personally place the border of Multitools between Swiss Army Knives and penknives. I don't consider a penknife a multitool because it's only a cutting instrument. A multitool has to be designed to do at least two different tasks.@Aloha007 said:
I refer to single blade knife only as tool just not multi-tool.What about Solo, or Sentinel, or Pocket Pal... Begginer, Sentry, Student, Excelsior etc. ?
They are all single-blade or double-blade. And they are definately SAKs. Do you consider them to be Multitools? -
It's a good topic, which also could be related to our MT.O mt timeline. Personally, I do consider most Victorinox/Wenger tools MT(save a few knife only models)
My reasonings are:
-
The term SAK, IIRC, was used loosely as a substitute for Victorinox brand name during/post WW2. So it is not a categorization to begin with.
-
We could say most Victorinox products are knife-based MT, and they are valid MT as any pliers-based MT. But I really think we shouldn't exclude all MTs before Leatherman products in the MT.O MT timeline.
If anything that is not pliers-based will not be considered as MT, should we also exclude milestone products like Leatherman Micra or SOG crosscut from MT family?
</topic/2281
- By definition, the term multitool is a very board term. It could potentially covers anything from a pocketwrench2 to a Swisstool. It might also be beneficial to categorize the one-piece tool with no moving 'blades' as 'simple MT', while all others as 'complex MT'
-
-
I personally place the border of Multitools between Swiss Army Knives and penknives. I don't consider a penknife a multitool because it's only a cutting instrument. A multitool has to be designed to do at least two different tasks.
@Aloha007 said:
I refer to single blade knife only as tool just not multi-tool.What about Solo, or Sentinel, or Pocket Pal... Begginer, Sentry, Student, Excelsior etc. ?
They are all single-blade or double-blade. And they are definately SAKs. Do you consider them to be Multitools?No. Or at least I don't.
that's us mobile
-
I personally place the border of Multitools between Swiss Army Knives and penknives. I don't consider a penknife a multitool because it's only a cutting instrument. A multitool has to be designed to do at least two different tasks.
@Aloha007 said:
I refer to single blade knife only as tool just not multi-tool.What about Solo, or Sentinel, or Pocket Pal... Begginer, Sentry, Student, Excelsior etc. ?
They are all single-blade or double-blade. And they are definately SAKs. Do you consider them to be Multitools?Most of those are designed only for cutting tasks, so no, I would not consider them multitools. I wouldn't consider them SAKs either, since "Swiss Army Knife" is often used as a metaphor for a multifunctional and versatile object. "the Icom 706 is a Swiss Army Knife of radios, it does everything in a small, portable package."
-
So, here my opinion (and please don't stone me): I think that they are all multitools. Even if there is "only" a knife, this knife has several cutting functions (rope, wood, meat etc). Some knife tips are even useable as a screwdriver.
It's not like having a kitchen knife that is for kitchen use only. Well, they sometimes get misused for pry open something...
Jimmy the Turnip Wang's girl
-
Swiss army knife
multi tool
-
@Sweety-Sama said:
So, here my opinion (and please don't stone me): I think that they are all multitools. Even if there is "only" a knife, this knife has several cutting functions (rope, wood, meat etc). Some knife tips are even useable as a screwdriver.
It's not like having a kitchen knife that is for kitchen use only. Well, they sometimes get misused for pry open something...
Jimmy the Turnip Wang's girl
By this logic, a kitchen knife is a multi. It cuts fruit, beef, pig, deer, veggies, a finger.........
that's us mobile
-
So, here my opinion (and please don't stone me): I think that they are all multitools. Even if there is "only" a knife, this knife has several cutting functions (rope, wood, meat etc). Some knife tips are even useable as a screwdriver.
It's not like having a kitchen knife that is for kitchen use only. Well, they sometimes get misused for pry open something...
Jimmy the Turnip Wang's girl
By this logic, a kitchen knife is a multi. It cuts fruit, beef, pig, deer, veggies, a finger.........
that's us mobile
You are not supposed to cut your finger! :P
^_^
-
So, here my opinion (and please don't stone me): I think that they are all multitools. Even if there is "only" a knife, this knife has several cutting functions (rope, wood, meat etc). Some knife tips are even useable as a screwdriver.
It's not like having a kitchen knife that is for kitchen use only. Well, they sometimes get misused for pry open something...
Jimmy the Turnip Wang's girl
By this logic, a kitchen knife is a multi. It cuts fruit, beef, pig, deer, veggies, a finger.........
that's us mobile
You are not supposed to cut your finger! :P
^_^
Really?

I thought that was half the fun! It feels especially nice when you hit the bone. :D
<a href="http://s927.photobucket.com/user/ChadV_2010/media/RANDOM/DSC03319.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i927.photobucket.com/albums/ad112/ChadV_2010/RANDOM/DSC03319.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
<a href="http://s927.photobucket.com/user/ChadV_2010/media/RANDOM/DSC03330.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i927.photobucket.com/albums/ad112/ChadV_2010/RANDOM/DSC03330.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a> -
@captain spaulding said:
So, here my opinion (and please don't stone me): I think that they are all multitools. Even if there is "only" a knife, this knife has several cutting functions (rope, wood, meat etc). Some knife tips are even useable as a screwdriver.
It's not like having a kitchen knife that is for kitchen use only. Well, they sometimes get misused for pry open something...
Jimmy the Turnip Wang's girl
By this logic, a kitchen knife is a multi. It cuts fruit, beef, pig, deer, veggies, a finger.........
that's us mobile
You are not supposed to cut your finger! :P
^_^
Really?

I thought that was half the fun! It feels especially nice when you hit the bone. :D
<a href="http://s927.photobucket.com/user/ChadV_2010/media/RANDOM/DSC03319.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i927.photobucket.com/albums/ad112/ChadV_2010/RANDOM/DSC03319.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
<a href="http://s927.photobucket.com/user/ChadV_2010/media/RANDOM/DSC03330.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i927.photobucket.com/albums/ad112/ChadV_2010/RANDOM/DSC03330.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>Eek!!! How'd you do that??? :o
^_^
-
I had my Spyderco Pacific Salt H1 in my left hand and kind of had a involuntary motion with the hand that was holding the knife and my finger just so happened to be there.

I kid you not every time I pick up any knife I remember that.
-
But you still can move your finger without any hindrance? Or was it too damaged?
^_^
-
After it happened I had to keep my finger straight for quite a while to let the wound heal. About a month if I remember correctly. I fashioned my own finger splint after a few accidental bending of my finger resulting in pain and opening the would back up. I also lost all feeling in the tip of the finger for a few months, but it slowly started to come back and I have almost full feeling in it now. I would say around 98%. It's been a year or two since it happened. If I poke the tip of that finger it does seem to have slightly less felling than all the others, but nothing that is a issue. One thing I notice all the time is the joint closest to the cut hurts on occasion and feels stiff regularly and I have a very hard time if I try and crack my knuckles. You know how when your knuckles feel stiff you can crack them to release the pressure or whatever you want to call it. (Not everyone does this as it is bad for your knuckles). I could not do it on the closest knuckle to the cut anymore for around a year after the cut and even today I can only do it 15%-20% of the time. Not sure why the cut affected the knuckle. When I first started to try and crack the knuckle again it would not do it and my finger would hurt for half a day or so. I can almost guarantee I severed a tendon or severely cut one. I never went to the doctor for it so i'm not sure. I have full range of movement now, but as I sit here i'm moving it around and it just feels different than all the rest of the fingers like its stiffer or something. Its kind of hard to explain. Anyways that's about the just of it. I learned my lesson and wont forget it.
-
Ouch!!! I did my thumb like that. Just right before the knuckle. And like you, to the bone. Gah! Still makes me shiver when I thing about it.
that's us mobile
-
Probably you injured one of the fibre too. It really looks like a deep cut.
My fingers crack for no reason at all for most of the time... Heck, every joint in my body can crack just for the fun of it (not my fun but the fun of my joints). You don't want to know where it can crack! -.- I wish they would stop that
^_^
-
@Sweety-Sama said:
So, here my opinion (and please don't stone me): I think that they are all multitools. Even if there is "only" a knife, this knife has several cutting functions (rope, wood, meat etc). Some knife tips are even useable as a screwdriver.
It's not like having a kitchen knife that is for kitchen use only. Well, they sometimes get misused for pry open something...
Jimmy the Turnip Wang's girl
No stones, in fact I enjoy discussions like this.
I think knives are better described as "versatile" rather than "multi-functional."After all, if a knife is a multitool because it can also be used as a pry bar, then a wrench can be used as a hammer, a hammer can be used as a paperweight, and a dental drill can be used to extract information from intruders. In this sense, multitool and tool have the same definition.
I usually go by features advertised by the manufacturer, not user-discovered functions. I've done more prying with the Wave's flat blade than screw driving, but it's advertised as a screwdriver. Also, I've found that the Skeletool actually does have a can opener, and a really useful one at that.
-
This is my same definition for multitool. otherwise a rock becomes the most versatile multitool ever.
Road material, ship ballast, counterweight, sinker, projectile, hammer, hand warmer or water boiler (when combined with campfire), etc., etc.
So, for me, a multi tool must have multiple individual implements. And, those multiple individual implements can't all be blades. Because if they're all blades, then you don't have a multitool, you have a multibladed knife. Same with a screwdriver with replaceable bits. Sure, it can work on lots of different screws, but it's still just a screwdriver. I also don't consider one-piece gadgets multitools, like the piranha. If that were the case, then I'd have to consider the old combo can/bottle openers multitools, and that just doesn't work for me. Cut all the holes you like in it, it's still just a cleverly shaped piece of metal, IMO, not a multitool. So, I guess 'cool transformer action' is another required feature for my definition. :D
The thing here is we all bring in a different perspective, and none of them are necessarily wrong, so the definition will ultimately be up to the individual.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
This is my same definition for multitool. otherwise a rock becomes the most versatile multitool ever1.Road material, ship ballast, counterweight, sinker, projectile, hammer, hand warmer or water boiler (when combined with campfire), etc., etc.
So, for me, a multi tool must have multiple individual implements. And, those multiple individual implements can't all be blades. Because if they're all blades, then you don't have a multitool, you have a multibladed knife. Same with a screwdriver with replaceable bits. Sure, it can work on lots of different screws, but it's still just a screwdriver. **I also don't consider one-piece gadgets multitools, like the piranha.**2 If that were the case, then I'd have to consider the old combo can/bottle openers multitools, and that just doesn't work for me. Cut all the holes you like in it, it's still just a cleverly shaped piece of metal, IMO, not a multitool. So, I guess 'cool transformer action' is another required feature for my definition. :D
The thing here is we all bring in a different perspective, and none of them are necessarily wrong, so the definition will ultimately be up to the individual.
1: You are forgetting about those 5 digit, be born with one - get one free!*, 1 digit per side with sprecial features, Multitools!
*Sadly, no manufacturer's guarantee here2: I like your definition!

Especially about the one-piece tools. They may be versatile, but they are not multi.
And now someone will mention the 1/4" bit-driver in the Piranha
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login