Phillips driver slippage
-
This may be important enough to deserve its own thread.
How many of you guys knew that Phillips drivers are designed to slip: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cam_out ?
Think I remember learning that fact long ago, but had completely forgotten it.
When testing various SAK/multi Phillips drivers recently, I was trying to loosen some very tight Phillips woodscrews but was frustrated by the tendency of the drivers to slip.
The torque at which they'll begin to slip may vary somewhat between makes, but beyond some level of torque all of them will slip - by design.
.
-
Wow, you learn something everyday. That annoying tendency is by design.
-
Didn’t know that.
-
I knew that. Pozidrive is another design that has been developed since so that more torque can be applied to the fastener without slippage.
-
This is one of those things that I can't remember where I learned it first, probably some tidbit my Dad gave me while tinkering around his workshop when I was a little boy.
Coarse finishes and diamond coatings were implemented to alleviate the cam-out to some degree in certain uses. The latter is one of those things I would put on my ideal multitool. Seems really handy and neat.
-
I didn't know that. Never even imagined it. ???
Thanks ringzero.
-
@J-sews said:
I didn't know that. Never even imagined it. ???It does have practical applications, such as when I recently put together a ramp out of 2x10s and 2x4s using woodscrews.
I was driving the screws with just a basic electric drill without any torque limiting capability.
Driving the Phillips screws didn't require any particular care. I could just drive them until the driver cammed out, which sunk their heads slightly below the surface of the 2x10s. Perfect, with no damage to screwhead and no splitting of the wood.
Then I ran out of Phillips, but rummaged around in the basement and found an unopened, but ancient box of chrome-plated slot head woodscrews - probably 40 or 50 years old.
Started using the slot heads and immediately ran into problems. They worked, but they required very careful control of the drill at all times. Otherwise their heads would strip or else they'd over tighten and split the wood.
.
-
Yah, I hear what you're saying. Slotted heads are nothing but a pain in the butt. Everybody knows it too. I'm trying to think.......it seems like the only slotted head screws I've had to deal with lately are the little decorative ones that hold the switchplate on for home electric light switches.
During the same period I've had to deal with thousands of phillips screws.
-
@J-sews said:
Yah, I hear what you're saying. Slotted heads are nothing but a pain in the butt. Everybody knows it too. I'm trying to think.......it seems like the only slotted head screws I've had to deal with lately are the little decorative ones that hold the switchplate on for home electric light switches.During the same period I've had to deal with thousands of phillips screws.
Phillips screws do seem to be more common than slot heads these days. Sometimes people will post on MTO that they rarely need to turn a Phillips screw, but that makes me wonder if they're somehow living among technological relics from half-a-century ago.
Especially when dealing with consumer electronics gadgets, a Phillips driver is often indispensable.
Even the much-maligned, polished, slippery, T-handle Phillips drivers found on Vic and Wenger SAKs really aren't that bad. They've saved the day for me many times by turning recessed Phillips screws to open the case of some balky gadget.
.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login