First impressions of the 2014 Leatherman Juice S2
-
Hey guys,
I got a new toy today. One of the new Juice S2's. These are just my first impressions. Keep in mind I'm comparing this to my other Leathermans so I'm not pulling any of this out of nowhere. Hopefully it doesn't make me too unpopular :DScales
I'm not really a fan. First off it looks way better in photos than it does in real life. It's actually pretty ugly and the scales don't match up nicely. I know the old juice is wonky in terms of thickness too, but at least it feels uniform in terms of weight (I'd stick with the older model).
One side of the tool is a much thicker, solid stainless, then the other is a really light, real thin flimsy aluminum scale.

It's not only the thickness that is on the piss, the weight difference between the sides is significant. Look how wonky and on the piss all the springs and tools are too... nothing lines up.

Fit and finish
The springs on the tools are a bit average. The tool doesn't snap shut, it just gets to a point then stops trying to close itself. The scissors feel gritty, the can opener doesn't close properly (you have to guide it into where it sits).Here's what I mean about the snap up. The tool doesn't shut itself all the way.

Tools
Finally something nice to say :) The pliers feel really nice. I've seen a lot of people say/suggest the pliers (despite the size) aren't much better than the Squirt. The squirt is VERY capable for its size (I'm surprised mine isn't broken with what I've done with it) but the juice pliers already in my playing are far more capable than they look.The drivers are fine. It's great that the bit adapter goes on this Phillips, I didn't know that until recently. The flathead drivers are dangerous though... I cut my thumb (as per one of the earlier pics) just opening them. The same thing happened with my girlfriends Juice XE6 but the fine driver on this is even sharper than the earlier model.
The knife is a bit of a disappointment. They've made them WAY shorter. As in not much different from the small SAK blade. Look how much empty space there is for more knife

Perhaps that's for the UK guys? If so, that's a good enough reason. I suspect however it's so you can't put as much torque on the knife.

Size & weight
The dimensions are the same as the Fuse, except the Fuse is just over a centimeter longer.For the cost of one centimeter you lose:
-
Much more capable pliers
-
Long shanks on all the drivers
-
Locking tools.
-
Can opener (I know it has one but it looks and feels so flimsy I'd be too scared to use it)
And all you gain is scissors that have about 50% of a cutting length.

So overall
Compare to my other Leathermans, the build quality, feel and fit and finish isn't good. I actually think the older model one (the solid orange one) is better than this.I am getting the distinct impression after using a few Juices that I'm not in the target market.
I feel like even for urban EDC this isn't capable enough and isn't built well enough for me to want to risk actually having to do something with. In my jeans coin pocket a Rebar or Fuse is no more noticeable (as the only dimensional difference is a little length), and they're built tough.
-
-
Excellent comparison, thank you so much.
Now I even less want a Juice ;)I think that would be an excellent size but if the quality is not there, its simply sad. Picture No. 3 looks really worry-some.
-
Thank you for the review. Now I'm going to but and old model. :)
Sent from my HTC One X using Tapatalk
-
Thanks for the pictures!
Having read other topics here, I wasn't surprised by your negative impressions.My old version S2 snaps pretty well, but my old Xe6 (brand new) does the same thing like your new S2 - it just won't close on its own.
Yeah, before I'd read further, I was just wondering if that thing on your thumb hadn't been caused by a driver :D One of my Juices did the same, lol.
I'm getting more and more happy for snatching an old version S2 and Xe6 at the last moment.
-
I think the idea with the blade is that it is fractionally under 2 inches. LM assumed the Rules for taking knives on flights were going to be changed to allow blades under 2". They weren't and all that has happened is it looks like the new Juice has had the tip snapped of it's blade and been reprofiled on a bench grinder. UGLY.
Many people dislike the new Juice scales. I too think they look tacky and mismatched. Again LM have managed to take their tool that obviously has looks as one of its design criteria and make it look UGLY.
I am left permanently scratching my head over the uneven thickness between handles on the Juice tools. I could see it perhaps on one or two models as you add or remove tools but not on every single one??? I have CS4, S2 and C2 models and they all have this mismatch, it just looks half-arsed and UGLY.
I have been thinking about pulling my C2 apart and removing the corkscrew and its backspring just to make the damn thing even sided. If there was a way of grafting a pair of SAK scissors in there rather than that weirdo can/bottle opener thing, all the better.I know this all sounds negative, but I do like the Juice S2 that I own (old model) and think it is a nice light duty, sheeple friendly (bright colours, very non-tacticool looks) tool.
BUT, it could have been done sooooo much better.
-
Not surprised with your findings at all. I am not a big new Juice fan myself.
-
That weirdo can/bottle opener thing is also the corkscrew assist which helps in opening a bottle of wine. (as shown in the below linked thread)
</topic/24417
But if you're removing the corkscrew, then you can go ahead and remove that anyway.
When I first saw the original Juice line when they came out, I never thought about getting any of them. Did get a couple of the Squirt P4's though. Now seeing the new Juice line, they still don't appeal to me. I'd rather get a retired Flair instead.
-
I usually make up some excuse to buy just about every new or improved Leatherman MT, but I can't really do that here. If nothing else, that teeny blade makes no sense whatsoever. If Leatherman wanted to make a sub 2" flavor for certain jurisidictions (though I don't know what they would be) or for the TSA (though that ship has sailed), that would be fine. But to force the sub 2" blade on everyone is not groovy.
I guess what makes me so grumpy about both the old and new Juice is that it has so much untapped potential. Makes the two halves the same thickness. Reconfigure the drivers so the plier head does not bind when you close it. De-sharpen the drivers so they don't slice your fingers. Slap on some replaceable wire cutters (yeah, I said it). Make the blade as long as the MT will allow. Makes the scissors as precise as Victorinox does. Lose the weirdo corkscrew assist thing. Offer it in Powernoodle Blue. There is so much untapped potential there. Rock on.
-
@powernoodle said:
I usually make up some excuse to buy just about every new or improved Leatherman MT, but I can't really do that here. If nothing else, that teeny blade makes no sense whatsoever. If Leatherman wanted to make a sub 2" flavor for certain jurisidictions (though I don't know what they would be) or for the TSA (though that ship has sailed), that would be fine. But to force the sub 2" blade on everyone is not groovy.I guess what makes me so grumpy about both the old and new Juice is that it has so much untapped potential. Makes the two halves the same thickness. Reconfigure the drivers so the plier head does not bind when you close it. De-sharpen the drivers so they don't slice your fingers. Slap on some replaceable wire cutters (yeah, I said it). Make the blade as long as the MT will allow. Makes the scissors as precise as Victorinox does. Lose the weirdo corkscrew assist thing. Offer it in Powernoodle Blue. There is so much untapped potential there. Rock on.
Thanks Powernoodle you nailed what I was thinking as well. SO much potential with this line as there really isn't a competitor if done right. I like my old S2 minus the flat drivers that apparently like to bite everyone. SO much potential in this line and while they are making a Powernoodle blue make a green one as well.
-
I'm going to be getting a cs4 in blue sooner or later and after reading this I know **for sure **I want the old model.
I was a little undecided.
thanks RimfireNZ
:)
-
I had been eyeballing a CS4 as well.
How does one tell the difference between a new and old CS4? I'm new to the Juice line.
-
The old style juice's are much nicer! I would stick with the older ones! Nice review though! :)
-
@Chako said:
Not surprised with your findings at all. I am not a big new Juice fan myself.Chako, you did a side by side comparison of the drivers which appeared to show the new model small driver was longer than the old model small driver. If so that would provide a wider landing area for the plier jaw and probably eliminate the susceptibility for the pliers jamming on closing.
If so, great if you could confirm, finally LM slip in without comment a fix to a long standing design issue.
I "sorted" my new pre-2014 S2 by filing a flat on the plier jaw.
For me in nanny UK, the S2 is a perfect urban EDC "SAK with pliers" but I won't be opening cans with it or otherwise abusing it. Too expensive and with hints of fragility.
-
Pingu mentioned the drivers, so here's the new vs old juice drivers


And the knife

-
@RimfireNZ said:
Pingu mentioned the drivers, so here's the new vs old juice driversThanks for that. Looks longer. I think the acid test is does the new model jaw closed from fully open now land on the full width part of the small driver and not the bevelled section (with a rounded jaw :ahhh) with the old model?
I reprofiled the old model blade tip to make it even more nanny friendly. Lost less than half the length loss of the new model. Not unhappy but would not want it the length of the new one.
One other comment. When I first heard about the textured scale I thought surely a solution to the uneven thickness issue. Err... no. What a wasted opportunity.
-
@pingu said:
Thanks for that. Looks longer. I think the acid test is does the new model jaw closed from fully open now land on the full width part of the small driver and not the bevelled section (with a rounded jaw :ahhh) with the old model?I think I know what you mean. If you have the pliers wide open, and you fold the handles around to close the LM, I have had it catch (my Wave does this too, but strangely not the Charge). I have to close the pliers before trying to fold the handles... if that makes sense?
-
That really looks horrible with only one handle being colored. Leatherman, what are you thinking

-
@mashguy4077 said:
That really looks horrible with only one handle being colored. Leatherman, what are you thinking
Agreed, and the one handle being thicker than the other is aesthetically displeasing. :-\
-
Nothing they did could be considered an improvement besides maybe the alterations to the drivers. MAYBE the two-tone look could have worked, if they hadn't also done that stupid diamondplate texture. And who shortens a knife on purpose?
The stupid thing is, they could have made a KILLING if they had just brought out one new model of Juice, like an Sf4 that's pretty much the Cs4 but with a file instead of the corkscrew. Color it green (on both sides) and build a new wing onto the factory to hold all the money. Hell, if they brought back the Kf4 they'd have done great.
I'm gonna see if I can't get hold of a classic S2 or Cs4. I think that's my next purchase, if it isn't a Squirt. It's been half a year since I bought a multi.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login