Rust Resistance Test
-
So, I got the Camillus Les Stroud MT in today.
And decided to test it's Titanium Bonded (TM,R, C,U,K) coating against...
A Victorinox Supertinker I got used off of ebay. It had sand in it, and some surface corrosion when I got it. I rubbed it off with 2000 grit sandpaper.
A Leatherman Wingman. This tool's beadblasted finish has made its rust resistance very questionable.
And finally, a Rebar. This is pretty much a standard finish on other leatherman tools.
I soaked a little piece of paper towel in salt water, and taped it to the tools in little plastic baggies. Maybe not exactly airtight, but that's okay. I'll give it a few days, and see how they all do.
I used the flat drivers on all of them, since i figured those would be the easiest to remove rust from, should it form. Except for the Les tool. The file on the flat driver seemed like a problem, so I used the can opener instead.
Let... the oxidation... BEGIN!

-
Might just be me, but I have a feeling nothing's serious gonna happen to the tools. Maybe a few spots, that'll come off with a good wipe with a clean cloth. But I'm definitely following this one. :)
-
I can't watch!

-
@Freaver said:
Might just be me, but I have a feeling nothing's serious gonna happen to the tools. Maybe a few spots, that'll come off with a good wipe with a clean cloth. But I'm definitely following this one. :)If nothing happens in a few days, I'll reset the test, and use big plastic food containers wit ha LOT more liquid and punch the drivers through the lids.
I honestly don't know what's going to happen either. There may not be enough moisture, or oxygen in those little baggies. Dunno.
Science! :D
-
I'm interested to see what happens as well! By the way, thank you fpr the Les Strout MT test! It was worse than I expected, so thank you for wasting your money on our education!

I would think, there has to be enough Oxigen as well as electrolytes to start rusting. But we will see in a few days. I have some ideas if salsmurfer alone doesn't do anything.

-
@RT1969 said:
I would think, there has to be enough Oxigen as well as electrolytes to start rusting. But we will see in a few days. I have some ideas if salsmurfer alone doesn't do anything.

You might want to put a space into 'salt water'. Otherwise the naughty-filter mangles it.

EDIT: Same with 'pocket watch'.
-
I am looking forward to the results of this test, and to your thoughts on the Les Stroud tool once it gets some use. :D
Def
-
In comparison, that Camillus Les Stroud tool looks awfully cheap based on general shape. This should be interesting to see what sort of results you will get.
-
My money is on the Vic for the win! :D
The best way to get rust (if you arent getting any action) is to make sure the metal surfaces have constant droplets on them. Thats what forms electrochemical cell that pumps out the rust.

-
I refuse to comment on that as I have been told in the past that the rust I found on my Wingman was imaginary.
Def
-
I'm very interested in the results you're going to get here. That Wingman that rusted looked like the rust "flowed" from the axles,which would make sense because you've got a really great anode and cathode there; the brass bushing in the axle assembly and the steel body of the tool. Here, you don't have dissimilar metals. I bet if you soaked the whole tools in salt water you'd get much more corrosion in all cases, but it would damage or destroy all of them. I know you wouldn't give a smurf about the Les Stroud "tool," but the others are actually quality stuff.
I can tell you horror stories about corrosion, as can most aviation maintenance technicians. movie trailer voiceover In a world made out of 2024 aluminum held together with steel rivets, water becomes the enemy.
-
Cool test Lynn
I'm curious to see how it turns out, especially with the Rebar and Wingman since I own both. -
I can tell you that my Rebar, just through regular use, developed some compleyely cosmetic rust spots on the plier jaws...and nowhere else.
I think it makes the tool look (forgive the expression) manlier. It's like my Rebar has Indiana Jones stubble.
-
@Jothra said:
I can tell you that my Rebar, just through regular use, developed some compleyely cosmetic rust spots on the plier jaws...and nowhere else.I think it makes the tool look (forgive the expression) manlier. It's like my Rebar has Indiana Jones stubble.
Jothra! It's great to see you again, where have you been?

-
I can tell you that my Rebar, just through regular use, developed some compleyely cosmetic rust spots on the plier jaws...and nowhere else.
I think it makes the tool look (forgive the expression) manlier. It's like my Rebar has Indiana Jones stubble.
Jothra! It's great to see you again, where have you been?

Things got busy in a potentially destructive way. Long story short, everything is fine, nothing is ruined. I've been easing back into the forum.
You guys know which tools don't have a speck of rust on them? Coghlan or Campy. I'm totally serious.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
@RT1969 said:
I would think, there has to be enough Oxigen as well as electrolytes to start rusting. But we will see in a few days. I have some ideas if salsmurfer alone doesn't do anything.

You might want to put a space into 'salt water'. Otherwise the naughty-filter mangles it.

EDIT: Same with 'pocket watch'.
Oh man, didn't see this yesterday

But salsmurfer smurfs up the tools, feels kind of appropriate in this sentence.
-
If the Vic Rusts, I'm eating its toothpick ::)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
