Digital Vernier Calipers
-
I only use verniers as a quick reference gauge only (particularly digital ones - I tend to trust the analogue scales a little more), and don't rely *too *heavily on the results. If I need anything of any accuracy, I'll always reach for the micrometers and standards (I always use standards in case whoever calibrated the mic has got a heavier/lighter touch than me, as this can lead to errors)
-
I don't think there are any difference in performance, besides what mentioned about the battery. I do use a few of those verniers often in RC racing, and the only reason I think one will choose CF is because of its weight.
-
@gregozedobe said:
I have some cheap digital SS ones, but they drain the batteries pretty quick even when they are switched off (high parasitic drain). Something that might be worth checking out before buying.My batteries drain too. I just get the packs of 10 cells for about $1 or $2 shipped, also ebay.
-
Stainless.
I have several that don´t drain, and one that does. Even the cheap ones are usually good enough to measure tenth of a milimeter, on hundreds they may be slighly off.
But most people are producing more "off" while handling.
-
I have a cheap one that reads to .5mm, and two that came from work that read to .01mm, but the calibration is out, and one now reads +/- .01mm, and the other +/- .02mm. For me though, I'll never in my life need that accuracy! I think they are made by Starrett.

-
@hiraethus said:
Personally, I'd go for stainless analogue verniers.+1. My choice and recommendation as well.
-
My first choice would be stainless analog for durability but would you get a slightly different read with say a temperature variance of 30.C (Hot day vs Cold night). Or are we only talking hundredths of mm here?
-
Thousandths of a mm, not hundredths. You'll get more variation from the way you measure the parts rather than any temperature change.
-
@TheDude said:
My first choice would be stainless analog for durability but would you get a slightly different read with say a temperature variance of 30.C (Hot day vs Cold night). Or are we only talking hundredths of mm here?The actual length difference due to thermal expansion is dependent on the total length of the piece in question (as well as materials of construction, obviously).
However, assuming a coefficient of linear thermal expansion for stainless steel of 2 x 10-5 per degree C, using your stated temperature change of 30 degrees C yields a difference of only 0.06%.
So if you were measuring a piece that was exactly 40 mm in length (and had a thermal coefficient of expansion of zero) at your temperature extremes, the difference observed due to the thermal expansion of the calipers would be about 0.024 mm.
-
@nate j said:
My first choice would be stainless analog for durability but would you get a slightly different read with say a temperature variance of 30.C (Hot day vs Cold night). Or are we only talking hundredths of mm here?
The actual length difference due to thermal expansion is dependent on the total length of the piece in question (as well as materials of construction, obviously).
However, assuming a coefficient of linear thermal expansion for stainless steel of 2 x 10-5 per degree C, using your stated temperature change of 30 degrees C yields a difference of only 0.06%.
So if you were measuring a piece that was exactly 40 mm in length (and had a thermal coefficient of expansion of zero) at your temperature extremes, the difference observed due to the thermal expansion of the calipers would be about 0.024 mm.
That just made me dizzy! :ahhh

-
For casual use it doesn't really matter. go with the best you can afford but don't go overboard Case in point;. my old oscilloscope was a bell+howel cause I didn't need the precision of a techtronix as a hobbyist, it was money I could spend on other equipment and parts.
For my current calipers I just went with what was available at the local hardware store and the gun shop. But for my application of hobby reloading and a little lathe work they were precise enough.
When I built rescue/confined space winches and equip we had a + /- .005in variance on critical mechanical and +/- .01 on non critical parts. So standard Staretts were good enough for most. Though engineering kept an expensive master set and a standard in office under lock and key. Soft goods and rubber parts could be read with veneers at .1in.
But if the parts you are dealing with are of different materials or subject to thermal stress then pay attention to that sort of thing.
Ever hear the phrase; "cold enough to freeze the balls off a brass monkey"?
Its a 200yr old reference to the difference in shrink rates between iron cannon balls and the brass monkey tool they were stored on.Thermal coefficients have been a measurable item for hundreds if not thousands of years. In smithing a seamless collars and plugs for rifle or cannon breach, wagon tyres and hot mortise joints are just a few examples.
Parts for racing engines, aircraft, precision mechanicals(cooling fan or HDin your pc) and even paintball markers all have to take thermal effects during operation vs during manufacture into account. the level of operational variance determines whether more precise measurement is necessary to maintain tolerance. In most cases it is a non issue as the engineered +/- tolerance whether fixed or % offers enough space , but there are occasional exceptions.And usually a couple ten thousandths variance in the tool is not an issue but if you get into truly precision building then it may make all the difference.
After all whats the difrence between 223Rem and 5.56x45? About a thousandth of an inch, 1or2 deg.s on the shoulder and 800psi in the chamber. Not enough to tell by eye or even by some measurement; but enough to blow the action on your gun and hurt you if you drop a 556 in a 223 weapon. I give this as a simple example of precision=safety concerns. Sometimes precision measurement is safety, in real life both rounds are marked on the head stamp to avoid confusion.So The choice of calipers and how much to spend is very much a question of your use.
Ask yourself;
Professional or hobby?
What sort of parts am I measuring?
Is the safety of someone dependent?
What size variance is tolerable?
Are thermal coefficients really an issue?
Am I going to be upgrading skills/product/standards to need better in the near future?
How much do I actually have to spend? Buy the best you can afford but don't go broke on more than you need. -
I have a set of Mitutoyo 8" Digimatic digital calipers that I have had for about 15 years. The battery in them lasts forever. But they were pretty expensive.
I also have a set of Mitutoyo analogue vernier calipers that I've had for over 30 years also 8", and the main reason I hardly use them these days is my eyes are not good enough to read them any more. :'( -
Hmmmm......the MTO anwser, get both. :p
I would go SS myself.Nate
-
and putting my pedantic hat on for a minute... they are EITHER Digital OR Vernier calipers.
Digital readout, OR Vernier scale.
Here's another thought. You could go for a set of Dial calipers. Easier to read than a vernier scale and no batteries to run down.
-
Thanks team.
-
@Noa Isumi said:
When I built rescue/confined space winches and equip we had a + /- .005in variance on critical mechanical and +/- .01 on non critical parts.I´m each time again astonished how big and scary those 0.00xx inch numbers read ....... until i recalculate them to metric. :D
The above mentioned variance is not that much, that could be done with each cheap caliper, be it a analoque or a digital one.
The more precise ones are only needed for work like defined fits, let´s say the slide fit, or press fit of bearings/gears and such stuff. There it can be needed to work down to 1/100 - 3/100 of a milimeter (just for example what i´m talking about, then we are at numbers like 1/100 mm is 0.0004 inch). If someone needs such exact readouts, he better uses micrometers than calipers.
-
I know, don't those decimals look scary in imperial units? >:D
But they aren't
So please bear with my backwards scale...
I have always used dial calipers until recently when I got a set of digitals for the convince of reading when measuring hundreds of parts at a time.
Yes I measure every part when hand loading. Its not that I'm looking for bench rest precision I just want it to be right. I'm not yet confident or experienced enough to just run it through my progressive press and batch test like some do.
You are right about mics being better for the truly precise. I haven't needed to live and work in the 4th and 5th place very often. But I have machinist friends that do.
Precision and accuracy is all relative to application.
-
get you a pair of brown & sharp or starrett in stainless they wont let you down learn how to read in tenths too if you dont know its a big help
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



