Gerber Flik vs. Leatherman OHT
-
Good comparison Kyle

If I had to choose between the two it would definitely be the OHT.
-
@Lichtbote said:
Thanks for your work.
In general your result is what i expected to read, my tendency is just more straight to the OHT, due to my way of use.
After the MP 600 experience I thought about to try it again, next time with a Flik (i like it´s look) - but after reading this review i assume i can skip that.
Yeah, if you're more of a heavy duty user, the OHT is probably the way to go. I can only base this on the feel of the tools though, and not actual heavy use, so I don't want people to take that as a knock on the Flik's capability. For all I know, it is plenty capable of some heavy duty use, but the OHT seems more made for it, at least with the pliers.
-
@babola said:
BTW, just found this...</topic/4910 :(Hope it's an isolated incident and not matter of course.
I just read through a bunch of this. I had a similar concern when I was first fiddling around with the Flik as it seemed like it would be easy to just squeeze and crush the mechanisms, or at least based upon what I could see once the handles deploy that pawls. I've squeezed mine pretty hard and felt nothing that made me worry I was about to break it. I think it may have been the newness of the model at that point. I think this happens with other manufacturers as well at times. The Flik has since been out for a few years now, so I figure at this point, all bugs have been discovered and rectified. Thanks for that link though, as it was an interesting read

-
Nice job mate

It kind of made me want to try the Flik again ... right up until the point where you said the pawls don't always lock out, which was the main deal breaker for me last time :-\ If they made the pawl out of one piece rather than two pieces stacked together (which then flare out), it would be a much more reliable design. If they then scrificed a teeny bit of plier size so they could increas the small tools a little, it would be even better still.
I've handled the OHT, and can see why some folks might like it, but to me it's just way too big for what it offers. I'd say it's better made than the Flik, but I can't say I feel either of them are well designed. A little extra thought on both tools would have made a lot of difference for the common user .... but then again, the OHT isn't really marketted/intended for the common user. If the Flik was tweaked as above, I'd try it again, wheras the OHT steers too far away from what I want in a tool
-
@50ft-trad said:
Nice job mate
It kind of made me want to try the Flik again ... right up until the point where you said the pawls don't always lock out, which was the main deal breaker for me last time :-\ If they made the pawl out of one piece rather than two pieces stacked together (which then flare out), it would be a much more reliable design. If they then scrificed a teeny bit of plier size so they could increas the small tools a little, it would be even better still.
I've handled the OHT, and can see why some folks might like it, but to me it's just way too big for what it offers. I'd say it's better made than the Flik, but I can't say I feel either of them are well designed. A little extra thought on both tools would have made a lot of difference for the common user .... but then again, the OHT isn't really marketted/intended for the common user. If the Flik was tweaked as above, I'd try it again, wheras the OHT steers too far away from what I want in a tool
Thanks Al - your recent pic filled comparisons are part of what inspired this

Yes, that mechanism could be an issue I suppose, but I don't mind it as I think it's sometimes caused by how I open the handles. Most times it works fine, but if I don't quite do it all the way, it doesn't always work. Still, it's not a desirable thing, but I'm just more willing to let it slide, much like the driver accessibility.
You sort of summed up the OHT for me, just in a way that makes more sense rather than my rambling
I'm a common user, maybe even less than that in a sense, and the OHT is not really for me in that way. Also, as you said, the MT as a whole is bulky, but doesn't offer much in tool size, other than the pliers. I just really like the pliers and the fun of the tool as a whole. Is it the most practical option for me? Not at all, but I don't really operate on that line of thinking when it comes to my MTs ;) If I went that way, I'd probably be just fine with a Sideclip or PST for the most part, or even just a Juice S2 or KF4. But that's just not as fun for me >:D -
Nice write up
. I'll eventually get a OHT but I don't see it being a go to tool for me. The Flik sure is pleasing to the eye. -
Funny to read how POV can vary. :D
The OHT is my standard tool when i don´t plan to work on anything (on the other days i carry the Surge), and if it would be smaller i probably would use it noticeable less.

My hands are not overly big, but i want a tool i can hold and handle, no small gadget-toy to fiddle around. First days they felt bulky, but Surge and OHT are barely noticeable since after a few days of carrying them horizontally on my belt.Atm. i have a bigger serrated blade from TexasToolCrafters on it´s way - that´s my most used tool (followed or on par with the pliers), so i will upgrade that. The other toolload is OK for me, they do the job when needed.
Hmm, except one thing - i next to never use a woodsaw, but if i do, i want it a little bigger, too. That will be upgraded as soon as a fellow forum member finds time to go further with selling me a BO saw he has. -
@Lichtbote said:
Funny to read how POV can vary. :DThe OHT is my standard tool when i don´t plan to work on anything (on the other days i carry the Surge), and if it would be smaller i probably would use it noticeable less.

My hands are not overly big, but i want a tool i can hold and handle, no small gadget-toy to fiddle around. First days they felt bulky, but Surge and OHT are barely noticeable since after a few days of carrying them horizontally on my belt.Atm. i have a bigger serrated blade from TexasToolCrafters on it´s way - that´s my most used tool (followed or on par with the pliers), so i will upgrade that. The other toolload is OK for me, they do the job when needed.
Hmm, except one thing - i next to never use a woodsaw, but if i do, i want it a little bigger, too. That will be upgraded as soon as a fellow forum member finds time to go further with selling me a BO saw he has.Yes, it is interesting, and part of what makes these comparisons fun
I feel the same way in that I want to feel confident that the MT I'm carrying can handle harder use should it become necessary. That's an impression I get from the OHT more than the Flik. As I've said though, that's not necessarily a knock on the Flik's capabilities as I have nothing on which to base it, other than the feel of the tool. The main issue there for me is the more rattly pliers in comparison to the more solid feeling ones on the OHT.So when you say you're getting a bigger serrated blade, are you removing the small flathead to allow room?
-
@ducttapetech said:
You need a Flik too.Nate
Tell me about it ! I also have to get a Surge. Hate this site :)
Sak's rule !
-
You need a Flik too.
Nate
Tell me about it ! I also have to get a Surge. Hate this site :)
Sak's rule !
For some reason I thought you already had a Surge, but I don't know why I thought that

-
Monrogue, a great writeup and good read! Thanks for doing that.
I do own both of these tools, although I do use them regularly enough to comment on long term use. I tried using OHT for a short while, but can never get use to the small tools with a big frame(I have mid sized hand). I can see if someone needs a pliers in emergency situation, maybe it's a great tool. Otherwise, I am still more attached to my Wave/Charge as usual.
Flik is a little different for me, mostly it is so easy and fun to play with the pliers. However, I don't like how inconsistent the tools are being opened, and it could be something to do with QC. Also the middle tools are a little too small for my taste, I think even the 91mm SAK offers better or more usable tool than Flik.
-
You need a Flik too.
Nate
Tell me about it ! I also have to get a Surge. Hate this site :)
Sak's rule !
For some reason I thought you already had a Surge, but I don't know why I thought that

you both need a Surge.

Again Kyle, great write up. The Flik is one of my Top 3 plierbased multitools.
Nate
-
@comis said:
Monrogue, a great writeup and good read! Thanks for doing that.I do own both of these tools, although I do use them regularly enough to comment on long term use. I tried using OHT for a short while, but can never get use to the small tools with a big frame(I have mid sized hand). I can see if someone needs a pliers in emergency situation, maybe it's a great tool. Otherwise, I am still more attached to my Wave/Charge as usual.
Flik is a little different for me, mostly it is so easy and fun to play with the pliers. However, I don't like how inconsistent the tools are being opened, and it could be something to do with QC. Also the middle tools are a little too small for my taste, I think even the 91mm SAK offers better or more usable tool than Flik.
Yeah, I agree about the smaller tools on such a large frame. The Flik has this issue with the drivers, but the frame isn't quite so bulky. I also agree about the SAK drivers. Since my Rogueneer has a phillips and the various flatheads, the Flik's drivers aren't much of an issue really. And the pliers are fun to play with indeed ;)
-
You need a Flik too.
Nate
Tell me about it ! I also have to get a Surge. Hate this site :)
Sak's rule !
For some reason I thought you already had a Surge, but I don't know why I thought that

you both need a Surge.

Again Kyle, great write up. The Flik is one of my Top 3 plierbased multitools.
Nate
Thanks Nate, and sorry, the Surge is one I know I'd not get along with due to the size and especially weight of it. Tool loadout is great though. That thing won't work in a pocket, although with a pocket clip...
NO, mustn't give in to the enabling mindset :ahhh -
NO, mustn't give in to the enabling mindset :ahhh
No MT afficionado or collector should be without one. What are you waiting for?

Now don't you start too
I think the Surge would just be far too big for my smallish hands. Now if someone could post a pic of a OHT and Surge side by side for reference... -
@Lichtbote said:
Atm. i have a bigger serrated blade from TexasToolCrafters on it´s wayNice one.

Have any more info on it? Is this something the make on a side and don't advertise?
I would have though the serrated blade on OHT cannot be much bigger/longer as it would interfere with the flat blade screwdriver bit at the top.
-
NO, mustn't give in to the enabling mindset :ahhh
No MT afficionado or collector should be without one. What are you waiting for?

Now don't you start too
I think the Surge would just be far too big for my smallish hands. Now if someone could post a pic of a OHT and Surge side by side for reference...I'd love to post a comparo pic but I'm off to work now. BTW, they are of comparable size so you should be fine with it if you're OK with the OHT.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
;)