Any interest in a minimalist SAK challenge?
-
I rest my case, here.
I want to be without my trusty Swisschamp ..... it has a 'HOOK' >:D -
Ok, I'm going to be brave and accept this challenge
I just ordered a black Vic Compact, which will be minimalist compared to my Rogueneer for sure. I think for the most part I'll get by fine with it, but I'm rather attached to my Rogueneer, and will surely miss carrying it. As I said earlier, I'll still carry a multi for the pliers more than anything, but will only use it if absolutely necessary, and will honestly report if I do so. I should have it between Friday and early next week, so I'll be a few days late to start the challenge, but will update when I have it. -
I'm going to try to make it with just the Esquire that Aloha so kindly gifted me, however I will need to keep pliers on stand-by for the jobs where that is simply a requirement.

What's the idea? Do we report back here with daily updates? On the first everyone should post in a row which SAK they'll be using so there's an uninterrupted list.
-
Hardly a challenge if people are going to carry backup stuff.

-
@zoidberg said:
Hardly a challenge if people are going to carry backup stuff.
:P ;)
Honestly, it will be a challenge for me regardless of the MT factor. I wouldn't be using any SAK for pliers, so it won't factor in much at all. I rely on my Rogueneer for pretty much anything I encounter with the exception of the pliers obviously. I will be attempting to rely on the Compact for all other tasks, and it's the only minimalist SAK with scissors, which is something I've gotta have, especially since my wife asks to use scissors rather regularly... -
Hardly a challenge if people are going to carry backup stuff.

:P ;)
Honestly, it will be a challenge for me regardless of the MT factor. I wouldn't be using any SAK for pliers, so it won't factor in much at all. I rely on my Rogueneer for pretty much anything I encounter with the exception of the pliers obviously. I will be attempting to rely on the Compact for all other tasks, and it's the only minimalist SAK with scissors, which is something I've gotta have, especially since my wife asks to use scissors rather regularly...Excuse alert. :ahhh I'm sure she can look after herself. But you, not so much.

-
Hardly a challenge if people are going to carry backup stuff.

:P ;)
Honestly, it will be a challenge for me regardless of the MT factor. I wouldn't be using any SAK for pliers, so it won't factor in much at all. I rely on my Rogueneer for pretty much anything I encounter with the exception of the pliers obviously. I will be attempting to rely on the Compact for all other tasks, and it's the only minimalist SAK with scissors, which is something I've gotta have, especially since my wife asks to use scissors rather regularly...Excuse alert. :ahhh I'm sure she can look after herself. But you, not so much.

You may be right there
She probably could handle it herself, but she's come to expect and rely on the fact that I always have a knife and scissors on me. -
Hardly a challenge if people are going to carry backup stuff.

:P ;)
Honestly, it will be a challenge for me regardless of the MT factor. I wouldn't be using any SAK for pliers, so it won't factor in much at all. I rely on my Rogueneer for pretty much anything I encounter with the exception of the pliers obviously. I will be attempting to rely on the Compact for all other tasks, and it's the only minimalist SAK with scissors, which is something I've gotta have, especially since my wife asks to use scissors rather regularly...Excuse alert. :ahhh I'm sure she can look after herself. But you, not so much.

You may be right there
She probably could handle it herself, but she's come to expect and rely on the fact that I always have a knife and scissors on me.Time to hand over the Rogueneer then.

Edit: And the OHT. :)
-
I'm definitely in - I'm going from a 5 layer Explorer with wood saw to a
Wenger SI.I guess I'll have to ditch my P4 for the duration as well?
I'm also tying this in with a 30 days without sweets - I've started a new job and people keep buying me chocolates and it's starting to show!

-
@magentus said:
I'm definitely in - I'm going from a 5 layer Explorer with wood saw to a
Wenger SI.I guess I'll have to ditch my P4 for the duration as well?
I'm also tying this in with a 30 days without sweets -** I've started a new job and people keep buying me chocolates** and it's starting to show!

sounds like my dream job

-
You'd think so wouldn't you? I've put on so much weight though.......
-
@Higgins617 said:
I'm going to try to make it with just the Esquire that Aloha so kindly gifted me, however I will need to keep pliers on stand-by for the jobs where that is simply a requirement.
What's the idea? Do we report back here with daily updates? On the first everyone should post in a row which SAK they'll be using so there's an uninterrupted list.
I was thinking I would start a new thread on the 1st where everyone could report on what they are using, and give updates.
-
I don't want to sound like I'm applying for membership of the OCD Squad,but,what are our choices for the challenge?
-
@kirk13 said:
I don't want to sound like I'm applying for membership of the OCD Squad,but,what are our choices for the challenge?Do you mean choices as far as SAKs?
I originally was thinking we would pick one type and everyone use that, but it would necessarily limit the # of participants, since not everyone would have that particular knife or be able/willing to buy one.
So I think it is better to leave it to the individual to decide what would be a challenge. My opinion is that anything over 2 layers is probably not very challenging, but that may just be me.
For me even 2 layers isn't a challenge, since its what I EDC, so I'm trying to procure a Bantam.
Hope that helps.
-
I don't want to sound like I'm applying for membership of the OCD Squad,but,what are our choices for the challenge?
Do you mean choices as far as SAKs?
I originally was thinking we would pick one type and everyone use that, but it would necessarily limit the # of participants, since not everyone would have that particular knife or be able/willing to buy one.
So I think it is better to leave it to the individual to decide what would be a challenge. My opinion is that anything over 2 layers is probably not very challenging, but that may just be me.
For me even 2 layers isn't a challenge, since its what I EDC, so I'm trying to procure a Bantam.
Hope that helps.
Kind of,but not really....
I know I can breeze through a month with a DofE, but Cadet would be a monumental challenge :ahhh
Any chance of a short list of options?
-
all this talk of 'minimalist' SAK's and there's me hunting for something BIGGER than a Swisschamp

-
I don't want to sound like I'm applying for membership of the OCD Squad,but,what are our choices for the challenge?
Do you mean choices as far as SAKs?
I originally was thinking we would pick one type and everyone use that, but it would necessarily limit the # of participants, since not everyone would have that particular knife or be able/willing to buy one.
So I think it is better to leave it to the individual to decide what would be a challenge. My opinion is that anything over 2 layers is probably not very challenging, but that may just be me.
For me even 2 layers isn't a challenge, since its what I EDC, so I'm trying to procure a Bantam.
Hope that helps.
Kind of,but not really....
I know I can breeze through a month with a DofE, but Cadet would be a monumental challenge :ahhh
Any chance of a short list of options?
Ok, this is just off the top of my head;
- Classic
- Rambler
- Executive
- Bantam
- Recruit
- Pocket Pal
- Cadet
- Lumberjack
- Tinker
- Spartan
- Waiter
- Compact
- Scientist
- Pioneer/Alox Soldier
- Electrician
I'm sure there are lots others.
The hard part is I would consider the DofE acceptable, so it really comes down to what is challenging for you.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login