Benchmade Griptillian, unimpressed.
-
I recently got a mini grip from a friend in trade. Had the same centring and clip issues. I used to have a couple other mini grips. Same clip issues, maybe centring. I don't think this is unique at all.
-
@gunga said:
I recently got a mini grip from a friend in trade. Had the same centring and clip issues. I used to have a couple other mini grips. Same clip issues, maybe centring. I don't think this is unique at all.It would seem the clip not touching is just because of the scale shape and (in my opinion) poor design. The centering also seems to be very common, but still unacceptable. Benchmades prices go up and quality control goes down. I feel like I sound like a broken record, but most knife and tool companies are having these issues. They rather produce less superior products and charge more to maximize profits and screw you on both ends of the spectrum then make a fair amount of profit and produce a superior product. Pisses me off.
-
@captain spaulding said:
I recently got a mini grip from a friend in trade. Had the same centring and clip issues. I used to have a couple other mini grips. Same clip issues, maybe centring. I don't think this is unique at all.
It would seem the clip not touching is just because of the scale shape and (in my opinion) poor design. The centering also seems to be very common, but still unacceptable. Benchmades prices go up and quality control goes down. I feel like I sound like a broken record, but most knife and tool companies are having these issues. They rather produce less superior products and charge more to maximize profits and screw you on both ends of the spectrum then make a fair amount of profit and produce a superior product. Pisses me off.
I wouldn't be surprised in this day and age, that many manufacturers are having to take any shortcuts they can just to make any profit at all. Steel prices are always a dynamic factor, as are energy prices for powering machines and for heat treatment. Inflation matching wage increases, rents, tooling, logistics, litigation ... the list of year on year cost increases for manufacturers goes on and on. I bet the dealers have better margins than the makers do. Doesn't help the user much, I know - but I can see both sides of the fence, and it's not easy for either party right now. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying sloppiness is acceptable, but I expect we'll see this trend continue with larger manufacturers for a while yet
-
@50ft-trad said:
@captain spaulding said:
I recently got a mini grip from a friend in trade. Had the same centring and clip issues. I used to have a couple other mini grips. Same clip issues, maybe centring. I don't think this is unique at all.
It would seem the clip not touching is just because of the scale shape and (in my opinion) poor design. The centering also seems to be very common, but still unacceptable. Benchmades prices go up and quality control goes down. I feel like I sound like a broken record, but most knife and tool companies are having these issues. They rather produce less superior products and charge more to maximize profits and screw you on both ends of the spectrum then make a fair amount of profit and produce a superior product. Pisses me off.
I wouldn't be surprised in this day and age, that many manufacturers are having to take any shortcuts they can just to make any profit at all. Steel prices are always a dynamic factor, as are energy prices for powering machines and for heat treatment. Inflation matching wage increases, rents, tooling, logistics, litigation ... the list of year on year cost increases for manufacturers goes on and on. I bet the dealers have better margins than the makers do. Doesn't help the user much, I know - but I can see both sides of the fence, and it's not easy for either party right now. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying sloppiness is acceptable, but I expect we'll see this trend continue with larger manufacturers for a while yet
I would respectfully disagree, but it is just my opinion and I really have no way to know either way. What really gets me is the MAP pricing going into effect. Benchmade knives cost rose 33% to the customer. That's a huge increase. Now the pricing is one thing and if quality stayed the same then it is what it is, but introducing MAP pricing and letting quality control go to crap is a whole other problem. I just personally don't see how they could be struggling to make profit. Without knowing what they make the knives for and what they sell them to the dealers for it is hard to say how much profit they realistically make, but with a hugely successful knife company you would think they would know how to run a profitable business. I could be completely wrong. I don't know.
-
@captain spaulding said:
@50ft-trad said:
@captain spaulding said:
I recently got a mini grip from a friend in trade. Had the same centring and clip issues. I used to have a couple other mini grips. Same clip issues, maybe centring. I don't think this is unique at all.
It would seem the clip not touching is just because of the scale shape and (in my opinion) poor design. The centering also seems to be very common, but still unacceptable. Benchmades prices go up and quality control goes down. I feel like I sound like a broken record, but most knife and tool companies are having these issues. They rather produce less superior products and charge more to maximize profits and screw you on both ends of the spectrum then make a fair amount of profit and produce a superior product. Pisses me off.
I wouldn't be surprised in this day and age, that many manufacturers are having to take any shortcuts they can just to make any profit at all. Steel prices are always a dynamic factor, as are energy prices for powering machines and for heat treatment. Inflation matching wage increases, rents, tooling, logistics, litigation ... the list of year on year cost increases for manufacturers goes on and on. I bet the dealers have better margins than the makers do. Doesn't help the user much, I know - but I can see both sides of the fence, and it's not easy for either party right now. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying sloppiness is acceptable, but I expect we'll see this trend continue with larger manufacturers for a while yet
I would respectfully disagree, but it is just my opinion and I really have no way to know either way. What really gets me is the MAP pricing going into effect. Benchmade knives cost rose 33% to the customer. That's a huge increase. Now the pricing is one thing and if quality stayed the same then it is what it is, but introducing MAP pricing and letting quality control go to crap is a whole other problem. I just personally don't see how they could be struggling to make profit. Without knowing what they make the knives for and what they sell them to the dealers for it is hard to say how much profit they realistically make, but with a hugely successful knife company you would think they would know how to run a profitable business. I could be completely wrong. I don't know.
You're quite right, without knowing their actual manufacturing cost per piece and their wholesale prices, it's all guesswork. My comments/opinions are based on working in manufacturing for many years (other products) seeing the pressures and rising costs involved, and looking at the general trends out there in the market with knives and tools.The recent changes to the Juice and Surge spring to mind, along with the move to OPMT and the Sidekick and Wingan. I dare say they're not all finding it as hard as each other, but I'd hate to think I was trying to run this kind of business right now. I could easily have got the wrong impression though

-
People buy them, so they sell them..
Maybe the extra cost covers the extra amount neded for refunds/repais etc. due to the low quality.. :) There are huge threads on BF about that, by the way.
I have never owned or wanted to own a Benchmade, so I am talking in general here.
-
@dks said:
People buy them, so they sell them..Maybe the extra cost covers the extra amount neded for refunds/repais etc. due to the low quality.. :) There are huge threads on BF about that, by the way.
I have never owned or wanted to own a Benchmade, so I am talking in general here.
Possibly. That would be a horrible way to run a business though. It just makes your products look like crap and puts all the strain on the customer. Just make it correct in the first place and its all the same.
-
@captain spaulding said:
@50ft-trad said:
@captain spaulding said:
I recently got a mini grip from a friend in trade. Had the same centring and clip issues. I used to have a couple other mini grips. Same clip issues, maybe centring. I don't think this is unique at all.
It would seem the clip not touching is just because of the scale shape and (in my opinion) poor design. The centering also seems to be very common, but still unacceptable. Benchmades prices go up and quality control goes down. I feel like I sound like a broken record, but most knife and tool companies are having these issues. They rather produce less superior products and charge more to maximize profits and screw you on both ends of the spectrum then make a fair amount of profit and produce a superior product. Pisses me off.
I wouldn't be surprised in this day and age, that many manufacturers are having to take any shortcuts they can just to make any profit at all. Steel prices are always a dynamic factor, as are energy prices for powering machines and for heat treatment. Inflation matching wage increases, rents, tooling, logistics, litigation ... the list of year on year cost increases for manufacturers goes on and on. I bet the dealers have better margins than the makers do. Doesn't help the user much, I know - but I can see both sides of the fence, and it's not easy for either party right now. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying sloppiness is acceptable, but I expect we'll see this trend continue with larger manufacturers for a while yet
I would respectfully disagree, but it is just my opinion and I really have no way to know either way. What really gets me is the MAP pricing going into effect. Benchmade knives cost rose 33% to the customer. That's a huge increase. Now the pricing is one thing and if quality stayed the same then it is what it is, but introducing MAP pricing and letting quality control go to crap is a whole other problem. I just personally don't see how they could be struggling to make profit. Without knowing what they make the knives for and what they sell them to the dealers for it is hard to say how much profit they realistically make, but with a hugely successful knife company you would think they would know how to run a profitable business. I could be completely wrong. I don't know.
I don't know too much about knife economics, but judging from the recent MAP enforcement, I'd say the (certain) dealers seem to have strong influence over the BM.
-
@captain spaulding said:
@50ft-trad said:
@captain spaulding said:
[quote author=gunga link=topic=54933.msg964717#msg964717 date=1413414231]
I recently got a mini grip from a friend in trade. Had the same centring and clip issues. I used to have a couple other mini grips. Same clip issues, maybe centring. I don't think this is unique at all.It would seem the clip not touching is just because of the scale shape and (in my opinion) poor design. The centering also seems to be very common, but still unacceptable. Benchmades prices go up and quality control goes down. I feel like I sound like a broken record, but most knife and tool companies are having these issues. They rather produce less superior products and charge more to maximize profits and screw you on both ends of the spectrum then make a fair amount of profit and produce a superior product. Pisses me off.
I wouldn't be surprised in this day and age, that many manufacturers are having to take any shortcuts they can just to make any profit at all. Steel prices are always a dynamic factor, as are energy prices for powering machines and for heat treatment. Inflation matching wage increases, rents, tooling, logistics, litigation ... the list of year on year cost increases for manufacturers goes on and on. I bet the dealers have better margins than the makers do. Doesn't help the user much, I know - but I can see both sides of the fence, and it's not easy for either party right now. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying sloppiness is acceptable, but I expect we'll see this trend continue with larger manufacturers for a while yet
I would respectfully disagree, but it is just my opinion and I really have no way to know either way. What really gets me is the MAP pricing going into effect. Benchmade knives cost rose 33% to the customer. That's a huge increase. Now the pricing is one thing and if quality stayed the same then it is what it is, but introducing MAP pricing and letting quality control go to crap is a whole other problem. I just personally don't see how they could be struggling to make profit. Without knowing what they make the knives for and what they sell them to the dealers for it is hard to say how much profit they realistically make, but with a hugely successful knife company you would think they would know how to run a profitable business. I could be completely wrong. I don't know.
I don't know too much about knife economics, but judging from the recent MAP enforcement, I'd say the (certain) dealers seem to have strong influence over the BM.
[/quote]Why do you say that. It's more like Benchmade has influence over the dealers. Benchmade has the upper hand in my opinion.
-
@captain spaulding said:
@captain spaulding said:
@50ft-trad said:
[quote author=captain spaulding link=topic=54933.msg964739#msg964739 date=1413416958]
[quote author=gunga link=topic=54933.msg964717#msg964717 date=1413414231]
I recently got a mini grip from a friend in trade. Had the same centring and clip issues. I used to have a couple other mini grips. Same clip issues, maybe centring. I don't think this is unique at all.It would seem the clip not touching is just because of the scale shape and (in my opinion) poor design. The centering also seems to be very common, but still unacceptable. Benchmades prices go up and quality control goes down. I feel like I sound like a broken record, but most knife and tool companies are having these issues. They rather produce less superior products and charge more to maximize profits and screw you on both ends of the spectrum then make a fair amount of profit and produce a superior product. Pisses me off.
I wouldn't be surprised in this day and age, that many manufacturers are having to take any shortcuts they can just to make any profit at all. Steel prices are always a dynamic factor, as are energy prices for powering machines and for heat treatment. Inflation matching wage increases, rents, tooling, logistics, litigation ... the list of year on year cost increases for manufacturers goes on and on. I bet the dealers have better margins than the makers do. Doesn't help the user much, I know - but I can see both sides of the fence, and it's not easy for either party right now. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying sloppiness is acceptable, but I expect we'll see this trend continue with larger manufacturers for a while yet
I would respectfully disagree, but it is just my opinion and I really have no way to know either way. What really gets me is the MAP pricing going into effect. Benchmade knives cost rose 33% to the customer. That's a huge increase. Now the pricing is one thing and if quality stayed the same then it is what it is, but introducing MAP pricing and letting quality control go to crap is a whole other problem. I just personally don't see how they could be struggling to make profit. Without knowing what they make the knives for and what they sell them to the dealers for it is hard to say how much profit they realistically make, but with a hugely successful knife company you would think they would know how to run a profitable business. I could be completely wrong. I don't know.
I don't know too much about knife economics, but judging from the recent MAP enforcement, I'd say the (certain) dealers seem to have strong influence over the BM.
[/quote]Why do you say that. It's more like Benchmade has influence over the dealers. Benchmade has the upper hand in my opinion.
[/quote]My understanding (and I might be wrong) is that it ensures the manufacturer does it to minimise pressure from the larger dealers to drop prices further than they can bear to allow. The MAP ensures the larger dealers are happy and get big buck profit without having to driving the price from the manufacturer through the floor completely in order to compete with a smaller dealer who would otherwise accept a much smaller margin
.... or something like that
-
Sounds correct. The problem is those "much smaller dealers" get rubbed out and no longer carry Benchmades products. It screws the smaller dealers and mom and pop shops. I remember reading something about minimum products that must be carried by any dealer of Benchmade knives from ALL their lines of knives which includes their "gold class" knives. I believe their gold class knives start at around $500. Again, all it does is make the smaller shops not be able to carry ANY Benchmade products because they cannot afford to carry a full line of ALL their knives.
-
Hopefully your situation works out to your satisfaction, but I would say I agree with the thread title - I've never been impressed with the Benchmades I've seen either. Maybe I'm not seeing the "good" ones, I don't know. I have a buddy who is way into Benchmade and snags every one he can get at pawn shops if the price is right, and I've never liked any of them.
I'm admittedly not a big folder guy anyway - I like fixed knives. I do have a couple of Spyderco folders that I like, but they aren't perfect either - there are a couple of things I wish they would have done better.
-
I got my first Griptilion and noticed similar issues. When I get the pivot screw tuned where it should be the centering is off a bit. I love the axis lock on these though.
-
I got my Griptilian back from warranty service and the centering is perfect now. I'm happy with it now and it will be my main pocket knife for the foreseeable future. Their customer service handled it well and its good to go.
This still does not change the fact that I still have the custom with the blade off center and I even had to send it in, in the first place.
Benchmades customer service is excellent though.
-
@captain spaulding said:
I got my Griptilian back from warranty service and the centering is perfect now. I'm happy with it now and it will be my main pocket knife for the foreseeable future. Their customer service handled it well and its good to go.This still does not change the fact that I still have the custom with the blade off center and I even had to send it in, in the first place.
Benchmades customer service is excellent though.
Great news Cap'n
Does this mean you'll be trusting them with fixing up your custom now? -
@50ft-trad said:
@captain spaulding said:
I got my Griptilian back from warranty service and the centering is perfect now. I'm happy with it now and it will be my main pocket knife for the foreseeable future. Their customer service handled it well and its good to go.
This still does not change the fact that I still have the custom with the blade off center and I even had to send it in, in the first place.
Benchmades customer service is excellent though.
Great news Cap'n
Does this mean you'll be trusting them with fixing up your custom now?Honestly I have not decided yet. The centering is not as bad as the other one, but it is still off. As a piece I bought to simply enjoy and not planning on carrying it would technically not be a problem, but still bugs me to think about. I do think they sen't another paid shipping label so if it shows up I might send it in. I was really waiting to see how they handled this one which turned out excellent so chances are I might.
-
@captain spaulding said:
@50ft-trad said:
@captain spaulding said:
I got my Griptilian back from warranty service and the centering is perfect now. I'm happy with it now and it will be my main pocket knife for the foreseeable future. Their customer service handled it well and its good to go.
This still does not change the fact that I still have the custom with the blade off center and I even had to send it in, in the first place.
Benchmades customer service is excellent though.
Great news Cap'n
Does this mean you'll be trusting them with fixing up your custom now?Honestly I have not decided yet. The centering is not as bad as the other one, but it is still off. As a piece I bought to simply enjoy and not planning on carrying it would technically not be a problem, but still bugs me to think about. I do think they sen't another paid shipping label so if it shows up I might send it in. I was really waiting to see how they handled this one which turned out excellent so chances are I might.
Glad to see things ended up resolving in a positive way for you!

-
@captain spaulding said:
@50ft-trad said:
@captain spaulding said:
I got my Griptilian back from warranty service and the centering is perfect now. I'm happy with it now and it will be my main pocket knife for the foreseeable future. Their customer service handled it well and its good to go.
This still does not change the fact that I still have the custom with the blade off center and I even had to send it in, in the first place.
Benchmades customer service is excellent though.
Great news Cap'n
Does this mean you'll be trusting them with fixing up your custom now?Honestly I have not decided yet. The centering is not as bad as the other one, but it is still off. As a piece I bought to simply enjoy and not planning on carrying it would technically not be a problem, but still bugs me to think about. I do think they sen't another paid shipping label so if it shows up I might send it in. I was really waiting to see how they handled this one which turned out excellent so chances are I might.
Glad to see things ended up resolving in a positive way for you!

Me too. :D
To top it off I fitted it with a Benchmade factory deep carry clip.

Ill get some quick pics.
-
I just got a few. The lighting sucked, but you will get the "picture" so to speak. :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


