Official 30-Day Minimalist SAK Challenge!
-
A spectacular Fall morning here in the high desert yet again... Cool n sunny and sipping my coffee.
Is this PT-1AA in the category of flashlight that fits the challenge? I've been carrying this for 3+ yrs, so it's my usual anyways, but I don't know what a 5mm flashlight is by definition. This is an LED by Streamlight. Single AA battery. If it fits the challenge you can add it to the "Official Equipment List" for me please :)
Also, for those of us that need a dedicated tool(s) for a specific task I'm wondering if FOR THAT TASK if they may be allowed an exemption to perform that task with another SAK and not have to withdraw? As 50ft-trad and a few others were saying it's creating a hardship in certain situations especially when common sense says you need a certain tool for a given task... As long as the Participant states his departure from his Minimalist tool of choice on that situation/event. What say ye?
For example I know for me I'd prefer someone defer to another SAK w/pliers than have to grab a pair of Craftsman pliers from the tool chest. Or when you know you're going out into the garden to do this or that and know you need a saw and there's just no way around it... Why not a pocket a Farmer for an hour rather than a pruning saw from the garage? Just note it in your "Daily Report" here when you check in at the end of the day? This may help some of the participants survive the month rather than having to pull out completely. Just a suggestion... :)

-
Oh my GOD WHAT THE smurf WAS I THINKING?!?! Gahhhhh!!!
I Want my SURGE!!!I think we are beginning to separate into two groups. The first consists of guys like Nate who actually use their larger SAKs and MTs on a daily basis or on the job. This minimalist thing is going to be hard on them, because it entails not having the proper tool on hand or having to keep walking to the tool box.
The other group, which I fall into, use a SAK merely as a daily convenience item - opening a package, snipping a thread or tightening a screw once in a while. This minimalist thing is not so difficult for us, as even a Classic SD will handle these things just fine. For this second group, the only "burden" of going minimalist is that we just have to give up the fun of carrying something larger or switching between SAKs. That's not an inconsequential burden for a true SAK addict, but its not nearly as difficult as giving up a Surge that you rely on all day.
So we guys in the second group definitely have an advantage when it comes to remaining faithful for the whole 30 days. Its only been 4 days, but I'm having no difficulty whatsoever with carrying only the Executive. And I partly wish that I had gone even smaller (Classic SD).
Good thoughts here. I fall mostly into the 2nd category as well. Though, when I do need bigger and better than the EDC pioneer, I usually prefer dedicated tools anyway. So, I don't feel "minimalist" with my daily carry, even though compared to many, I suppose I might be.
Honestly, after these last couple of days, I think I could manage just fine with a bantam as EDC. I just prefer the slightly larger tools on the pioneer. I also vastly prefer alox, but that doesn't make it a "need."
-
@50ft-trad said:
I had a worrying thought last night...
Do any of you remember the Top Gear race across London? STIG takes the Tube,Hamster cycles,Jezza uses a boat(!) and Slow drives...
And,to most Londoners anyway,the result was no surprise....STIG won!
In the same way,I fear this thread may prove that we're proving we don't need big multi layer SAKs and MTs!
Well, I was kind of thinking about this last night and considered officially bailing out of the challenge.
I need to go and do a few jobs on the boat soon ... and I know the minimalist carry won't be of any use. I could use dedicated tools, but that will just mean I get less done than I would with a multi as I'll be working slower. Same in the garden if the weather is half decent tomorrow. A multitool will help speed things up.
A lot of the time, going minimalist is not a major obstacle - but I'm just forcing myself to be inefficient when it matters. I've annoyed a lot of friends in the pat by waiting till they've gone to fetch the correct tool before pulling out a multitool and having the job well under way or even completed by the time they got back >:D Now all I've done is lowered myself to their level in terms of having to spend longer getting a dedicated tool than I would actually doing what needs doing.
Minimalist carry is better than nothing for generally pottering about, but there's a reason I have a pocket load of stuff on me most of the time .... it works! At the very least, I really ought to take normal carry when going to work on the boat, or having an hour or two in the garden, or doing any kind of project really even if I drop back to the Scout Jr and Nitecore T0 afterwards. Only reason I haven't already failed or bailed, is it's raining so I haven't done any project work yet ... :-\
Yeah, sounds like this may be tougher on you, since you have a more consistent need for heavier duty tools.
Though I like the minimalist idea, if I had the need for the multi I would be carrying one. I wouldn't like being handicapped in what I can do just to save a couple ounces.
But, I guess that's where the challenge part comes in ;)
-
@ducttapetech said:
I wonder if Mag-lite will update this one like are doing with the others. These new Mag Lites they are coming out with are bad ass and for a good price.Nate
Nate, they actually do make a Mag-lite Solitaire LED version now, for what it's worth.

-
I wonder if Mag-lite will update this one like are doing with the others. These new Mag Lites they are coming out with are bad ass and for a good price.
Nate
Nate, they actually do make a Mag-lite Solitaire LED version now, for what it's worth.

But not in the old school 5mm version, that one has a modern LED.
-
-
@kirk13 said:
I had a worrying thought last night...Do any of you remember the Top Gear race across London? STIG takes the Tube,Hamster cycles,Jezza uses a boat(!) and Slow drives...
And,to most Londoners anyway,the result was no surprise....STIG won!
In the same way,I fear this thread may prove that we're proving we don't need big multi layer SAKs and MTs!
I had this worry as well Kirky...wondering if this would confirm my thoughts that I can get by just fine with something like the Compact and a simple plier based MT rather than the more robust Rogueneer and MTs I carry. I don't like that idea :ahhh
-
I easily fall into powernoodle's 2nd category as well. The primary need I have for a multi is for the pliers really. If I have my Rogueneer, there's little else I need covered other than pliers and a wood saw. I guess that would make the Sidekick a good MT for that purpose, plus it'd give me a OHO blade. The OHT is a great companion to the Rogueneer as well, but a bit bulky and heavy to carry just for that purpose. Anyway, if I were to carry the Compact instead, I would definitely want a full size robust MT on me as well. So far I've managed fine though with the Compact.
-
Day 4
Nothing special today. Used the tiny manager to clean the mowing robots blades.
-
I had a worrying thought last night...
Do any of you remember the Top Gear race across London? STIG takes the Tube,Hamster cycles,Jezza uses a boat(!) and Slow drives...
And,to most Londoners anyway,the result was no surprise....STIG won!
In the same way,I fear this thread may prove that we're proving we don't need big multi layer SAKs and MTs!
I had this worry as well Kirky...wondering if this would confirm my thoughts that I can get by just fine with something like the Compact and a simple plier based MT rather than the more robust Rogueneer and MTs I carry. I don't like that idea :ahhh
I am thinking the opposite, it is showing me how much time is lost and how inefficient it is not carrying a bigger Sak or Multi. but if it gets right down to it, you only need a knife. And a tool box.
Nate
-
My minimalist EDC are fighting back my old EDC. I guess they don't want me to fail the challenge :D

-
That is a cool pick!
Nate
-
Day 3 wrapped up with me using the combo opener on a can of pineapple for on homemade pizza. Worked much better than I had been expecting.
Day 4 so far has seen it trimming tags with the scissors. Tomorrow should be interesting as I'm out all day in the woods. I'll have dedicated tools, but I usually carry a bigger SAK or Multi. We'll see how it goes.
-
End of day 4 - it's the weekend and my family have colds so I've been in nursing all day. Prepared lunch and tea with my SI and it bit me tonight! Blood everywhere though it's only a small cut.
Hang in there everyone, I hope you're enjoying the challenge as much as I am.
-
I hope your family gets to feeling better.
I have been enjoying the challenge. But there has been more than a few times it has been trying.Nate
-
@ducttapetech said:
That is a cool pick!Nate
Thanks!
-
@magentus said:
End of day 4 - it's the weekend and my family have colds so I've been in nursing all day. Prepared lunch and tea with my SI and it bit me tonight! Blood everywhere though it's only a small cut.Hang in there everyone, I hope you're enjoying the challenge as much as I am.
Hope everyone feels better :-\
-

Slicing some hot links for the skillet :) -
Mmmmmmmm
Nate
-
@ducttapetech said:
MmmmmmmmNate
+1 yummy!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

