Self defense Folder, deployment method.
-
@cbl51 said:
There's no winner in a knife fight. One goes to the morgue, the other goes to the ER, maybe to survive, maybe not. That's if the other guy has a knife and you're dumb enough to pull one too. If he has a buddy or accomplice standing by as lookout, that guy may see you pull a knife, and he panics and pulls that old Davis .380 and shoots you.Totally agree, no further truth than this.
Flashing someone in a dark area, when you and opponent's eyes are dark adjusted, will also dampen your own vision. Unless you intend to keep the lights on, it may be a little hard to navigate after the flash when escaping full speed. The easiest way to test this is to find an unfamiliar dark room with furniture, flash a blank room 1-2 feet in front of you then turn around and try to run away full speed. It makes great entertainment at night.
:DFlashlights are directional, so unless the person you're shining a light at throws a mirror up at the last second this simply isn't true. Shining a flashlight in tight confines as opposed to a street are very different situations due to ambient light and the lack of reflective surfaces.
Certainly, and the 'target' to flash on is not stationary too.
Pardon me to even suggest this silly experiment, and I agree there are probably dozens of factors in play, and any 'discussion' on those are merely academic. What essentially the message I trying to convey is there are no certainty on how effective the 'flash-hit-run' will work, and to think the opponent/criminal is going to stand still/dumbfounded after the flash is wishful thinking. Afterall, it is a flashlight, not a flashbang.
Back to the knife survival, I have trained with friends who served in military/police force/security detail around the world, and I have yet to meet someone who has a good knife fight story to tell. Most are just thankful to walk away ok. As I previously said in some other threads, the best kind of self defense/survival for me is situation awareness, plan ahead and avoid confrontation. Sometimes "throwing away your wallet and run the other way" may hurt your ego, but I am sure you and your family will agree your life worth more than the ego and wallet combined.

-
To each their own and all that, but I know, 100%, that without my Karambit I would be dead. With it not a drop of blood was shed and we both got to part ways. It worked for me on a few occasions and those few occasions could have cost me my life, one most certainly would have. I'm glad I had one and glad that I have had the training (Military, PPS, Silat, and Kali).
-
@jekostas said:
I don't carry knives for self-defense and I would probably never draw one (should I be carrying) in such a situation.Knives have crappy range, are reliant on fine motor skills (folders more than fixed blades), lack stopping power, and last but definitely not least, are considered lethal force weapons just about everywhere on the planet.
I'd much rather use my brain to avoid a confrontation, or at least a really good pair of running shoes. In the absolute "must do something" situation (a situation that almost never happens, statistically, unless it's part of your job) I'd want a bright flashlight or a good weighty piece of pipe, in that order.
In the case of a "brewing " confrontation , where one can anticipate thing going south , I would prefer discrete two hand opening , or low profile( quiet ) opening behind the right leg . If rapid response was needed , - I'd use the wave .
Chris
This is a really grey area. Besides the legality of drawing a knife, it's an act that can escalate a confrontation from "puffing out your chest" to "well this guy (or girl) and 5 of their friends are waiting for you around the corner with baseball bats".
@comis said:
Flashing someone in a dark area, when you and opponent's eyes are dark adjusted, will also dampen your own vision. Unless you intend to keep the lights on, it may be a little hard to navigate after the flash when escaping full speed. The easiest way to test this is to find an unfamiliar dark room with furniture, flash a blank room 1-2 feet in front of you then turn around and try to run away full speed. It makes great entertainment at night.
:DFlashlights are directional, so unless the person you're shining a light at throws a mirror up at the last second this simply isn't true. Shining a flashlight in tight confines as opposed to a street are very different situations due to ambient light and the lack of reflective surfaces.
-
Situational awareness is the best approach , however , nobody is infallable . A blade is quite a viable weapon , when you consider most civilian shootings are at 1.5 - 3 m. ( remember the "Tuller Drill " , which indicates the need for a 10 21' -10m. saftey zone ) . I have pre deployed discretly a couple of times - in neither case did the goof have a foggy clue !
Outside of the prison system , knife on knife is very rare . Other permutations are much more common .
Handgun stopping power is pretty limited .
Given a choice , I would take impact , over edged weapons , every time .
Chris
-
To each there own I guess. I would rather have the option than not. Besides every day cutting tasks which is obviously why I carry a folder there are dog attacks all the time and if you have a dog latched onto your arm or leg good luck getting it to let go or stop attacking you. A folder is invaluable and could most definitely save your life or someone else in that sort of situation. You don't have to worry about the dog taking your weapon and using it against you either. No thumbs. :D
-
This thread had turned to different direction unexpectedly.
There are people who believe a folder can be use in self defense while others do not.
Let's agree to disagree.let me rephrase the question I asked at the beginning: What is your favorite deployment method for folding knife?
-
@Kampfer said:
This thread had turned to different direction unexpectedly.
There are people who believe a folder can be use in self defense while others do not.
Let's agree to disagree.let me rephrase the question I asked at the beginning: What is your favorite deployment method for folding knife?
Spydie hole for me. It offers the most reliable deployment for me. When I use something with a thumb stud I find a lot of half deployments or my thumb looking for the thumb stud. The Spydie hole offers a very easily found and deployed method.
-
@captain spaulding said:
This thread had turned to different direction unexpectedly.
There are people who believe a folder can be use in self defense while others do not.
Let's agree to disagree.let me rephrase the question I asked at the beginning: What is your favorite deployment method for folding knife?
Spydie hole for me. It offers the most reliable deployment for me. When I use something with a thumb stud I find a lot of half deployments or my thumb looking for the thumb stud. The Spydie hole offers a very easily found and deployed method.
+1 With Kershaw's Speedsafe AO system a close second actually. I carried a Scallion or Leek for a long time, still two of my favorite carry blades.

-
I found "wave" is the quickest, funniest way to play with, maybe not the most reliable however.
I mod my 746 with "nut job" which offers wave, stud & hole altogether. -
A thumbhole for me (Spydiehole, or other brands). I find lots of thumbstuds get hooked to my pocket when clipped, and are just less good looking.
-
@captain spaulding said:
To each there own I guess. I would rather have the option than not. Besides every day cutting tasks which is obviously why I carry a folder there are dog attacks all the time and if you have a dog latched onto your arm or leg good luck getting it to let go or stop attacking you. A folder is invaluable and could most definitely save your life or someone else in that sort of situation. You don't have to worry about the dog taking your weapon and using it against you either. No thumbs. :DCapt, you brought up a very interesting point, not to drag away from the discussion any further...let me just say, instead of using a knife for self defense, I will much rather to have:
A. My Dog:

Or
B. My green little friend:

:D
@Kampfer said:
I found "wave" is the quickest, funniest way to play with, maybe not the most reliable however.
I mod my 746 with "nut job" which offers wave, stud & hole altogether.Maybe I am a little MTcentric, so I too do like the LM OHO blade quite a bit. I think part of the reason being most OHO blades on LM are not directly centered, so the other fingers could have a good grip and leverage to help open the blade.
I am mixed about thumstuds, and it all boils down to how the geometry and design of the knife. For example, regardless how much time I spend on it, I still dislike the CRK thumstuds. But on the other hand, I love my Brisa Enzo Birk 75 and how well it open and close.
I am never a Spydie fan, but the 111mm Vic OHO Trekker really did reignite my interest in thumbholes. Currently I do like the newly acquired Benchmade Bone collector(with thumbhole) quite a bit and warming up to Spydie offerings.
-
I've been avoiding responding to this thread since I didn't want to become embroiled in the debate about the use of folders for self defense. So, I won't comment on that at all, but will answer the questions originally asked.
@Kampfer said:
Let's say you carry a folder for self defense, do you believe one hand open is absolutely necessary?I'm sure some people have successfully defended themselves with folders that were not OHO. However, if one were shopping specifically for a folder for self defense, I would think OHO would be a prerequisite.
@Kampfer said:
What is your favorite deployment method? thumb stub, hole, assist, wave?If favorite means what I use the most, the answer would be 2HO using a nail nick. For OHO knives, I usually pinch either the handle or the blade and use inertia to flip them open, so it doesn't matter if they have a thumb hole, thumb stud, or neither. I believe the wave must be the fastest way to open a folder, since the draw and open happen at the same time in a single motion. While I find the wave very clever, I personally don't generally carry waved knives since (1) the selection is limited, (2) they are hard on the pockets, and (3) I can usually access any knife I carry reasonably quickly, and don't foresee many situations in which the extra second is going to make a difference (and if I thought I would need to get a knife out with all possible speed, I would probably opt for a fixed blade over a folder). Finally, I don't like assisted knives.
@Kampfer said:
Do you think such method is totally reliable under pressure in a split of second?
Or old fashion two hand open is more reliable?No method is totally fail-safe. However, the fewer motions are required, the less complex those motions are, and the more one practices, the more sure any chosen method becomes. With regard to the final question, note that any OHO knife can be opened with two hands, if desired, but the reverse is not true.
-
@nate j said:
I've been avoiding responding to this thread since I didn't want to become embroiled in the debate about the use of folders for self defense. So, I won't comment on that at all, but will answer the questions originally asked.+1.
@Kampfer said:
Let's say you carry a folder for self defense, do you believe one hand open is absolutely necessary?I think it could be useful. Absolutely necessary, no.
@Kampfer said:
What is your favorite deployment method? thumb stub, hole, assist, wave?Of the options given I like thumb stud then spydie hole then flipper.
Not on your list but balisongs are fast andfunlets not forget autos.@Kampfer said:
Do you think such method is totally reliable under pressure in a split of second?Yes, I'm opening a knife not defusing a bomb.
@Kampfer said:
Or old fashion two hand open is more reliable?If you have an issue with the easy step of one hand opening, I don't see how using two hands will transform you into a more coordinated person.
-
-
@zoidberg said:
If you have an issue with the easy step of one hand opening, I don't see how using two hands will transform you into a more coordinated person.Opening a knife one-handed (regardless of practice or method) requires fine motor skills. Under stress, said fine motor skills tend to disappear very, very quickly.
Even with practice, you're much more likely to launch your knife about 10 feet away than successfully open it in the event that you are in danger and actually need it.It's not something that can be hand-waved away with "practice more".
-
If you have an issue with the easy step of one hand opening, I don't see how using two hands will transform you into a more coordinated person.
Opening a knife one-handed (regardless of practice or method) requires fine motor skills. Under stress, said fine motor skills tend to disappear very, very quickly.
Even with practice, you're much more likely to launch your knife about 10 feet away than successfully open it in the event that you are in danger and actually need it.It's not something that can be hand-waved away with "practice more".
I was trying to be subtle. Using it is going to be much harder than getting it open. Whatever the reason for using two hand opening, I hope you have the ability to deal with what comes next.
-
If you have an issue with the easy step of one hand opening, I don't see how using two hands will transform you into a more coordinated person.
Opening a knife one-handed (regardless of practice or method) requires fine motor skills. Under stress, said fine motor skills tend to disappear very, very quickly.
Even with practice, you're much more likely to launch your knife about 10 feet away than successfully open it in the event that you are in danger and actually need it.It's not something that can be hand-waved away with "practice more".
I'm curious, have you actually deployed or used a folder in a combat situation? Have you received training in using a blade/folder in combat?
Being able to put your thumb on a stud to open it up is no more a fine motor skill than being able to place your thumb on a slide release on a firearm yet many people do that exact thing every single day, successfully.
-
IF I can't just leave.
IF I don't have something little louder.
IF I don't have something I can grab and use as I would a sword or short staff.
IF I don't have a fixed blade.Thumb stud. Much easier to access with gloves on.
-
Well if you got some time then this might be a worth while video to take a look at since it does offer some interesting perspectives
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
