Any interest in a minimalist SAK challenge?
-
I've been monitoring my SAK uses for the last few days and I think I'll fail very soon with the Waiter.

LOTS of use of scissors, awl, and phillips once or twice. All the tools the Waiter lacks.

**BTW, when do we start? **
-
There's some decidedly non-minimalist stuff being talked about, and the challenge hasn't even started yet. Stop making excuses and give it a go, you big jessies. ;)
Minimalism is "making due with what you've got"... Improvise! You'd be surprised what you can do with the most basic SAK if you just go with it.
The Pioneer/SI or similar are easily up to 99% of the tasks people could reasonably ask of a pocket knife type tool.
You guys have got me really thinking about giving it a go without any MTs. The only thing I really feel I may need is the pliers, which I doubt my Compact can replicate, no matter how great the improvisation skills may be
I may try it out at first though, and if I encounter a need for a multitool, that may cause me to start carrying one again.Pliers is the only thing I do sometimes need and when I do they're sure nice to have! I've EDC'd the same Leatherman classic for 20 yrs now. When I stop and think about it the one tool I use on that Leatherman 90% of the time is the pliers. The screwdrivers occasionally. The knife blade almost never, the other tools no because the SAK has those. In fact I don't even think of the Leatherman as a knife at all - it's a tool.
If your occupation or lifestyle requires a specialized tool (pliers are def that IMHO) then yes you need that tool. Otherwise the basic Leatherman I have actually has all the same implements my Pioneer has. A dilemma yes!
I'd almost say if you carried a MT for the purpose of ONLY it's pliers - due to personal needs in your day to day tasks - then that's not necessarily a violation of the Challenge... Because pliers are a tool that cannot be replicated by anything else.
If you do a lot of outdoors, tinkering or handyman activities a MT, flashlite and SAK are a basic necessity in life. If you're an average Joe who just drives to a desk job and then goes home again to watch TV, bbq dinner, etc then a fairly simple SAK will get you through life pretty easily. Geez, most folks nowdays don't even carry a pocket knife or MT at all! By that standard we here are all MacGyvers!

-
@enki_ck said:
I've been monitoring my SAK uses for the last few days and I think I'll fail very soon with the Waiter.
LOTS of use of scissors, awl, and phillips once or twice. All the tools the Waiter lacks.

**BTW, when do we start? **
This is why I decided on the Compact. It's a rather minimalist type SAK, but has many bases covered. That's as far as I'm willing to go ;)
-
@arizonaranchman said:
Pliers is the only thing I do sometimes need and when I do they're sure nice to have! I've EDC'd the same Leatherman classic for 20 yrs now. When I stop and think about it the one tool I use on that Leatherman 90% of the time is the pliers. The screwdrivers occasionally. The knife blade almost never, the other tools no because the SAK has those. In fact I don't even think of the Leatherman as a knife at all - it's a tool.If your occupation or lifestyle requires a specialized tool (pliers are def that IMHO) then yes you need that tool. Otherwise the basic Leatherman I have actually has all the same implements my Pioneer has. A dilemma yes!
I'd almost say if you carried a MT for the purpose of ONLY it's pliers - due to personal needs in your day to day tasks - then that's not necessarily a violation of the Challenge... Because pliers are a tool that cannot be replicated by anything else.
If you do a lot of outdoors, tinkering or handyman activities a MT, flashlite and SAK are a basic necessity in life. If you're an average Joe who just drives to a desk job and then goes home again to watch TV, bbq dinner, etc then a fairly simple SAK will get you through life pretty easily. Geez, most folks nowdays don't even carry a pocket knife or MT at all! By that standard we here are all MacGyvers!

I would love to carry something smaller like the PST just to have the pliers on me, even though it's a very capable tool in itself. Unfortunately, mine is in storage right now, along with the majority of my collection.
I'm an office guy myself, but also handle the occasional file cabinet or desk type repair or odd job. Pliers can come in handy there, and they also come in handy at times removing paper jams from our mail folder/inserter machine. However, I do have a few tools scattered around between my office and the mail processing room, so I wouldn't be lost if I didn't carry one, at least for work, unless I was away from this area and in another of our buildings.
Overall, I don't use pliers a lot at all, but they have been very handy when needed. As you said, nothing can replicate them. I just wish I had a more minimalistic multitool with them. It is just about the primary use I have for a multi, and like you, I don't even think of them as knives, but more as a tool. A SAK is pretty much all I need, and my Rogueneer covers everything I ever really need for the most part, other than pliers of course.
Yeah, it's odd how many people carry nothing. I used to be one of those people until about 2.5 years ago, and now I don't know how I managed without at least a SAK. It doesn't seem right to go anywhere without one ;)
-
for the love of god somebody stop this madness !!!
before one of you gets caught out and needs to scale a fish or something needs a 'hook'
-
My Compact has a hook. :)
Nate
-
@ducttapetech said:
My Compact has a hook. :)Nate
With a nail file even

-
Sorry, mine is old skool. But it has the thicker blade and tang. Well worth the fingernail file. IMO
The nail file would be sweet to have. Maybe I might mod it a tad later. Not sure.
Nate -
@Taxi Dad said:
for the love of god somebody stop this madness !!!
before one of you gets caught out and needs to scale a fish or something needs a 'hook'
Careful Michael, Lynn will hear you >:D
-
Monrogue,
I agree 100% - the need for pliers is something that should be an allowable exception to the Challenge IMHO - with the proviso that ONLY the pliers be allowed for use... :)
This is a complex subject isnt it!! Lol
-
Seems like a LM Mini Tool would be an acceptable carry in this case.
-
@ducttapetech said:
Sorry, mine is old skool. But it has the thicker blade and tang. Well worth the fingernail file. IMO
The nail file would be sweet to have. Maybe I might mod it a tad later. Not sure.
NateYeah, I'm the other way around, but I don't use it lots; I just like having one.
-
@arizonaranchman said:
Monrogue,I agree 100% - the need for pliers is something that should be an allowable exception to the Challenge IMHO - with the proviso that ONLY the pliers be allowed for use... :)
This is a complex subject isnt it!! Lol
I'm all for that
I would stick to only using the pliers if necessary. I hardly ever really use my MT for anything else, so I can commit myself to that. Yes, it is a complex subject, and one of many where I can go on and on, as I may be known to do around here 
@eddie1115 said:
Seems like a LM Mini Tool would be an acceptable carry in this case.That would be perfect for this challenge. Unfortunately I don't have one :-\
-
I am giving all of this up....

For this.....

Wow! On my test run to day, I had to walk to the shop 3 times for pliers, phillips and a wood saw. I do mess the OH blades. I am used to that fast opening and being able to do things one handed. All and all, I did ok, I did not run for my Surge.Also, the Compact 1911 is shoptoad approved.

Toad like Vics......and Bud......
Nate -
@arizonaranchman said:
Monrogue,I agree 100% - the need for pliers is something that should be an allowable exception to the Challenge IMHO - with the proviso that ONLY the pliers be allowed for use... :)
This is a complex subject isnt it!! Lol
May I suggest the 125mm Knipex Cobra? :D Really pocket friendly.
Very impressive, is what they are :ahhh

-
how can the moderators just stand about and watch this unfold :ahhh
who knows where it could end ? people 'selling off' cheep tools because they're fooled into believing they no longer need them ?*PM me folks >:D
-
Those have wire cutter on them?
Nate
-
@ducttapetech said:
Those have wire cutter on them?Nate
Nope, but they have a tremendous
gripbite.Man, you got a pet toad there? Cool. I once knew a pet rat that liked beer.
-
Also, will there be a new thread that we report to, or do we report to this one?
Kyle, we gonna tear this up with our Compacts!
Booo yahhhhh bitches!!! LOL!Nate
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
