5/32 hard wire cut test
-
That's a very useful test, and the result is quite interesting. It seems like the size of the plier/handle may not be the determining factor of the cutting capability. Based by effort:
LM ST300(easiest) > LM Charge > LM Rebar > Gerber MP600 ~ Vic Spirit > Crunch
I read somewhere that the joint of Vic swisstool pliers are designed to be off-center, so it could apply more force when used for twisting. I wonder will that undermine its cutting ability.

It's a very interesting test, I think I may have all LM and Vic products, and some Gerber and SOG. As soon as I have more from Gerber and SOG, I will probably try to follow suit and make a video sometime for it.

-
Good to see what they are capable of. Were cutters affected in any way? Any dents or marks of overdoing them?
-
Very interesting Joel. Thanks for taking the time to do it

-
I'd be curious to see how other tools coped with the exact same wire, maybe a SOG powerlock ? if you don't have one, could you post a small piece of wire to another member ? (one with some camera skills and a good selection of tools ;) )
thanks for what you've done so far though
I found it great information 
-
nice comparison. as a side note does the BO on the Spirit help with it's slipperiness?
-
@JAfromMn said:
First I tried my ST300. It cut through it without much effort and without having to use both hands . . . Next I tried my Rebar it wouldn't cut it with one hand but did when I squeezed very hard with two handsThis comports with something you noted in your previous ST300 and Rebar usage. The cutters on the ST300 and Rebar are identical, so that's not where the difference in performance is found. The ST300 cuts better because you get more leverage with the longer handles. That would also translate to more torque on nuts, bolts, etc., which your own experience demonstrated. So in this case, bigger really is better, at least as it relates to the application of force.
-
Great test Joel. This has me re-thinking the Rebar in favor of the Wave or Charge. The cutters may be there, but if there's no leverage what's the point ???
-
The Charge cut threw it.
That's us mobile.
-
I wonder how the SOG Powerlock would do with its compound plier head. I suspect that it would do pretty well.
-
@sawman said:
Great test Joel. This has me re-thinking the Rebar in favor of the Wave or Charge. The cutters may be there, but if there's no leverage what's the point ???Here is a quote of mine from way back, talking about the Original Surge vs ST300.
The same applies to the Charge vs Rebar. Hopefully you can understand what I mean.@zoidberg said:
IMO, re the cutters on the different plier heads after using the Surge for months and the ST3 for weeks. Both can cut a nail in half, the ST3 will need more hand power to shear/tear through and the Surge will cut through with ease/less effort. Plier heads were tested on both sets of handles with the same results. I found that the Surge handles are more comfy and the ruler markings felt good.I tend to carry both tools. If the job looks tool abusive I'll use the ST3 head as I can replace the cutters, otherwise I go with the Surge head for less stress on my hands.
-
@powernoodle said:
I wonder how the SOG Powerlock would do with its compound plier head. I suspect that it would do pretty well.I'm sure it would. However just because you can apply more pressure doesn't mean the cutters can handle it.
-
@powernoodle said:
I wonder how the SOG Powerlock would do with its compound plier head. I suspect that it would do pretty well.It does very well. It also loves barbwire.
That's us mobile.
-
Great comparison, and good to know!

-
@Taxi Dad said:
I'd be curious to see how other tools coped with the exact same wire, maybe a SOG powerlock ? if you don't have one, could you post a small piece of wire to another member ? (one with some camera skills and a good selection of tools ;) )
thanks for what you've done so far though
I found it great information 
If someone wants some for testing il send them some as long as there in the usa.
-
@ducttapetech said:
The Charge cut threw it.That's us mobile.
Its Tim leatherman's tool of choice I had a feeling it would do good.
-
@Taxi Dad said:
I'd be curious to see how other tools coped with the exact same wire, maybe a SOG powerlock ? if you don't have one, could you post a small piece of wire to another member ? (one with some camera skills and a good selection of tools ;) )
thanks for what you've done so far though
I found it great information 
If someone wants some for testing il send them some as long as there in the usa.
Ill take a tad. Ill use the Powerlock, Surge and OHT on it.
That's us mobile.
-
@Taxi Dad said:
I'd be curious to see how other tools coped with the exact same wire, maybe a SOG powerlock ? if you don't have one, could you post a small piece of wire to another member ? (one with some camera skills and a good selection of tools ;) )
thanks for what you've done so far though
I found it great information 
If someone wants some for testing il send them some as long as there in the usa.
Ill take a tad. Ill use the Powerlock, Surge and OHT on it.
That's us mobile.
Sent you a pm
-
@Taxi Dad said:
I'd be curious to see how other tools coped with the exact same wire, maybe a SOG powerlock ? if you don't have one, could you post a small piece of wire to another member ? (one with some camera skills and a good selection of tools ;) )
thanks for what you've done so far though
I found it great information 
If someone wants some for testing il send them some as long as there in the usa.
Ill take a tad. Ill use the Powerlock, Surge and OHT on it.
That's us mobile.
Original Surge, Surge or both?

-
New Surge.
That's us mobile.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
