Interesting link- flaw in MUT pliers?
-
Found it, 0213 Wave broken in the same place as the MUT. Pics here and here.
Joking aside, that flaw seems to be an Achille's heel of the LM tools that belong to the modern scales design - Wave, Surge and MUT all fall into that category.
If you inspect the handles around the pliers pivot area you will notice how thin and small the area that supports the pliers when fully closed and pressure applied to them, is. It's to do with the side cutouts that make the construct a little less robust compared to handles with solid design like ST300, Rebar etc.
While the plier heads are all robust and thick and designed to sustain a reasonably large pressure, the handle area which supports them, isn't.
IMO, those scale cutouts should be much smaller and build a lot more solid. At the moment, that's not the case. MUT scales are the worst in that respect.
Could you please take some pics showing the difference between the three you mentioned for us MUTless peeps.
-
This is interesting...as I remember posting about my MUT and how tightening the torx screws just really wasn't helping. Finally, it was sent into LM and they of course replaced it. So, now I understand what [more than likely] was wrong with it.
Hmmmm... :D...yes and I dove in for all three versions too. Gee, hope it was a 'lucky' series of investments. All three do see use and I haven't had a real problem. However, I have noticed some looseness that I've been trying to avoid thinking about.
Yeah, well - at least I know what's probably wrong now or will be in the near future. Thanx. :P I'll absolutely be requesting that a 'Quality Mgr.' check out any replacement[s].
-
Not good at all!
[quote author=babola link=topic=54027.msg934473#msg934473 date=1408249953]
[quote author=zoidberg link=topic=54027.msg934452#msg934452 date=1408241328]
Didn't someone from here break a Wave
there?Would this be your shot at poetry, mate? :D
Nar, the only poetry I write is about def in the shower.
And that's worse again

Oi watch it.

[/quote]I don't know which would be worse,watching it,or hearing the poetry :ahhh
[/quote]Maybe Zoidberg is secretly a Vogon?

:ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
-
Not good at all!
[quote author=zoidberg link=topic=54027.msg934486#msg934486 date=1408256737]
[quote author=babola link=topic=54027.msg934473#msg934473 date=1408249953]
[quote author=zoidberg link=topic=54027.msg934452#msg934452 date=1408241328]
Didn't someone from here break a Wave
there?Would this be your shot at poetry, mate? :D
Nar, the only poetry I write is about def in the shower.
And that's worse again

Oi watch it.

[/quote]I don't know which would be worse,watching it,or hearing the poetry :ahhh
[/quote]Maybe Zoidberg is secretly a Vogon?

:ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
[/quote]That was never a secret.

-
[quote author=kirk13 link=topic=54027.msg934540#msg934540 date=1408279565]
Not good at all![quote author=zoidberg link=topic=54027.msg934486#msg934486 date=1408256737]
[quote author=babola link=topic=54027.msg934473#msg934473 date=1408249953]
[quote author=zoidberg link=topic=54027.msg934452#msg934452 date=1408241328]
Didn't someone from here break a Wave
there?Would this be your shot at poetry, mate? :D
Nar, the only poetry I write is about def in the shower.
And that's worse again

Oi watch it.

[/quote]I don't know which would be worse,watching it,or hearing the poetry :ahhh
[/quote]Maybe Zoidberg is secretly a Vogon?

:ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
[/quote]That was never a secret.

[/quote]Ah, of course, I was confused for a sec, there...

Hold on to your towels, ladies and gentlemen, here we go!
-
Found it, 0213 Wave broken in the same place as the MUT. Pics here and here.
Joking aside, that flaw seems to be an Achille's heel of the LM tools that belong to the modern scales design - Wave, Surge and MUT all fall into that category.
If you inspect the handles around the pliers pivot area you will notice how thin and small the area that supports the pliers when fully closed and pressure applied to them, is. It's to do with the side cutouts that make the construct a little less robust compared to handles with solid design like ST300, Rebar etc.
While the plier heads are all robust and thick and designed to sustain a reasonably large pressure, the handle area which supports them, isn't.
IMO, those scale cutouts should be much smaller and build a lot more solid. At the moment, that's not the case. MUT scales are the worst in that respect.
Could you please take some pics showing the difference between the three you mentioned for us MUTless peeps.
Mate this will have to wait until the weekend, not at home before than...sorry.
Surge and Wave you own already I believe so can take a peek 'under the hood' yourself. As for the MUT, have you seen the second photo in this link: http://blogs.militarytimes.com/gearscout/2014/07/31/frame-cracks-cause-leatherman-mut-pliers-to-fail/
That's what I'm referring to as the weak link. IMO, this part should be made a little more robust as it's the part which is under quite a lot of stress for those jobs exerting lot of force while squeezing the handles.
-
double post, sorry
-
Found it, 0213 Wave broken in the same place as the MUT. Pics here and here.
Joking aside, that flaw seems to be an Achille's heel of the LM tools that belong to the modern scales design - Wave, Surge and MUT all fall into that category.
If you inspect the handles around the pliers pivot area you will notice how thin and small the area that supports the pliers when fully closed and pressure applied to them, is. It's to do with the side cutouts that make the construct a little less robust compared to handles with solid design like ST300, Rebar etc.
While the plier heads are all robust and thick and designed to sustain a reasonably large pressure, the handle area which supports them, isn't.
IMO, those scale cutouts should be much smaller and build a lot more solid. At the moment, that's not the case. MUT scales are the worst in that respect.
Could you please take some pics showing the difference between the three you mentioned for us MUTless peeps.
Mate this will have to wait until the weekend, not at home before than...sorry.
Surge and Wave you own already I believe so can take a peek 'under the hood' yourself. As for the MUT, have you seen the second photo in this link: http://blogs.militarytimes.com/gearscout/2014/07/31/frame-cracks-cause-leatherman-mut-pliers-to-fail/
That's what I'm referring to as the weak link. IMO, this part should be made a little more robust as it's the part which is under quite a lot of stress for those jobs exerting lot of force while squeezing the handles.
Trust me, it isn't weak. IMO, most of the force goes straight down the handle. A small amount pushes back inwards. However it can't go that way as it is wrapped around the plier head. Years ago I sanded too much off the plier cam trying to make it easier to open and close. Even with a hammer I had trouble getting that weak bit to bend in to correct my mistake. I really don't see anyone being able to apply enough force to do damage without it being considered abuse. With the MUT, I think if there was a factory issue or fracture there then the pressure from the plier cam pushing outwards when being opened would be enough to finish the break. I have seen plenty of broken plier jaws but very few broken handles.
-
Time will tell brother. I should be fine though as I hardly use my MT pliers for jobs that would cause me to squeeze the handles so vigorously and forcefully to cause that sort of damage. I like my multi tools far too much to do that to them haha...
-
Didn't someone from here break a Wave
there?I broke a Wave like that, but I never posted about it on here.
You remember its date stamp?
Unfortunately not, but I think it was the same year as when I got it, so probably early 2013.
That puts around the same batch as the other broken Wave. Interesting.
-
[quote author=zoidberg link=topic=54027.msg934452#msg934452 date=1408241328]
Didn't someone from here break a Wave
there?I broke a Wave like that, but I never posted about it on here.
You remember its date stamp?
Unfortunately not, but I think it was the same year as when I got it, so probably early 2013.
That puts around the same batch as the other broken Wave. Interesting.
[/quote]When the replacement came, the lock release looked a bit different, but the cutout looked bigger, which seems counter productive. The new one (which has since been modded) has no date code.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login