First impressions of the 2014 Leatherman Juice S2
-
The old style juice's are much nicer! I would stick with the older ones! Nice review though! :)
-
@Chako said:
Not surprised with your findings at all. I am not a big new Juice fan myself.Chako, you did a side by side comparison of the drivers which appeared to show the new model small driver was longer than the old model small driver. If so that would provide a wider landing area for the plier jaw and probably eliminate the susceptibility for the pliers jamming on closing.
If so, great if you could confirm, finally LM slip in without comment a fix to a long standing design issue.
I "sorted" my new pre-2014 S2 by filing a flat on the plier jaw.
For me in nanny UK, the S2 is a perfect urban EDC "SAK with pliers" but I won't be opening cans with it or otherwise abusing it. Too expensive and with hints of fragility.
-
Pingu mentioned the drivers, so here's the new vs old juice drivers


And the knife

-
@RimfireNZ said:
Pingu mentioned the drivers, so here's the new vs old juice driversThanks for that. Looks longer. I think the acid test is does the new model jaw closed from fully open now land on the full width part of the small driver and not the bevelled section (with a rounded jaw :ahhh) with the old model?
I reprofiled the old model blade tip to make it even more nanny friendly. Lost less than half the length loss of the new model. Not unhappy but would not want it the length of the new one.
One other comment. When I first heard about the textured scale I thought surely a solution to the uneven thickness issue. Err... no. What a wasted opportunity.
-
@pingu said:
Thanks for that. Looks longer. I think the acid test is does the new model jaw closed from fully open now land on the full width part of the small driver and not the bevelled section (with a rounded jaw :ahhh) with the old model?I think I know what you mean. If you have the pliers wide open, and you fold the handles around to close the LM, I have had it catch (my Wave does this too, but strangely not the Charge). I have to close the pliers before trying to fold the handles... if that makes sense?
-
That really looks horrible with only one handle being colored. Leatherman, what are you thinking

-
@mashguy4077 said:
That really looks horrible with only one handle being colored. Leatherman, what are you thinking
Agreed, and the one handle being thicker than the other is aesthetically displeasing. :-\
-
Nothing they did could be considered an improvement besides maybe the alterations to the drivers. MAYBE the two-tone look could have worked, if they hadn't also done that stupid diamondplate texture. And who shortens a knife on purpose?
The stupid thing is, they could have made a KILLING if they had just brought out one new model of Juice, like an Sf4 that's pretty much the Cs4 but with a file instead of the corkscrew. Color it green (on both sides) and build a new wing onto the factory to hold all the money. Hell, if they brought back the Kf4 they'd have done great.
I'm gonna see if I can't get hold of a classic S2 or Cs4. I think that's my next purchase, if it isn't a Squirt. It's been half a year since I bought a multi.
-
Maybe we'll soon see the new Juices in the section "Discontinued" and something new will pop up
Or the good old :D :D -
Disturbing. Disappointing.
The new handles look like garbage. By having them be different thicknesses torques the hing when you're using the screwdrivers on a stiff fastener. That they can't get that part right shows me just how much the new management at Leatherman just doesn't want to produce a 50th Anniversary PST
The screwdrivers are still an inexcusable design failure. EVERY Juice owner I know has cut themselves multiple time, becuase they can't be bothered to break the edges. And the blade... really? Even if you shorten the blade, make it look like it was intentional, rather than looking like it was ground down after losing the tip.
I agree, the sub-2" thing probably would have been cool IF the TSA had deigned to allow sane, rational adults have adult tools. But that should have been a special model, maybe even a knifeless model.
The Juice is supposed to be LM's answer to the SAKs. But they keep failing. Fail, fail, fail, year after year. I have to wonder what their sales look like for this line. They either need to fix problems the serious users (us) have been calling them out on, or drop the production and put that tool like into making more of the tools that make them money. I love Leatherman tools, but the new Juices aren't going to help them.
-
@powernoodle said:
Powernoodle Blue. There is so much untapped potential there. Rock on.Powernoodle Blue, weren't they Nugent's opening act on the Free For All Tour?
-
Many folks here know I wasn't a fan of the old design either. I agree there is a lot of untapped potential in these tools, but I am sure that Leatherman succeeded in their primary motivation in the redesign. There was one specific factor in the design they needed to improve - the profit margin. They've been fighting in a receeding market with escalating costs for some time, and some of their other products have also been reviewed for cost reduction
It seems like they have made significant changes to reduce their manufacturing costs on the Juice line, though not done themselves any favours regarding the quality or appeal of the tools. Whilst I personally wasn't a fan of the old models, there were lots of people who sang their praises, leading to other people making a purchase. I can't see these cheaper (built) models having the same fanbase and "peer marketing"
-
@50ft-trad said:
Many folks here know I wasn't a fan of the old design either. I agree there is a lot of untapped potential in these tools, but I am sure that Leatherman succeeded in their primary motivation in the redesign. There was one specific factor in the design they needed to improve - the profit margin. They've been fighting in a receeding market with escalating costs for some time, and some of their other products have also been reviewed for cost reductionIt seems like they have made significant changes to reduce their manufacturing costs on the Juice line, though not done themselves any favours regarding the quality or appeal of the tools. Whilst I personally wasn't a fan of the old models, there were lots of people who sang their praises, leading to other people making a purchase. I can't see these cheaper (built) models having the same fanbase and "peer marketing"
Cost reducing is really shooting yourself in the foot though I would have thought. We like them for their quality and capability. I'd pay $10 more for a model if it meant it was built better.
And yeah there were a lot of people singing praise about the Juice line (i.e. Nutnfancy on Youtube along with a lot of other similar channels) so I figured it'd be great... so I'm one of the chumps you were talking about :P. I got hold of mine and was like "What the hell is this supposed to be?".
Ah well, it can stay in the back of my cupboard.
-
I still like the old version juice S2. This new version made me buy a brand new one of them as backup. :D I tried a few other juice models but they felt like bricks to me, so the S2 is the only one I have.
-
Fugly
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login