Most collectible Alox Victorinox Soldier?
-
Some years are low delivery to the army and some the ratio between Wengers and Victorinox makes it tricky to get a Victorinox (like 1972)
Some years are very common like 1981 ... the date on the knife is I believe when it was accepted into the stores rather than an issue date so they may have issued the 81's for a few years.
I am still missing a 58 which I think is the lowest production year (well its in the top 5 low years :( )
-
What would be the reason that for example the '69 model is apparently rarer than models from surrounding years, '70 for example? Were there years with fewer issued SAKs?

To quote jazzbass from the Soldier Trivia Contest thread:
- What is the only year since 1921 that there were no soldier knives of any type produced? --> 1960
- What year of the alox M61 Soldier is the hardest to find? --> 1995, followed by 1974 (Wenger SI only) and then 1972
- What year of the alox M61 Soldier is the easiest to find (excluding 2008)? --> 1983 (followed by 2003 and then 1991)
There are some years only Wenger or only Victorinox made Soldiers.
Right. Let me clarify my question a bit more: why from the other years, with regular SAK issues, some years seem much more difficult to find, worldwide, compared with other years? And my example was the '69.
-
@Marius said:
Right. Let me clarify my question a bit more: why from the other years, with regular SAK issues, some years seem much more difficult to find, worldwide, compared with other years? And my example was the '69.I can't tell you why exactly other than "They seem to have made less that year". I can tell you which years show up less, which is something that can be observed. Here's an updated version of the Soldier sales graph I made last year:
Updating from the old trivia thread, since I posted that there have been three 1960 models that have gone up for sale, so we can now say that there is a dated Soldier knife for every year since 1921.
You can see from this graph the years that show up the least post WWII are: 1961, 1960, 1958, 1946, 1995, 1974, 1972, 1969, 1951 and 1959.
Note to anyone paying $200 for a 2008 M651 Soldier - 2008 is not shown on this graph because there have been so many of them sold (250+) that it skews the Y axis and makes it harder to see the numbers on the other years. They are very, very not rare.
-
Amazing collection
ok little bump back,where is the best place to pick up date stamped soldiers,im after a 1970 preferably in red (was there one ?) vic or wenger,thanks for any help 
-
@nsa-x-file said:
The older years from 1962 to 1971 are by far the hardest to find in new shape and the most valuable.
I've almost finished my complete Elsener/Victorinox run from 1962 to 2008 with just a couple more years to find. With my best find to date being a Red 1971 brand new in box. Almost all of mine are brand new.
Man... I was born in 1971 and already have a Silver Soldier 71 brand new... If you ever decide to sell that Red 1971 to a person willing to give his life for it
... just let me know...
:D ;) -
Sweet collection..... Wish I would have started collecting 12 years ago (when I first got interested) instead of last year, when I got re-interested. I gave away countless numbers of these dated between 2001 - 2004.
-
The 1970's reds can be a bit tricky as some can be early 60's ones that have been repaired but its always nice to find a good one :)
here is a 78 I found



-
. So there would of been a 70 in red ,would that be both manufacturers? -
Wow, very impressive collection, congratulations

The 71 is great :ahhh
Thanks.

Almost complete now. Just need to find the 69' and 74' :ahhhDo you need a silver 1974 Soldier? I may be able to get one
-
Wow, very impressive collection, congratulations

The 71 is great :ahhh
Thanks.

Almost complete now. Just need to find the 69' and 74' :ahhhDo you need a silver 1974 Soldier? I may be able to get one
I managed to pick up a 69 and 74.
Thanks for thinking of me.
-
Just looking for a few more in better shape and i'm done.
-
wow - those are some great pics of some really nice collections.I'm still trying to track down one of the old models made in the forties from WWII so I can have one in my meager collection. I have a few older alox ones tucked away but nothing like some of you guys.
Impressive! Joe
-
Sometimes its really difficult to say, what is an original soldier and what is not. I`m 100% sure, that victorinox never produced a run in 1960. There are also some other years, where wenger or victorinox never produced soldiers for the army. So even if there appear hundreds of 1960 stamped soldiers on ebay, its true, that they are not original but fakes.
I`m sure, for collectors its really interesting to proove that there are some ultra rare stamped soldiers and they possess them :-)
I`m also 100% sure, that victorinox or wenger never produced red alox soldiers for the army after 1965.
What I know is that victorinox has a great service. I know from some guys who sent their old fiber soldiers to victorinox for repair. Victorinox replaced the scales, changed broken tools or the blade, and at the end, they put a WK-stamp on the scale, even if there wasn
t any WK-stamp before. You could also wish the blade-scale-combinations. Elsener senior was no collector at all. Around 10 years ago, victorinox didnt even have a small collection of their own knives. He was a business man, wanted to expand, make good money and one of his goal was to have a great service. So at ibach, they did and still do almost every service for the customers, as long as they pay it. So if you want a 75 red alox soldier, just send them a red and a silver 75 soldier with the wish to change the scales, and I`m sure, they will do that or at least did that in the past. When victorinox produced more year stamped blades than they could sell to the swiss army, they used them for other knives. Why would victorinox produce red alox soldiers for the army later, when they decided in 1965, that the product is not good enough for army issues and the silver alox scales are much more resistant?For alox soldiers, there are no repair stamps on the scales. So you
ll never know if the blade is original or not. Even the year stamp isnt always an indicator for the production year. For example, the 2009 soldiers were all produced in 2008. -
Excellent post, ulli.

-
@ulli said:
Sometimes its really difficult to say, what is an original soldier and what is not. I`m 100% sure, that victorinox never produced a run in 1960. There are also some other years, where wenger or victorinox never produced soldiers for the army. So even if there appear hundreds of 1960 stamped soldiers on ebay, its true, that they are not original but fakes.I`m sure, for collectors its really interesting to proove that there are some ultra rare stamped soldiers and they possess them :-)
I`m also 100% sure, that victorinox or wenger never produced red alox soldiers for the army after 1965.
What I know is that victorinox has a great service. I know from some guys who sent their old fiber soldiers to victorinox for repair. Victorinox replaced the scales, changed broken tools or the blade, and at the end, they put a WK-stamp on the scale, even if there wasn
t any WK-stamp before. You could also wish the blade-scale-combinations. Elsener senior was no collector at all. Around 10 years ago, victorinox didnt even have a small collection of their own knives. He was a business man, wanted to expand, make good money and one of his goal was to have a great service. So at ibach, they did and still do almost every service for the customers, as long as they pay it. So if you want a 75 red alox soldier, just send them a red and a silver 75 soldier with the wish to change the scales, and I`m sure, they will do that or at least did that in the past. When victorinox produced more year stamped blades than they could sell to the swiss army, they used them for other knives. Why would victorinox produce red alox soldiers for the army later, when they decided in 1965, that the product is not good enough for army issues and the silver alox scales are much more resistant?For alox soldiers, there are no repair stamps on the scales. So you
ll never know if the blade is original or not. Even the year stamp isnt always an indicator for the production year. For example, the 2009 soldiers were all produced in 2008.I would agree there are quite a few fakes out there the number of badly etched 58 soldiers I have seen is scary , not so sure about the 1970's reds ... we all see the odd 1980 / 90's red soldier turning up which is clearly an early 1960's with a replaced blade .... but in all the 71 /78's I have seen and the two I currently have the WK stamp is horizontal not vertical and non of my 1960's knifes have this. Maybe in 71 Victorinox thought they had perfected a harder wearing red ... and a limited trial was done.
Having said that my soldier collection turns silver in 66 and I have never been tempted to replace one with an even perfect red.
-
So is there a reference book that I can pick up that will walk me through all of the different Soldiers, production numbers, differences in the models, etc?
-
I would agree there are quite a few fakes out there the number of badly etched 58 soldiers I have seen is scary , not so sure about the 1970's reds ... we all see the odd 1980 / 90's red soldier turning up which is clearly an early 1960's with a replaced blade .... but in all the 71 /78's I have seen and the two I currently have the WK stamp is horizontal not vertical and non of my 1960's knifes have this. Maybe in 71 Victorinox thought they had perfected a harder wearing red ... and a limited trial was done.
Having said that my soldier collection turns silver in 66 and I have never been tempted to replace one with an even perfect red.
[/quote]Just wanted to thank the OP for this thread as I received some pm's from fellow forum members which led to me being able to track down a couple of the old Soldier models I was looking out for. I'll post some pics when they arrive. Wanted to be sure to say that there's a great bunch of fellow collectors here helping each other out. Fantastic.
Jaydar - You aren't making me feel good about your post concerning the 58's. :)
As my user name indicates - I'm still in search of a 58 but sorry to hear there's fakes out there from that year. That, and using that for my forum name is easy for me to remember. Lol.
If I run across one, I'm going to have to try and get pics on here to help me verify.Joe
dmanuel - the SAKWIKI has a bunch of great info. And here of course.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login