Leatherman Juice CS4 Old v.s. New.
-
What follows is a short comparison between the newly acquired Juice CS4, and the older Juice CS4. I will also add in my opinions.
Like many, I was surprised to see that Leatherman decided to revamp their Juice lineup. There was a bit of controversy on this forum in regards to the new cosmetic look of the second series, especially in regard to the two tone colour scheme. I must say, I didn't mind the new colour scheme when I first laid eyes on the online photos...but with a new example in hand, my opinion has changed somewhat. To me, and I know this is a personal opinion, the new Juice appears to be unfinished.
Above, we see the old versus the new Juice CS4. You can see the solid anodized colours of the older lineup. The new Juice lineup all feature a two tone scheme. Not so bad, but they also decided to texturize those scales from the plain side. In person, I am less than happy. Not only does it make the tool look unfinished, but the texturized coloured scale is super thin. It is only a super thin covering. Not only is it super thin covering over the regular thick scale hidden underneath, but it feels like light aluminium. There are several reasons why I am less pleased with this. The old Juice line had nice weighty and thick scales. The new line feels cheap and flimsy compared to those older slabs. On top of that, because the covering is super thin, it makes for a fairly sharp edge in places. This just compounds the cheap feel of the new Juice lineup. Paint me not a big fan of this...and yet, when I first spied them online, I thought they looked good. In hand, it is a different matter.
The above photo shows the backside of both Juice CS4s. The older CS4 had Leatherman written on the back. The newer one lacks this. You can see the dimpling texture on the newer Juice. If they had added the texturing to the other side, it would make the tool more uniform. Personally, I would ditch the texturing as it makes the tool feel cheap due to its thinness. Yeah, I guess they probably should have touched the Juice lineup in the first place.
You can't really tell from this photo, but the pliers are slightly different. The older pliers being more angular The newer ones have more of a taper towards the distal end. Frankly, I believe under that new textured scale is a full sized scale. It is just a super thin covering. I was prepared to like the new Juices...but no. I just can't rally up to that.
Overall, there aren't many differences between the older and newer CS4. Just a few minor cosmetic changes added to 2 larger changes. Can you spot anything different in the above photograph?
Those of keen eyes would have noticed they changed the nail nicks on the Flathead screwdriver as seen in the above photograph.
They in fact changed how one access these tools that reside in one of the handles. Not sure why they decided to make it all even as seen in the above photo. Personally, I sort of like the staggered formation seen in the older tool. At least I could get the one I wanted without pulling them all out. This is a step backwards in my opinion...but one ultimately based on personal opinion.
The other big change is the knife blade. This is another change not for the better in my opinion. The newer blade sports more of a wharncliffe pattern compared to the older drop point blade. To add insult to injury, the newer blade is also shorter. The sad part of this, there is just as much room in the newer tool for the older blade lenght. Is this some sort of cost cutting method to save on steel? Your guess is as good as mine.
A better look at those two blades. Guess which one I like better? :D
The only other difference I could see was a cosmetic one. Here is the only change I actually like, and it is the one that matters the least...go figure. The newer font looks a lot better than the older simpler font for the name plate found on the edge of the tool. The newer version is above the older version in the above photo.
So there you have it. At first, I was all for the new look of the Juice lineup. However, in hand, I do not much care for them compared to the older Juices. They just covered one side with a cheap textured plate that makes the whole tool feel decidedly economical. The knife blade does not dissuade this viewpoint either. I can only see the new blade as a cost cutting initiative. It does come sharp, but that is the only polite thing I can say about it. I suppose if you have never seen an older Juice or have one to make a direct comparison, the blade is passable shape-wise, but I can't forgive the shorter blade length. The change in the nail nicks on one handle to me is also a step backwards. The older staggered formation is more convenient to me. This is a nit pick however, as I can easily live with the new configuration. I just have to wonder why they would "upgrade" something that wasn't broke in the first place.

-
Wow thanks for those photos. Love the Juice size, but the looks always turned me away.
It appears that the wire-cutter surface is shorter on the new plier-head. Could you confirm/deny that
-
They are about the same size.
-
That's for the review! Do the inside tools open better or are they still finger cutters?
live from Nate's mobile
-
Thanks for the great comparison! Ive always liked the Juices... unfortunately they're way too expensive for me and I never summoned my courage to buy one... Maybe because I never had one and "craved" the old ones for ages, I still like the appearance of the older ones better (I can't talk about functionality).
But it's weird that the blade of the new one's shorter, indeed. What if they wanted to make those tools more... carry-friendly i.e. shorter blades would be allowed/better accepted in public places? (I have no idea how long the old one was and if that length is forbidden in some countries)
I also think that the way you take out the inside tools on the first model should be easier than the second

And as for the prices, which model is cheaper? Or are they at the same price?
-
That appears to be slightly improved.
N_N_R, that could be the reason. The newer shape might look friendlier to other people I guess. I am not a fan of the new blade however.
-
Yes, I too think that the new mixed colours look a bit like those old cars with different coloured doors; like they could not find matching ones.
I thought the blade was made smaller to make it legal in more places.
How long is the new one? -
The old blade is 2 1/4".
The new blade is 2". -
Thanks Dan
There wasn't much danger of me buying one,but this kinda buried the whole idea! I do like the look of the new blade!Here's an idea: This new REV that's being talked about...will it be a Juice replacement? Or will it be based around Juice components?
-
Good comparisation

-
I was a little afraid of that. They're fiddling. The only actual improvement I see here is the improved logo font on the edge of the tool, that does look better. I think the two-tone look could have been good if they kept the finish the same between both sides, but they went with that diamond plate texture for no reason I could think of. I'm in the Like The Juice But Never Bought One club, and I think I'm going to stay there.
-
The old blade is 2 1/4".
The new blade is 2".I do not see that change affecting the legality....** maybe it was so that they could have been carried in airplanes...** or to save money / make it look friendlier...
taaaaaaapaaaaaaas
This is exactly there reasoning. They shortened the blade just in case they made a 2" blade legal to carry on airplanes.

-
As a Leatherman focused collector, I am doomed into buying all of them eventually.

-
I also have a new Juice S2, but this one is even more annoying, as the thin textured scale covers have a little bit of play in them.

-
Good comparison Dan

I agree with you on the new inline formation of the screwdrivers - huge mistake in my opinion.
Silly question to ask but are these genuine USA built tools. They don't look it

P.S not forgotten about the shovel - been away all week. Its in the vault in my garage which at present is buried under god-knows-what
I'm hoping to have a bit of a sort out soon. -
No hurry, good things are always worth the wait. :)
-
Thanks for the side by side pics, Dan.

-
You are welcome.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login








