how about can openers???? useless!!!!
-
no, not enough tools for me. and again another bottle opener.
-
I use it. Just used my SAK to open a can for dinner the other day.
If you dislike them so much buy a SOG so you can replace them with something else.
-
I use the can opener on my SAK almost daily. It's great for opening cans(obviously), as a makeshift Phillips screwdriver, a scraper, a lightweight chisel, small flathead screwdriver etc etc. In fact if a multi-tool doesn't have a can opener it's pretty much a deal breaker for me. I always thought that it would be terrible to starve to death in a fully stocked bunker because you didn't have a can opener.
-
I suppose you could open up cans using the flat screwdriver as a chisel with a rock or hammer. Although i never tried it, you may be able to work through a can top just using the pliers..?
-
I've found it to be quite useful on multi's. I'd have to say that I use it more than I use the flat-bladed screwdriver.
-
The thing is that you can just add the can opener function to an existing tool, like the Vic Philips head/can opener combo. So if you get it for free, why not have one?
I hate having 3 flat heads which don't do anything else. So much wasted space...
I have to admit that I prefer the dedicated Wenger can opener to the Vic though. But even the Wenger can opener is useful for other things because it is so sharp. Some people use it as an awl, for example.
-
If you go Victorinox then the can opener has more than one use :), and beside's I actually use mine quite a bit :)
-
@sixgun said:
Biru asked everybody about the bottle opener, how about the can opener what the hell do you need a kitchen utensil on a multitool? do you use yours for anything other than opening a can or did you mod your can or bottle opener to make a new tool? maybe you changed it with something else.I agree.
I'd prefer that my multis had no canopener or bottleopener on them. The slots they take up could be used for some more useful implements.
I want a multitool, not a picnic tool.
If necessary, I can pop bottle tops off with a multi's pliers easily enough.
In an emergency, I can open a can using a multi's awl and/or its knife blade.
Anyways, I always have a P38 and a SAK handy for bottle and can opening tasks.
.
-
@max6166 said:
I have to admit that I prefer the dedicated Wenger can opener to the Vic though. But even the Wenger can opener is useful for other things because it is so sharp. Some people use it as an awl, for example.I'm begining to come around to your point of view.
I was a hard core Vic guy for many years.
However, since finding MTO and then SOSAK my eyes have been opened to the fact Wenger does indeed do some things better than Vic.
The Wenger canopener is one and the Wenger auto-locking screwdriver/bottleopener is another.
I bought a few Wengers and have been carrying them and comparing their performance to my Vics.
I haven't completely decided, but I may also prefer the Wenger SAK scissors and pliers over the Vic.
.
-
Wenger's scissor spring is nice, but I hate the serrated edge. Impossible to sharpen and doesn't give the feedback vic's plain edge does.
-
@jzmtl said:
Wenger's scissor spring is nice, but I hate the serrated edge. Impossible to sharpen and doesn't give the feedback vic's plain edge does.That serrated edge seems to cut better on more resistant materials such as thicker fingernails and plastic.
Maybe more difficult to sharpen, but surely not impossible. Wenger claims its scissors are self-sharpening, but I don't know how that works out in practice.
I've never sharpened the scissors on any of my Vic SAKs - I simply don't use the scissors enough for them to get really dull.
I think Wenger scissors may provide less feedback because they cut through things easier - less push required on the handle.
.
-
Can openers on a multi have the following advantages, even assuming they have no other use:
-
Compact to the point of not taking up any additional space at all (as opposed to carrying an additional SAK or P-38), as they're inside your indispensible multi.
-
Significantly more durable, as they're made to a higher standard than "kitchen utensils".
-
Allow for greater leverage; therefore, increased comfort and efficiency of operation.
Those arguing that rocks are a feasible alternative "in an emergency", would you please tell me why you bother with a multi at all? No need for a wood saw. After all, one can just break off a tree branch with their bare hands and a large rock. No need for a phillips - just use a regular screwdriver. It's an emergency, who cares? No need for a wire cutter - just twist and break the wire with your pliers, seeing how it's an official emergency and the whole world stopped to wait while you complete your extremely vital emergency task.
It's fascinating how some people imagine an "emergency" as some kind of a national holiday, where everyone enthusiastically improvises clever solutions to the emerging problems. Yes, you can open a can without a can opener in a well-lit laboratory equipped with the items statistically calculated to populate an average room or forest clearing. Try doing the same at four in the morning, in an actual forest, with a screaming infant at your ear and wolves howling in the distance. See how long it takes you to flatten the can with the nearest rock and shove it whole into the child's esophagus, bloody chunks of flesh hanging off your elbows. Who'll wish they had a can opener handy then, huh? HUH?
Thought so.
-
-
@Rodion said:
Can openers on a multi have the following advantages, even assuming they have no other use:- Compact to the point of not taking up any additional space at all (as opposed to carrying an additional SAK or P-38), as they're inside your indispensible multi.
They take up one of a limited number of implement slots that could be used for some more useful implement.
@Rodion said:
2. Significantly more durable, as they're made to a higher standard than "kitchen utensils".- Allow for greater leverage; therefore, increased comfort and efficiency of operation.
I don't see durability as an issue with most canopeners - certainly not those on SAKs or P38s which can be sharpened when necessary.
I prefer the ergonomics of a P38, P51, or SAK canopener - either Vic or Wenger - over the canopeners I've used on LM, Gerber, and SOG multis.
@Rodion said:
Yes, you can open a can without a can opener in a well-lit laboratory equipped with the items statistically calculated to populate an average room or forest clearing. Try doing the same at four in the morning, in an actual forest, with a screaming infant at your ear and wolves howling in the distance. See how long it takes you to flatten the can with the nearest rock and shove it whole into the child's esophagus, bloody chunks of flesh hanging off your elbows. Who'll wish they had a can opener handy then, huh? HUH?Thought so.
I don't see what the unlikely scenario above has to with some of us prefering multis without canopeners.
First, many people who buy multis are not looking for outdoors-oriented "pocket survival tools." They want a multitool to use around the house, on the job, or to carry in the car for emergency repairs.
Second, I've carried a LM PST for years outdoors and have almost never used its canopener. I carry P38s and SAKs for that eventuality and would much rather have that slot on the LM PST occupied by some more useful implement.
Third, I've opened cans with knife blades in the past and it's really not that difficult. If all else fails, use a knife blade. If a multi without a canopener is all you have and you really need to open a can, use its blade.
.
-
We had an emergency in the office the other day. One of my colleagues hadn't realised that the tin of tuna he had brought along as part of his diet, didn't have one of those modern ring-pull things.
Fortunately, I had supplied him with a Leatherman Blast a few weeks prior, and thus, the day was saved. Or at least his diet was, as the only alternative was a dodgy canteen supplied sandwich - phew!
Hurrah for the can opener! :D
-
I'm another vote for more MTs without the can/bottle opener, though I have used them on occasion so I still appreciate them. I'd just rather see the space filled with something else. LM's combo tool works ok for me though since it works as a bottle opener, can opener, awl (to a certain extent), and wirestripper. Still, I'd probably choose something else to fill the space if I had the choice.
Once again, I love the KF4.

-
I like having a can opener. I prefer the can opener to be combined with a bottle opener like Leatherman or with a screwdriver like Victorinox.
I don't use them very often because I EDC a P38. The can opener on a multitool serves as backup.
I'm aware that you can use a knife as a can opener, but I prefer not to because it tends to deform the edge of the blade.
-
Ever since i stopped being a single bachelor, I stopped opening cans for dinner. She knows how to cook, and I can't get away with those super simple eating habits from my single days so I tend to cook more often too. But since MTs are meant for both single and married folks, here's my 2 cents:
- Can openers can easily be substituted by using the flat screwdrivers already on the MT. And a cork screw? Trying to make an MT "good" at a lot of things sometimes gets in the way of making a "great" MT.
- The small flat blade screwdriver (the small rounded nub on the tip of the can opener) really puts the emphasis on the can opener function rather than the screwdriver application which seems like a poor choice of design. If we're going for a small flat blade, make it right in the first place and give it a longer reach.
- If I go camping, I make sure I get a pull-tab can. SO much easier to get all the contents out, especially the chunks of meat.
- Same basic reasoning above goes for getting rid of the bottle opener. Most bottled drinks now come with a manual screw off lid. These features on an MT are getting obsolete while other functions that should be there aren't.
-
I like the can opener, always have.
First, it has history within the multi-world. The idea, borrowed from the SAK and appearing on the first PST has been a feature of almost every full-size multitool since then. It hearkens back to the early days of multitooldom when the tools were aimed at outdoorsman and campers. Also, keep in mind that us poor people can't necessarily afford pull-top cans so it's still useful for us in a wide range of applications.
That and most modern can openers are useful for slightly more than opening cans.
The Leatherman model has a wire stripper ground into the tang and doubles as a (poor) bottle opener and awl in certain instances.
SOG and Victorinox add a small flathead to their openers.
For those who want it replaced with something else, what would you like to see? It's not too terribly hard to mod it into an awl if the tool doesn't have one of those but I can't think of much that would be potentially as useful to replace it.
- Can openers can easily be substituted by using the flat screwdrivers already on the MT.
Does that really work? I can't imagine it being anything but a messy pain in the butt.
-
@Spoonrobot said:
I like the can opener, always have.First, it has history within the multi-world. The idea, borrowed from the SAK and appearing on the first PST has been a feature of almost every full-size multitool since then. It hearkens back to the early days of multitooldom when the tools were aimed at outdoorsman and campers.
I've carried an original LM PST along on outdoor trips for quite a few years. So far as I can remember, it's never been used to open a can while outdoors. Opened a few cans at home right after I got it, just to check out its functionality.
Even on a multitool used exclusively outdoors, I'd rather have any other implement in that slot. I certainly see no need for canopeners or bottleopeners on multis not purchased for outdoor use.
@Spoonrobot said:
For those who want it replaced with something else, what would you like to see? It's not too terribly hard to mod it into an awl if the tool doesn't have one of those but I can't think of much that would be potentially as useful to replace it.I'd prefer nearly anything to a canopener.
Any implement that might see some use - a small Phillips or slothead screwdriver for example. An awl on those multis lacking an awl. Anything.
.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login