Official 30-Day Minimalist SAK Challenge!
-
Oh my GOD WHAT THE smurf WAS I THINKING?!?! Gahhhhh!!!
I Want my SURGE!!!I think we are beginning to separate into two groups. The first consists of guys like Nate who actually use their larger SAKs and MTs on a daily basis or on the job. This minimalist thing is going to be hard on them, because it entails not having the proper tool on hand or having to keep walking to the tool box.
The other group, which I fall into, use a SAK merely as a daily convenience item - opening a package, snipping a thread or tightening a screw once in a while. This minimalist thing is not so difficult for us, as even a Classic SD will handle these things just fine. For this second group, the only "burden" of going minimalist is that we just have to give up the fun of carrying something larger or switching between SAKs. That's not an inconsequential burden for a true SAK addict, but its not nearly as difficult as giving up a Surge that you rely on all day.
So we guys in the second group definitely have an advantage when it comes to remaining faithful for the whole 30 days. Its only been 4 days, but I'm having no difficulty whatsoever with carrying only the Executive. And I partly wish that I had gone even smaller (Classic SD).
The thing that's been interesting for me is to note how my work enviroment has changed,and the impact that's had on my carry.
One of the prime reasons I replaced my PST was the number of shelves I was having to repair,or bend back into usable shape,and the PST's handles where cutting my hands badly. The Wave gave me a massive increase in tasks I could tackle,rather than having to refer them to either our house services,or go scrounge a speSmurfpillst tool.
Another key factor has been a practical improvement in terms of how the shop floor is run. There is now a full screwdriver set,which our girls have claimed possessive ownership of;likewise scissors. My fixation with redundancy of tools is the nessesity it once was!
When I done the Fit test a year ago,I realised I could probably get away with a Rambler and LM Mini,and maybe keep a full sized Multi in my locker for those times where the smurf does hit the fan.
....
I've been very pleased with the one layer SAKs so far,but three or four years ago,I'd never have coped!
-
End of day 4 - it's the weekend and my family have colds so I've been in nursing all day. Prepared lunch and tea with my SI and it bit me tonight! Blood everywhere though it's only a small cut.
Hang in there everyone, I hope you're enjoying the challenge as much as I am.
Hope everyone feels better :-\
Thanks Gust and Nate - they're both on the mend now thanks to my great nursing abilities (!) Plus I did literally bleed for them.
Food prep again mainly today - opened a can of chickpeas to make hummous and lots of veg prep.
I really like the SI but I'm still missing my usual.

-
Just used my Pioneer on another orange....a longitudinal cut all the way around and most of the peel comes off in 2 pieces! Fast and not a lot of gunk under your nails!

-
End of day 4 - it's the weekend and my family have colds so I've been in nursing all day. Prepared lunch and tea with my SI and it bit me tonight! Blood everywhere though it's only a small cut.
Hang in there everyone, I hope you're enjoying the challenge as much as I am.
Hope everyone feels better :-\
Thanks Gust and Nate - they're both on the mend now thanks to my great nursing abilities (!) Plus I did literally bleed for them.
Food prep again mainly today - opened a can of chickpeas to make hummous and lots of veg prep.
I really like the SI but I'm still missing my usual.

Good to hear they're getting better!
-
I had a bit of an unusual situation today where I used a tool on my minimalist carry that my regular EDC doesn't have.
I used the tweezers on the Wengerinox to remove a splinter from my daughter's heel. Normally, if I had a splinter, I would just dig it out with the blade. On her, I would have had to go get some regular tweezers.
So, my minimalist carry was more efficient and saved me a trip

-
Oh my GOD WHAT THE smurf WAS I THINKING?!?! Gahhhhh!!!
I Want my SURGE!!!I think we are beginning to separate into two groups. The first consists of guys like Nate who actually use their larger SAKs and MTs on a daily basis or on the job. This minimalist thing is going to be hard on them, because it entails not having the proper tool on hand or having to keep walking to the tool box.
The other group, which I fall into, use a SAK merely as a daily convenience item - opening a package, snipping a thread or tightening a screw once in a while. This minimalist thing is not so difficult for us, as even a Classic SD will handle these things just fine. For this second group, the only "burden" of going minimalist is that we just have to give up the fun of carrying something larger or switching between SAKs. That's not an inconsequential burden for a true SAK addict, but its not nearly as difficult as giving up a Surge that you rely on all day.
So we guys in the second group definitely have an advantage when it comes to remaining faithful for the whole 30 days. Its only been 4 days, but I'm having no difficulty whatsoever with carrying only the Executive. And I partly wish that I had gone even smaller (Classic SD).
A very fair assessment I'd say. Now normally I'd fall into the first group as I work as a Maintenance Engineer and a MT has been a vital part of my tool kit for years now, I just couldn't imagine turning up to work without one.
However, I'm on a break from work just now (on purpose ;)) so a MT has become a bit of a luxury for a while. In this spirit my Golfer has managed all my needs for the last few days and I'd say it'll likely handle most of them for the rest of the month. Time will tell though. :D
-
Day 5
Stayed home, did nothing...
-
-
@Etherealicer said:
Day 5Stayed home, did nothing...
Add beer and it's

-
Opened a bunch of packages, improvised the nail file as a philips driver on my bike ride.
-
Kinda light day today. Used the combo tool to open a can of chili, used to hook to thread some twine through a trap. Blade did some cutting.
But the main thing today that was totally not related to my SAK use, was I got shoot a freaken 50 Pounder mountain howitzer!!!! BOO YAH!!!!

Nate
-
@ducttapetech said:
Kinda light day today. Used the combo tool to open a can of chili, used to hook to thread some twine through a trap. Blade did some cutting.
But the main thing today that was totally not related to my SAK use, was I got shoot a freaken 50 Pounder mountain howitzer!!!! BOO YAH!!!!

Nate
COOL!
-
Sorry guys, I'm out 
Tried it, but it's really not doing me any favours. It's proving to be a handicap in my normal daily life, so I'm reverting back to "normality" as of tomorrow. This exercise has confirmed to me that me carrying the stuff I normally do is justified, and it wouldn't be sensible for me to carry this on. I considerd just carrying extra at certain times, but the reality is I don't always know in advance when the extras will be needed, and makes much more sense to bow out now before I find myself too compromised
Good luck to everyone else

-
Seems our OCD Squad is slacking. ::)
Added the missing entries to the list.
If you're not on it but have entered, speak up and we'll correct that.

<u>NAME</u>¦<u>PRIMARY KNIFE</u>¦<u>WENGER WEDNESDAY</u>¦<u>LIGHT</u>
gustophersmob¦Wenger Premier¦¦Fenix E01
Higgins617¦Esquire¦¦Coast G10
SAK Guy¦OC Red Pioneer¦Wenger SI¦Gerber Infinity Ultra
eddie1115¦Tourist¦¦Princeton Tec Pulsar
ducttapetech¦Compact Plus¦¦Mag-Lite Solitaire
Toolslinger¦Compact Plus¦¦Led Lenser P2
Hyatt181¦Compact¦¦
colt 1911¦Tinker Small¦¦Gerber Tempo
powernoodle¦Executive¦¦Fenix E05
arizonaranchman¦Silver Alox Pioneer¦¦
Monrogue¦Compact¦¦Photon Freedom Micro
haackeg¦Tinker¦¦
SAKchief¦Manager¦¦
shark_za¦Vic Waiter¦¦Fenix E01
50ft-trad¦Case Scout Jr¦¦Nitecore T0
Sorel¦Alox Bantam¦¦
Grass¦Sportsman¦¦
red_rider_1979¦Rambler Stayglow¦¦
hiraethus¦OC Red Pioneer¦¦Fenix E05
Etherealicer¦Midnight Manager¦Crusader Mini Spotlight¦Scale Lights
coSAK¦Compact¦¦
zoidberg¦Pioneer Apprentice¦Wenger SI¦Fenix E01
kirk13¦Vic 84mm Apprentice¦Wenger Junior 10¦Fauxston
gene stoner¦Tinkerer¦¦
pfrsantos¦Sportsman¦¦Led Lenser K1
derekmac¦OC Red Pioneer¦¦
magentus¦Wenger SI¦¦
cbl51¦Classic¦¦
Caranthanus¦Wenger S10¦¦
fx17¦Small Tinker¦¦
Gareth¦Golfer¦¦Fenix E01
K13ss4r¦Silver Alox Electrician¦¦
enki_ck¦Waiter¦¦Peak Matterhorn
ivan_partizan¦Model 234¦¦
shamus¦Classic SD¦¦Photon Freedom
getahl¦Classic SD¦¦
Fast Bill¦Spartan¦¦
mrynnr¦Wenger SI¦¦
Syph007¦84mm Apprentice¦¦ -
Very cool, Nate. :o
BTW, did you hit that barn? :D
-
Just disqualifying myself ... ;)
<u>NAME</u>¦<u>PRIMARY KNIFE</u>¦<u>WENGER WEDNESDAY</u>¦<u>LIGHT</u>
gustophersmob¦Wenger Premier¦¦Fenix E01
Higgins617¦Esquire¦¦Coast G10
SAK Guy¦OC Red Pioneer¦Wenger SI¦Gerber Infinity Ultra
eddie1115¦Tourist¦¦Princeton Tec Pulsar
ducttapetech¦Compact Plus¦¦Mag-Lite Solitaire
Toolslinger¦Compact Plus¦¦Led Lenser P2
Hyatt181¦Compact¦¦
colt 1911¦Tinker Small¦¦Gerber Tempo
powernoodle¦Executive¦¦Fenix E05
arizonaranchman¦Silver Alox Pioneer¦¦
Monrogue¦Compact¦¦Photon Freedom Micro
haackeg¦Tinker¦¦
SAKchief¦Manager¦¦
shark_za¦Vic Waiter¦¦Fenix E01
50ft-trad¦Case Scout Jr¦¦Nitecore T0(BAILED OUT 5/10/14)
Sorel¦Alox Bantam¦¦
Grass¦Sportsman¦¦
red_rider_1979¦Rambler Stayglow¦¦
hiraethus¦OC Red Pioneer¦¦Fenix E05
Etherealicer¦Midnight Manager¦Crusader Mini Spotlight¦Scale Lights
coSAK¦Compact¦¦
zoidberg¦Pioneer Apprentice¦Wenger SI¦Fenix E01
kirk13¦Vic 84mm Apprentice¦Wenger Junior 10¦Fauxston
gene stoner¦Tinkerer¦¦
pfrsantos¦Sportsman¦¦Led Lenser K1
derekmac¦OC Red Pioneer¦¦
magentus¦Wenger SI¦¦
cbl51¦Classic¦¦
Caranthanus¦Wenger S10¦¦
fx17¦Small Tinker¦¦
Gareth¦Golfer¦¦Fenix E01
K13ss4r¦Silver Alox Electrician¦¦
enki_ck¦Waiter¦¦Peak Matterhorn
ivan_partizan¦Model 234¦¦
shamus¦Classic SD¦¦Photon Freedom
getahl¦Classic SD¦¦
Fast Bill¦Spartan¦¦
mrynnr¦Wenger SI¦¦
Syph007¦84mm Apprentice¦¦ -
@50ft-trad said:
Sorry guys, I'm out 
Tried it, but it's really not doing me any favours. It's proving to be a handicap in my normal daily life, so I'm reverting back to "normality" as of tomorrow. This exercise has confirmed to me that me carrying the stuff I normally do is justified, and it wouldn't be sensible for me to carry this on. I considerd just carrying extra at certain times, but the reality is I don't always know in advance when the extras will be needed, and makes much more sense to bow out now before I find myself too compromised
Good luck to everyone else

Noooooo ... :ahhh
Now I feel tempted too.

Well to be honest I've been tempted every single day since it started. I really miss the scissors. Occasionally the pliers. I'm starting to feel like a Neanderthal considering how much I've been using my teeth lately for stuff that would usually be done with the tools I had on me.

-
Day 5 Report
Went hiking all day. Stayed with just the Compact.
Used the scissors to cut moleskin to prevent blisters for a fellow hiker in new boots.
Used the blade to cut cheese and salami and spread mustard on bread at lunch.
Used the hook to remove the lid on my pot to check water when boiling it to make tea.One of my fellow hikers (whom I know usually carries a SAK) had his small Tinker with him today
. I helped him out by sharpening the blade on it while waiting for our water to boil. On a random note, my Compact nicked his pinkie finger at lunch when he borrowed it for mustard duty. Very small clean cut, but it bled a surprising amount. -
@50ft-trad said:
Sorry guys, I'm out 
Tried it, but it's really not doing me any favours. It's proving to be a handicap in my normal daily life, so I'm reverting back to "normality" as of tomorrow. This exercise has confirmed to me that me carrying the stuff I normally do is justified, and it wouldn't be sensible for me to carry this on. I considerd just carrying extra at certain times, but the reality is I don't always know in advance when the extras will be needed, and makes much more sense to bow out now before I find myself too compromised
Good luck to everyone else

Noooooo ... :ahhh
Now I feel tempted too.

Well to be honest I've been tempted every single day since it started. I really miss the scissors. Occasionally the pliers. I'm starting to feel like a Neanderthal considering how much I've been using my teeth lately for stuff that would usually be done with the tools I had on me.

Sorry Nik :-[
I was missing the pliers and scissors too much, plus a more capable knife blade. The torch actually handled what I needed quite well despite being only modest lumens, but not having the other tools wasn't working out. It's kind of like a "don't use your car for a month" challenge, some would manage fine, some would struggle but cope, but for others it just wouldn't be practical :-\
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
