Any interest in a minimalist SAK challenge?
-
I've seen on other forums where there have been 30 day challenges to use a minimalist knife, like a Case Peanut, for 30 days exclusively. I was wondering if anyone would be up for trying a similar experiment with a minimalist SAK?
My thought is that everyone could reply if interested, and also suggest some minimalist SAKs. Then I could do a poll on the SAKs suggested and whatever one is picked, give about a week for everyone to procure one. Then commence the 30 day challenge.
The goal would be to try and use that SAK exclusively for that time period. No other SAK, no multi-tool and no single blade knife. Now, I realize that isn't always practical for everyone, and the goal is for this to be fun, not all rules.
The trick may be how to define minimalist. My initial thought was no more than a 2-layer SAK, and no larger than a 93mm. This is completely arbitrary, of course, so feel free to offer suggestions there as well.
What say you?
-
I think it would be entertaining, and I would take part. But I currently have a limited selection of SAKs and even more limited funds unfortunately.
-
I am game. But I only have a few saks. But if one of mine fall into the Sak challenge, I would be game.
Nate
-
Can you guys list which ones you have. Maybe we can make it work somehow. I imagine this may be a common problem.
-
What if every participant locks in which they're going to use right before it starts?
-

I will not be taking part in this madness.
-
I think the spartan (or maybe tinker) would be a good minimalist SAK. Classic set of tools and 2 layers.

-
@gustophersmob said:
What say you?Good idea. I'm interested. But for a guy who switches his EDC stuff around constantly, a 30-day challenge seems like an eternity. I'll be watching, and maybe participating.
-
@Higgins617 said:
What if every participant locks in which they're going to use right before it starts?Maybe that's a better idea

Though, no excuse to buy a new SAK
I'm torn ;) -
I'm in most likely. I really want to use my new soldier for this
-
No!
:D -
I like this idea.
But Instead of thinking of a minimalist I'd like to see the most common sak used. I think it would get alot more folks involved.
minimalist rant
I'd much rather thrive with a few extra things than survive using the bare minimum I need to get by.
Rant concluded :D
-
I'd be up for the fun if it's a SAK I already own. Not up for buying a knife I wouldn't otherwise choose to own. I would still be carrying a pliers based tool no doubt as I use them regularly, but would use the SAK exclusively so far as possible .... and I'd be honest when I had to cheat :D
Options for me (based on 2 layer knives I already own) would be:
Pioneer/Cadet
Compact/Timekeeper/84mm Golfer
Spartan/Weekender/Tourist
Vic Sportsman/Wenger Commander
D of E / MFV.... and possibly a couple of non-Swiss knives too :D
EDIT:
My personal favourite of the above bunch would probably be my Tourist. It was my first SAK, and carried it on it's own for a lot more than 30 days before I started carrying plier based tools regularly :) As an extra incentive for me to use my SAK exclusively, I'd pair it with a Juice CS4 .... which many will know I will avoid using unless absolutely necessary :D -
@JAfromMn said:
I like this idea.But Instead of thinking of a minimalist I'd like to see the most common sak used. I think it would get alot more folks involved.
minimalist rant
I'd much rather thrive with a few extra things than survive using the bare minimum I need to get by.
Rant concluded :D
What's the most common SAK? I think its the classic, but I doubt I could get by with just that!
-
@50ft-trad said:
I'd be up for the fun if it's a SAK I already own. Not up for buying a knife I wouldn't otherwise choose to own. I would still be carrying a pliers based tool no doubt as I use them regularly, but would use the SAK exclusively so far as possible .... and I'd be honest when I had to cheat :DOptions for me (based on 2 layer knives I already own) would be:
Pioneer/Cadet
Compact/Timekeeper/84mm Golfer
Spartan/Weekender/Tourist
Vic Sportsman/Wenger Commander
D of E / MFV.... and possibly a couple of non-Swiss knives too :D
EDIT:
My personal favourite of the above bunch would probably be my Tourist. It was my first SAK, and carried it on it's own for a lot more than 30 days before I started carrying plier based tools regularly :) As an extra incentive for me to use my SAK exclusively, I'd pair it with a Juice CS4 .... which many will know I will avoid using unless absolutely necessary :D
for you that's quite the incentive :D -
@50ft-trad said:
I'd be up for the fun if it's a SAK I already own. Not up for buying a knife I wouldn't otherwise choose to own. I would still be carrying a pliers based tool no doubt as I use them regularly, but would use the SAK exclusively so far as possible .... and I'd be honest when I had to cheat :DOptions for me (based on 2 layer knives I already own) would be:
Pioneer/Cadet
Compact/Timekeeper/84mm Golfer
Spartan/Weekender/Tourist
Vic Sportsman/Wenger Commander
D of E / MFV.... and possibly a couple of non-Swiss knives too :D
EDIT:
My personal favourite of the above bunch would probably be my Tourist. It was my first SAK, and carried it on it's own for a lot more than 30 days before I started carrying plier based tools regularly :) As an extra incentive for me to use my SAK exclusively, I'd pair it with a Juice CS4 .... which many will know I will avoid using unless absolutely necessary :DHa, I like the CS4 idea :D
-
I like this idea.
But Instead of thinking of a minimalist I'd like to see the most common sak used. I think it would get alot more folks involved.
minimalist rant
I'd much rather thrive with a few extra things than survive using the bare minimum I need to get by.
Rant concluded :D
What's the most common SAK? I think its the classic, but I doubt I could get by with just that!
It would have to be a 91mm
Tinker, super tinker , old soldier etc
-
Since my EDC is a pioneer, I wonder what would be a stretch for me. Maybe a Bantam

-
Well, going with Higgins idea, what if we say we'll start the challenge on October 1st using the minimalist SAK of your choice.
Let us know the choice, and the goal is to try and use it exclusively. Feel free to provide updates in this thread, whether good or bad. Pics always encouraged.
Sound ok?
Now, off to pick my SAK (:ahhh)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login