What exactly is a "Gentleman's Folder"?
-
@WildJ3 said:
I've seen this term thrown around a lot in reading various boards. The definition of it seems kind of broad.What exactly constitutes a knife as a "gentleman's folder" in your opinion? Is it the size, function or the looks?
What would be some examples in your opinion of a "gentleman's folder"?
I consider a gentleman's folder to be one that is at home in the suit (or even tuxedo) pocket of an immaculately dressed fellow, and also (with regard to looks) appears natural when he uses it because the knife exudes the same level of quality and refinement as the rest of the owner's attire and accessories.
With regard to size, since suit pockets aren't usually designed for particularly heavy, large, or bulky items, this generally means a smaller knife, usually 3" or less closed.
With regard to function, the knife is generally designed/destined for the light duty sorts of tasks that might be expected to be encountered while wearing the above-referenced attire, such as opening mail, personal grooming, trimming a stray thread, etc.
Some examples of knives that I consider gentleman's folders are the Case small stockman or peanut in MOP; Victorinox cigar cutter, or any of the silver classics; and (though it is a bit on the large side, IMO) the A.G. Russell Spire.
-
The toothpick originated from European knives like the laquiole, some central European traditionals and other traditional styles. Most knives in the US were imported from Europe during the first decades of the US existence and the discovery of the continent.
Being thin and pointy the large toothpick or possibly laquiole at the time, was found to be good for discreet carry and stabbing/ cutting. I remember that with the insertion of a matchstick (or maybe a wooden toothpick) inside the blade was kept high enabling quick one hand opening. Maybe this was achieved otherwise too. The name toothpick comes from the shape (or the use of wooden toothpicks in the knife [emoji2] ). -
Have to split the message because of tapatalk
These stabbings and whether you can stab with a slip joint may have been exaggerated. I posted a picture of the various related knives some time ago but with tapatalk it is hard to find. BF has more history.
-
@WildJ3 said:
What exactly constitutes a . . . "gentleman's folder" . . . ?It is early Spring, and you are at a social gathering on the veranda of a Victorian mansion situated on 700 acres just outside of Charleston, South Carolina. A cool spring breeze is bringing the smell of ribs from the grill. An intoxicating aroma of charcoal and sizzling meat.
The estate's owner, a very attractive young widow who recently inherited a shipping fortune of almost $800M, is clearly captivated by your charm and good humor. She approaches, accompanied by her twin sister who has returned just this morning from boarding school in Switzerland. After a shy giggle and a bit of conversation, the young widow flings her long, brown hair away from her face and asks if you might slice a lime for her Gin and Tonic. As she does so, you sense the slightest whiff of her scent, which is quickly replaced by that of the grill. You find yourself suddenly hungry, though for what you know not.
You:
a) remove your Spyderco Camo Military with black blade from your pocket, and it snaps open with a satisfying clunk. The young widow recoils in fear and drops her Gin and Tonic. Her security personnel wrestle you to the ground and remove you from the estate; or,
b) you casually remove a small, finely crafted folder hand-made of exquisite and costly materials. You expertly slice the lime with its razor edge, and place a slice in the widow's drink. As you do so, your hand casually touches hers, causing her to blush. But the blush is accompanied by an unblinking stare into your own eyes, and you see her pupils dilate ever so slightly. After an embarrassed pause, she asks if you might accompany her and her sister on a private walking tour of the riding stables. You accept, and begin your stroll as the sun begins to set behind the adjacent hills.
If you chose answer b), you were carrying a gentleman's folder.
Why was i reading this in a old southern accent :D well said mr noodles

-
Maybe a Emerson with "Wave" opener?
-
Powernoodle , you are my hero!
-
@Gareth said:
Anyone else suspect Powernoodle reads, or perhaps even writes, for Mills and Boon?
Close enough. Meet his boss:

:D :D
-
I use a SAK Secretary as my choice. Very smooth, subtle knife. Two blades, one for cutting your food the other for opening letters, cutting some thread. Very small, disappears in your pocket.
-
@pfrsantos said:
I use a SAK Secretary as my choice. Very smooth, subtle knife. Two blades, one for cutting your food the other for opening letters, cutting some thread. Very small, disappears in your pocket.I have to say that I don't think most SAKs fall into the "Gentleman's" category, but I think this one passes.
This is totally subjective though. :D -
@Gareth said:
I have to say that I don't think most SAKs fall into the "Gentleman's" category, but I think this one passes.
This is totally subjective though. :DThen what about this one?

I think it would be my pick as number one of the two or three gentlemanly SAKs that I have. The other two are both 74mm Executive based.
-
I'd say that's too "busy" to be a gentleman's knife. In my view, a gentleman doesn't do manual labour. But that's me and like Gareth said, it's a matter of opinion.

-
I see a gentleman's folder as a small non-locking knife with two or three small blades. I think they should also be a little fancy looking.
I'd consider my Buck 303 to be one.
-
@pfrsantos said:
I'd say that's too "busy" to be a gentleman's knife. In my view,** a gentleman doesn't do manual labour.** But that's me and like Gareth said, it's a matter of opinion.

That's pretty much it. :D
Don't get me wrong, I think that's a beautiful SAK, but it's not what I think of as a Gentleman's folder.
-
One filter I have for what might be a gentleman's knife is this:
When you take the knife out and use it, do (all kinds of) people want to get closer to it or away from it?
Think about the most knife averse person. How would they react to the knife? If they go "Hum, looks nice..." THAT is a gentleman's folder!
:D :D -
Something like these, as described in my 1st post in the thread:


had to take a couple of quick pictures
(think of the "look" rather than who made it) -
I'm a Gentelman , so anything I carry is a Gents knife . I've seen the term applied to small , ornate "Tacticals " .
Chris
-
I love Powernoodle's answer, but I think it needs a little fleshing out.
A gentleman's knife is dressy but not showy. This could be something like the goldplated tools from Texas Toolcrafters, but they are a little closer to bling. Silver is a little more understated. A Vic Climber or Compact could qualify if you put on new scales, a faux ivory or an exotic hardwood or something like the engraved copper scaled Pioneer posted in custom SAKs by rickinFL. Or even a semi-precious or decorative stone, like malicite (particularly if you have copper or brass and black mosaic work). File work also goes a long way. It's a part of a gentleman's jewelry as much as a fine watch and walking cane.
Things I wouldn't expect is a one handed blade, or even most locking mechanisms. This is the realm of the slipjoint. I make an exception for the ring lock because it is "exotic", particularly if we have something like an engraved ring of copper or stainless with inlay to make the art stand out. I wouldn't want too many layers on a SAK, or anything overly long. Sidhartha has done some amazing 111mm SAKs with file work and really sexy scales, but liner locks and 4" long makes them borderline despite their beauty. Not sure how many multitools could be made to serve as gentleman's knives.
And it does not need to be custom. Case has a lot of lines that qualify. Turquoise and silver works if it matches the rest of your ensemble, and Case has done that. Yes, a gentleman's knife should not clash with his suit.
Sadly, it is hard to give a specific definition. All of these rules could be broken- dressed up properly, a long, slim fruit knife could work. In theory, even a small fixed blade could work, but not these days, it's just too likely to freak out the finer people. But you'll know one when you see one.
-
Been fawning over this for ages, but too far out for my budget:
Laguiole en Aubrac, 12c27 stainless, scales in mammoth ivory and ebony...
-
For me this is it

Or this

-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


