Official 30-Day Minimalist SAK Challenge!
-
You haven't converted me yet you fiend

In all honesty though, I could likely get by just fine with my Compact. My Rogueneer is looking more like overkill (not that such a fact has stopped me before), with the only two things I miss being a small secondary blade and the metal file. As much as I like to have the mag/phillips layer, I rarely use it, and the main thing I want is the magnifier. I wish there was something besides the phillips that could go there, especially since I have the can opener for phillips driver needs. I'm beginning to think that I would like the Compact with the metal file (I think that's the Trailguide). Still, the Rogueneer is the max of what I want in a SAK, and still my fave. I think the big thing helping the Compact is just how well it rides in the pocket, and how I barely notice it there in comparison with the 5 layer Rogueneer beast.
-
@Toolslinger said:
Before this challenge (ie the day before the first thread started) I had been debating carrying only my SwissChamp for a month or more and documenting each tool that I used. The goal being to mod it down to the absolute minimum toolset (eliminating unused ones) possible. I probably would have ended up with a Climber.
I pretty much did just that myself, though it has been years ago now. I bought a Swisschamp and decided to start carrying it, with the intent that I would ultimately either (1) get on with the Swisschamp well enough to make it my long-term EDC, or (2) figure out which tools I actually used and get a slimmer EDC with only those tools. It only took me a week or two to decide that the Swisschamp was more than I wanted to carry around; and that, in addition to the basic Spartan tool set (the fact that I carried a Spartan exclusively for years might have biased this outcome), the scissors were the one additional tool I really used regularly. So, while I didn't mod the Swisschamp down, I did end up with the Climber as probably the closest to perfect EDC for me.
@shark_za said:
I think the Climber can be replaced by the Compact if you don't use the Awl and think that the Phillips on the can opener is not so great. I'm thinking that is the SAK for EDC.This exercise is helping me narrow it down to a "Waiter Plus with scissors" aka the Compact.
I'll still use my Evo 10 (On Wednesday I see) but can see the Compact taking center stage.The Compact has many fans, and deservedly so. Though I tried the Compact, I ultimately returned to the Climber, for the following reasons:
-
the opener layer beats out the combo tool not only due to the can opener Phillips driver, but also because the beefier bottle opener makes a better light pry tool (and better flat screwdriver for stubborn screws) than the combo tool
-
I do use the awl
-
it is nice to have at least two knife blades; one for "dirty" work and one for "clean" work
But to each his own...

-
-
Before starting the challenge, I was alternating between a Marly Trail Guide and a Wenger Traveler with a Swiss Champ in my EDC Bag. There were ALOX Pioneers/ Farmers available if a really yucky/hard use/saw task came up but was really happy with the 3 layer Traveler/Trail guide combo.
I used to EDC a 93mm with along with another knife so just carrying the Pioneer was a change, but not an unfamiliar one.
I do miss my 3+ layer knives though.....
-

Quiet day at home again... The Pioneer opened a bag of bird feed.
-
I really like that pic AZR!

-
-
-
Fancied a less colourful knife so have swapped the red Pioneer for a black one:

I've now got a knife for Wenger Wednesdays too - my 1978 SI. Updated table below:<u>NAME</u>¦<u>PRIMARY KNIFE</u>¦<u>WENGER WEDNESDAY</u>¦<u>LIGHT</u>
gustophersmob¦Wenger Premier¦¦Fenix E01
Higgins617¦Esquire¦¦Coast G10
SAK Guy¦OC Red Pioneer¦Wenger SI¦Gerber Infinity Ultra
eddie1115¦Tourist¦¦Princeton Tec Pulsar
ducttapetech¦Compact Plus¦¦Mag-Lite Solitaire
Toolslinger¦Compact Plus¦¦Led Lenser P2
Hyatt181¦Compact¦¦
colt 1911¦Tinker Small¦¦Gerber Tempo
powernoodle¦Executive¦¦Fenix E05
arizonaranchman¦Silver Alox Pioneer¦¦
Monrogue¦Compact¦¦Photon Freedom Micro
haackeg¦Tinker¦¦
SAKchief¦Manager¦¦
shark_za¦Vic Waiter¦¦Fenix E01
50ft-trad¦Case Scout Jr¦¦Nitecore T0(BAILED OUT 5/10/14)
Sorel¦Alox Bantam¦¦
Grass¦Sportsman¦¦
red_rider_1979¦Rambler Stayglow¦¦
hiraethus¦Black Pioneer¦1978 Wenger SI¦Fenix E05
Etherealicer¦Midnight Manager¦Crusader Mini Spotlight¦Scale Lights
coSAK¦Compact¦¦
zoidberg¦Pioneer Apprentice¦Wenger SI¦Fenix E01
kirk13¦Vic 84mm Apprentice¦Wenger Junior 10¦Fauxston
gene stoner¦Tinkerer¦¦
pfrsantos¦Sportsman¦¦Led Lenser K1
derekmac¦OC Red Pioneer¦¦
magentus¦Wenger SI¦¦
cbl51¦Classic¦¦
Caranthanus¦Wenger S10¦¦
fx17¦Small Tinker¦¦
Gareth¦Golfer¦¦Fenix E01
K13ss4r¦Silver Alox Electrician¦¦
enki_ck¦Waiter¦¦Peak Matterhorn
ivan_partizan¦Model 234¦¦
shamus¦Classic SD¦¦Photon Freedom
getahl¦Classic SD¦¦
Fast Bill¦Spartan¦¦
mrynnr¦Wenger SI¦¦
Syph007¦84mm Apprentice¦¦ -
-
@hiraethus said:
Quick breakdown of the brand and size of primary knife used:


23% of the primary knives are alox too - mostly Vic but a couple of Wenger SIs.
And as you can see, 50ft trad has a category all of his own in both cases. :DI've often said that Al is in a category of his own :D
-
What are you folks finding the most difficult part of the challenge?
For me,it's carrying the same SAK everyday,without having a choice.
It's been a long,long time since I've lacked choice!
-
I think 50ft can't be considered minimalist... We limited this to 91mm or less...
:D :D
-
@kirk13 said:
What are you folks finding the most difficult part of the challenge?For me,it's carrying the same SAK everyday,without having a choice.
It's been a long,long time since I've lacked choice!
Well spoken Kirk! Also for me, not being able to dip into my bag of SAKs and pull out a specialized one for a task.

-
@kirk13 said:
What are you folks finding the most difficult part of the challenge?For me,it's carrying the same SAK everyday,without having a choice.
It's been a long,long time since I've lacked choice!
Its not the choice part. I carry a Surge most of the time. Well, was.
The difficult part is the major lack of tools. Pliers, drivers, saw and file. Miss the OH blades like crazy. Mostly because they are faster to open. Did have one job today when I was up on a latter when a OH blade would have been a God send. The utility knife did not and the reach I needed in a tight spot. Had to climb down the latter so I could safely open the blade. I was using one hand to brace myself while working. Walking back and forth to the shop for little fixes that a larger SAK or MT would have taken care of is getting a tad old. But, my Compact is proving to be useful. Just not as useful as my Surge.Nate
-
Still carrying the Sportsman. Used it to open a package of sesame flakes.

After I opened it, I read the label and threw the damned thing in the trash...



Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




