My small adventure into 58mm SAK modding!
-
Syph007 58mm assembly line. :ahhh
Looking good.

-
I asked my waterjet guy about doing a run of 58 parts to be able to make a buch, but those small holes are too small to waterjet, so doing them this way is still going to be the best until I finish the CNC conversion, then I can have a tool spot the holes instead of using liners to get them drilled just right.
-
So, how are you doing on the pliers?

(Am I being too impatient?
) -
@bmot said:
So, how are you doing on the pliers?

(Am I being too impatient?
)Changed gears on that one, going with a much simpler way to lock the pliers closed. I'll have pics of that in a bit. The sliding thing was way too complicated and well it just got out of hand. For the purpose of simplicity I got a better idea to just use a small thick O ring anchored into the SAK and then locked into a groove on the pliers handle to hold it down.
Sometimes simple is just a better idea.
-
Re: galling of dissimilar metals.
Galling is only a serious problem when the dissimilar parts are in close contact, and under pressure. Think of a Ti screw tightened into a steel tapped hole, or something similar.
I doubt a 58mm SAK would need preventative measures to prevent galling, as the loads are not high enough (possible exception being the assembly screws/pins), but there is a preparation that helps prevent galling, even when the loads are high. There's an anti-seizure "lubricant" called Ti-Prep, made by Finish Line. I used it quite a bit when I was into lightweight bicycles with Ti componentry and threading.......never had a thread seize on me.
I checked downstairs, I still have most of a syringe-full left. -
@neillcurrie said:
Re: galling of dissimilar metals.Galling is only a serious problem when the dissimilar parts are in close contact, and under pressure. Think of a Ti screw tightened into a steel tapped hole, or something similar.
I doubt a 58mm SAK would need preventative measures to prevent galling, as the loads are not high enough (possible exception being the assembly screws/pins), but there is a preparation that helps prevent galling, even when the loads are high. There's an anti-seizure "lubricant" called Ti-Prep, made by Finish Line. I used it quite a bit when I was into lightweight bicycles with Ti componentry and threading.......never had a thread seize on me.
I checked downstairs, I still have most of a syringe-full left.When I assembled the first Ti minichamp I did, the tools were pretty sticky and they would get a gouged round groove on all the tools. The carbidizer takes only minutes to use to coat the friction surfaces so thats been a fine solution. It was a really bad problem on the 93mm Ti ones I did, so much so that the tools would not even move freely at all. The first couple I would use
I also made a Ti tool and what I did on that was to carbidize the spring itself and that let the Ti pivot move freely.
The one trick though about doing the carbide layer deposit is that it goes does a bit rough, but I wet sand it with 800 grit and its silky smooth.
-
Re: galling of dissimilar metals.
Galling is only a serious problem when the dissimilar parts are in close contact, and under pressure. Think of a Ti screw tightened into a steel tapped hole, or something similar.
I doubt a 58mm SAK would need preventative measures to prevent galling, as the loads are not high enough (possible exception being the assembly screws/pins), but there is a preparation that helps prevent galling, even when the loads are high. There's an anti-seizure "lubricant" called Ti-Prep, made by Finish Line. I used it quite a bit when I was into lightweight bicycles with Ti componentry and threading.......never had a thread seize on me.
I checked downstairs, I still have most of a syringe-full left.When I assembled the first Ti minichamp I did, the tools were pretty sticky and they would get a gouged round groove on all the tools. The carbidizer takes only minutes to use to coat the friction surfaces so thats been a fine solution. It was a really bad problem on the 93mm Ti ones I did, so much so that the tools would not even move freely at all. The first couple I would use
I also made a Ti tool and what I did on that was to carbidize the spring itself and that let the Ti pivot move freely.
The one trick though about doing the carbide layer deposit is that it goes does a bit rough, but I wet sand it with 800 grit and its silky smooth.
Yes, I had forgotten that in my case galling was seldom an issue, as despite the compressive loads on most bicycle parts, the parts seldom actually rotate or move over each other. The parts that do move are usually non-Ti bearings or hardened steel (the chain, sprockets, chainrings).
I'm sure the Carbidizer solves the problem...........and you have the machine already, so good to go! -
Well I spent awhile cutting out Ti blanks for 58 mods the other day and figured I'd like to try texturing one. It turned out fine, but not the smoothest finish. I really need flood coolant and to play with the speeds to see what works best. I'll still build this into a Ti rambler to see how it looks though as the front scale.
Its very grippy thats for sure. Looks a little better in person since its a pretty small part.
-
@Syph007 said:
Well I spent awhile cutting out Ti blanks for 58 mods the other day and figured I'd like to try texturing one. It turned out fine, but not the smoothest finish. I really need flood coolant and to play with the speeds to see what works best. I'll still build this into a Ti rambler to see how it looks though as the front scale.Its very grippy thats for sure. Looks a little better in person since its a pretty small part.
That is awesome Syph!! I see
goodgreat things in your the future!!Wouldn't a MQL mist work well for cooling?
-
@Syph007 said:
Well I spent awhile cutting out Ti blanks for 58 mods the other day and figured I'd like to try texturing one. It turned out fine, but not the smoothest finish. I really need flood coolant and to play with the speeds to see what works best. I'll still build this into a Ti rambler to see how it looks though as the front scale.Its very grippy thats for sure. Looks a little better in person since its a pretty small part.
That's really cool.
Sent from my HTC One X using Tapatalk
-
I'm finalizing a Ti 58 today that had some options I havent done before. One was the Ti anodized liners.

The other was to have the awl from a 91mm replace the cuticle pusher / ruler layer.
The awl actually fits really well. I filled the original 2.5mm hole with brass and re-drilled a 1/16th inch hole for the right spot for a 58mm hole. In this super up close pic you can see what I mean.




This is just a test setup to see if the awl works and it does. Snap is perfect. The only other thing it needed was a very very did I say very, tiny washer that is 0.010" thick. That was not fun to make. I drilled a 1/16th inch hole in some sheet stock, and then by hand and with needle nose pliers turned it into a round washer.
The Ti scales for this one also spent the night in my vibratory tumbler so they are a matte grey color now. More pics later today when I do the assembly.
Cheers

-
Washer on 58mm ? This is top level modding.
Sent from my HTC One X using Tapatalk
-
WOW... just did something similar... since I couldn't find the cotton picker/orange peeler I added the awl from a 91mm

and here you can see the tiny brass washer...

I didn't round the tang or filled the original hole with brass. Great work Syph... :)
-
Ha, yes yours looks pretty close to what Im putting together. Going out to work on it now.

-
Here she is all done now. The liners look pretty sweet on the finished SAK. :D I tumbled the scales in ceramic pyramids for a day and they have a light matte gray look to them.







-
Soooo.... How's the 91mm-pliers-in-a-58mm-SAK project going?

-
I had a request to merge the older wide USB layer into a cellidor minichamp. It worked out fine, but of course a litte on the wide side. :D







-
Great work with the awl.
Have you tried putting the small knife from a 91mm into the 58mm frame, and so being able to take out the two blades currently used, which I always thought were a bit weedy and too similar to need both of them.
-
Great job on the awl integration!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login