TSA Confiscations
-
I would certainly vote for them to loosen the restrictions on knives, thus severely curtailing the confiscations. But barring that, it's not like the confiscations wouldn't happen if no one bought the confiscated items, so I don't see any issue with buying the confiscated items when a good deal can be had.
-
@nate j said:
I would certainly vote for them to loosen the restrictions on knives, thus severely curtailing the confiscations. But barring that, it's not like the confiscations wouldn't happen if no one bought the confiscated items, so I don't see any issue with buying the confiscated items when a good deal can be had.You probably already know this, bu they recently tried that and the flight attendants threw a hissy fit and got it shot down.

-
90% of what I have I bought from our Airports Chapel sale, so I'm 100% fine with buying confiscated items. The whole confiscation process sucks, but being able to buy the items for dirt cheap is better than them getting destroyed.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
@captain spaulding said:
@nate j said:
I would certainly vote for them to loosen the restrictions on knives, thus severely curtailing the confiscations. But barring that, it's not like the confiscations wouldn't happen if no one bought the confiscated items, so I don't see any issue with buying the confiscated items when a good deal can be had.
You probably already know this, bu they recently tried that and the flight attendants threw a hissy fit and got it shot down.

Yes, I do recall that. According to the TSA, the planned change was "part of an overall Risk-Based Security approach, which allows Transportation Security Officers to better focus their efforts on finding higher threat items such as explosives. This decision aligns TSA more closely with International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) standards."
This all made perfect sense, but was scuttled by fear-mongering whiners with a poor understanding of the dynamics of close range violence. Now, I'm not suggesting they start allowing knives in prisons, but anyone who is dangerous with a 6 cm non-locking folder can't be less dangerous without one by anything but the very slimmest of margins. While I don't claim to be an expert on the subject, if I had the choice between trying to use my 91 mm SAK as a weapon and using my bare hands, I would generally choose bare hands.

-
@cedricada said:
Its what happens when you privatize absolutely everything in a country, its gets full of shark style practices - ths TSA is in business to make money, and the sales of seizures from poor hurried or overwhelmed passengers go to them.The decent thing to do would be to have a padded post bag for sale at the terminal to have the item posted back. But instead, they opt to capitalize on the hurry someone is in and confiscate and resell.
I know the answer is "well if you dont want it taken, dont be absent minded". But I hate that pervasive attitude. Its creeping into everything. People should be given a little leeway for error here and there.
It must make the nutter terrorists so happy to see what they caused to happen to air travel. People getting looked at naked and molested just to get on a flight. When does it end?
I do agree with the idea of setting up a small segment somewhere close to the TSA screening, and people could just post their precious back to themselves. I mean they could even sell those padded envelop at much higher price(for example, $5-10 each), and in addition, a machine that sell postage label. That'd be triple win to airport, post office and traveller.
-
@comis said:
I do agree with the idea of setting up a small segment somewhere close to the TSA screening, and people could just post their precious back to themselves. I mean they could even sell those padded envelop at much higher price(for example, $5-10 each), and in addition, a machine that sell postage label. That'd be triple win to airport, post office and traveller.That would make perfect sense, so I guess it's unlikely to happen :(
-
I've been pondering some more on this subject and have come to the conclusion it's all a pretty vile act. By all means confiscate, seize whatever!! But it should at least be held say for 3 months with a docket for the passenger to pay and collect when they return, whatever remains after that period then by all means sell, donate whatever... The owner was clearly not interested.
@ironraven said:
In the state of Vermont, they are sold through the state surplus store, right next to other police seized items that are no longer needed as evidence and aren't firearms. Every few months, there is an email sent out, and the knife junkies gather there at 7am with their hats or buckets and bundles of cash. My former roommate picked up a bow at one of those, I just buy knives by the pint. Some if it is kinda sad, like a brand new knife with initials (if a name, I'd try to find the person), but by and large it's just people being stupid. I picked up a nice butcher knife there once, still have it.You can also buy surplussed out office equipment and furniture, old power tools, taxidermist albino beavers, and sometimes even a fire truck. For real. :P It's Mont-peculiar holding a lawn sale
Truly revolting, just proves that the whole thing is nothing more than a legalised cash cow for the TSA
Dispiccable! My morals are far too high too stoop to such a low level - without intending to offend anyone it's kind of like rats feasting!!It seems today, everyone is out to line their pockets without wanting to work for it. Slightly off topic, but our local refuse centre is just horrendous. The workers their actual scavenge through your stuff to see if they can sell any of it at car boots!
Fair enough I hear you say... But last year whilst cutting the hedge I cut the cable..again! Once the car was full I went to the tip, got my pliers out and asked one of the workers if I could possibly cut a cable off one of the mowers, there were dozens and dozens of them all in cages.
No! Was the answer, I protested what does it matter they are destined to be destroyed, he smiled and asked me to leave. I had to call at a shop on the way home and buy a new cable at £1.99 per metre - wanted 15m!
So now, if I take anything to the tip that I think they can make money on I simply smash it before I take it or give it to charity shops or friends! To hell with them!!
-
@tosh said:
I've been pondering some more on this subject and have come to the conclusion it's all a pretty vile act. By all means confiscate, seize whatever!! But it should at least be held say for 3 months with a docket for the passenger to pay and collect when they return, whatever remains after that period then by all means sell, donate whatever... The owner was clearly not interested.Of course you would be OK to pay the fee for that:
- Administration
- Storage
And pay in advance because the work is there whether you pick it up later or not, so you pay 20$ if they have to confiscate your 10$ Micra. On the up side, you can go an pick it up upon your return.
Seriously, don't bring a knife if you wanna fly!
In the state of Vermont, they are sold through the state surplus store, right next to other police seized items that are no longer needed as evidence and aren't firearms. Every few months, there is an email sent out, and the knife junkies gather there at 7am with their hats or buckets and bundles of cash. My former roommate picked up a bow at one of those, I just buy knives by the pint. Some if it is kinda sad, like a brand new knife with initials (if a name, I'd try to find the person), but by and large it's just people being stupid. I picked up a nice butcher knife there once, still have it.
You can also buy surplussed out office equipment and furniture, old power tools, taxidermist albino beavers, and sometimes even a fire truck. For real. :P It's Mont-peculiar holding a lawn sale
Truly revolting, just proves that the whole thing is nothing more than a legalised cash cow for the TSA
Dispiccable! My morals are far too high too stoop to such a low level - without intending to offend anyone it's kind of like rats feasting!!It seems today, everyone is out to line their pockets without wanting to work for it. Slightly off topic, but our local refuse centre is just horrendous. The workers their actual scavenge through your stuff to see if they can sell any of it at car boots!
Fair enough I hear you say... But last year whilst cutting the hedge I cut the cable..again! Once the car was full I went to the tip, got my pliers out and asked one of the workers if I could possibly cut a cable off one of the mowers, there were dozens and dozens of them all in cages.
No! Was the answer, I protested what does it matter they are destined to be destroyed, he smiled and asked me to leave. I had to call at a shop on the way home and buy a new cable at £1.99 per metre - wanted 15m!
So now, if I take anything to the tip that I think they can make money on I simply smash it before I take it or give it to charity shops or friends! To hell with them!!
Simple question. Were they legally allowed to give you that cable? Because, same situation here in Switzerland you would have been asking them to commit a felony and no matter how ridiculous you find that, the problem is not with those workers.
Also you should be furious at yourself, for being so careless and cutting the cable and then you wanted free replacement for the cable. -
I wasn't so much furious at cutting the cable. My hedge stands roughly 20ft high, I usually put the triple extending ladders up against the hedge and trim as I climb the ladder!! I really don't fancy the idea of petrol cutters and so use electric with a circuit breaker.
The refuse workers at my local recycling centre obviously have something going on - a friend of the family actually took a job there whist he was out of work. He told me it was all fiddle fiddle fiddle. As for the cable I wanted, it had already been taken there by its original owner, I wasn't after the motor, switch, blade just the cable with the moulded plug attached. They wouldn't allow me to cut one off, but then say "we'll take that" if you happen to have anything that could be resold - pretty double standards.So now I simply destroy whatever I take, it's a tip after all.
-
@tosh said:
It seems today, everyone is out to line their pockets without wanting to work for it. Slightly off topic, but our local refuse centre is just horrendous. The workers their actual scavenge through your stuff to see if they can sell any of it at car boots!
Fair enough I hear you say... But last year whilst cutting the hedge I cut the cable..again! Once the car was full I went to the tip, got my pliers out and asked one of the workers if I could possibly cut a cable off one of the mowers, there were dozens and dozens of them all in cages.
No! Was the answer, I protested what does it matter they are destined to be destroyed, he smiled and asked me to leave. I had to call at a shop on the way home and buy a new cable at £1.99 per metre - wanted 15m!
So now, if I take anything to the tip that I think they can make money on I simply smash it before I take it or give it to charity shops or friends! To hell with them!!
@tosh said:
I wasn't so much furious at cutting the cable. My hedge stands roughly 20ft high, I usually put the triple extending ladders up against the hedge and trim as I climb the ladder!! I really don't fancy the idea of petrol cutters and so use electric with a circuit breaker.
The refuse workers at my local recycling centre obviously have something going on - a friend of the family actually took a job there whist he was out of work. He told me it was all fiddle fiddle fiddle. As for the cable I wanted, it had already been taken there by its original owner, I wasn't after the motor, switch, blade just the cable with the moulded plug attached. They wouldn't allow me to cut one off, but then say "we'll take that" if you happen to have anything that could be resold - pretty double standards.So now I simply destroy whatever I take, it's a tip after all.
I'm really sorry, but I find it quite amusing that you're getting so uptight about this. When anything is taken to one of these recycling centres, it becomes the PROPERTY AND RESPONSIBILITY of the multimillion pound company that operates the site. Of course they're not just going to let you take stuff out! They're going to run it through a desheathing plant and sell it at £3.50/£4.00 per kilo, not let people help themselves to their stock, not to mention risk a massive legal battle when the used cable of unknown condition (potentially sub-standard or damaged) they "supplied", ends up electrocuting someone or starting an electrical fire. There are very sensible reasons for them restricting these materials.
If the lads there are scavenging and car booting their loot, that's theft pure and simple, and it's a matter between them, the police, and their employers. You can't start chuntering about it just because they wouldn't let you nick some of it instead of them nicking it and flogging it for themselves
Plus, why start protesting at them because you can't blag free cable or subsequently spending £30 on a new 15m length, when a £4 inline connector would have easily repaired it 
As for feeling the need to destroy stuff for fear of someone getting use out of it, if it's that much of an issue to you, and the item is still usable and friends or charity shops don't want it, stick it on Freecycle. That way someone who really needs one but hasn't got the cash gets a helping hand, and you don't have to lug it around in your car
-
@tosh said:
Truly revolting, just proves that the whole thing is nothing more than a legalised cash cow for the TSA
Dispiccable! My morals are far too high too stoop to such a low level - without intending to offend anyone it's kind of like rats feasting!!So... The government selling off things like older office equipment, surplus vehicles and the like for the purposes of recooping part of the purchase, along with items that were evidence or seized by people who after 13 years of a law being in force are still trying to sneak knives on planes, is revolting to you? Really? So you're getting your nose out of joint by things like selling a bunch of sleeping bags and tents that were bought for game wardens and most of them haven't been used in ten year to the boy scouts so that scouts that can't afford gear can go camping? Or cars that were seized from drug dealers? Or selling taxidermied animals and salvaged lighting fixtures from a state office building that is being torn down is a bad thing? How about coffee cups full of paper clips and pencil stubs being sold for fifty cents and lightly used 1 and 2 inch binders for a buck, marked down "you guys are broke, you're kid needs school supplies" in the last week of August?
Really? The DoD used to sell stuff by the pallet, some out modded and most of it just junk. Military surplus equipment, state surplus equipment, it's all surplus but usable equipment. The fire truck I mentioned I think is from the merger of two agencies into one, and since the state helped by it for the town it came from, they are helping to sell it to some town that needs a pumper, funds to go towards building a new building for the combined agency IIRC. This has you angry? This is SMART government, holding a bloody yard sale rather than smashing stuff and selling it for pennies on the dollar as scrap.
And you're going to toss about terms like "rats feasting"? Really dude?
Mods, this is getting political and unpleasant. And we're getting too much of this kind of thing.
-
Gentlemen, this is getting very close to being locked. Please tone down the political rhetoric. It really has no place at all here on the forum. -
I do agree with the idea of setting up a small segment somewhere close to the TSA screening, and people could just post their precious back to themselves. I mean they could even sell those padded envelop at much higher price(for example, $5-10 each), and in addition, a machine that sell postage label. That'd be triple win to airport, post office and traveller.
That would make perfect sense, so I guess it's unlikely to happen :(

-
Once again you've managed to to twist this around again - lol
Like I originally posted, it was the sentimental stuff that is seized and simply flogged off, the refuse centre operates on fiddle fiddle, what some of these have in common is that they have the backing of law which allows these people to take what they wish and then basically do with as they wish. That's my beef.I never mentioned anything about office equipment and the likes.
In my view if something is seized, then I think its perfectly reasonable that the owner is given the opportunity to claim it back - and just to clarify I'm talking about TSA seizing MTs & SAKs (this is a multitool forum after all) not drugs, office furniture, bombs and god knows what else you've brought up. Basically sentimental stuff confiscated from their boarding luggage.
As for the guys at the local tip with their fiddle fiddle fiddle "I'll take that love, now clear off" attitude....to hell with them, I'll choose not to line their pockets if you don't mind.
-
@tosh said:
In my view if something is seized, then I think its perfectly reasonable that the owner is given the opportunity to claim it back - and just to clarify I'm talking about TSA seizing MTs & SAKs (this is a multitool forum after all) not drugs, office furniture, bombs and god knows what else you've brought up. Basically sentimental stuff confiscated from their boarding luggage.There are simple steps to avoid that.
- Don't carry a MT or SAK when going for a flight
- Check your pockets (and carry on) before checking in your luggage (that way you can put anything illegal to carry on in your check in luggage)
- Check again your pockets (and carry on) while in line for the security check, find anything illegal put it in the trash or find a postal office and mail it to your home.
- Hand your contraband* to the TSA-officer without complaining, the people in line behind you will be thankful.
So, basically what you ask for is not required because it already exists.
- Yes, thats what it is. How do they know it was an oversight and not an attempt to smuggle a weapon aboard.
-
I hate the possibility, or even worse, the actuality, of tools being 'confiscated' by the 'TSA'
- Well in fact my SAK was not being 'confiscated' * it was being 'voluntarily surrendered' * by me
- as I was snootily corrected by a 'TSA' operator - one time it happened to me in Sydney.
But we all know the rules - So as many have said - Make sure your tools are in your hold luggage.
And if they are not ......'tough'......- It is so sad: A SAK you've had since childhood, a precious or rare tool, something you really need at your destination, you never really knew the rules (for a new/naïve traveller)
- But rules are rules - we know why they are there - and have to accept them
- Although why Classics cannot be allowed bewilders me.... Actually it does not really bewilder me
It's all a question of where do you draw the line and then subsequently enforce it.
So if Classics are allowed what about nail files, scissors, small knives (how small is small?)... easiest to have a blanket rule??
Likewise, having a postage or storage service, is a **fantastic ** idea - Until you start to think about it practically.
You'd have to allow people to mail anywhere in the world potentially, what about the possible massive weights/size variations, postage costs, customs declarations, banned items for export/import, what about the administration costs of a storage/postage facility ... blah blah blah.All that said - I had a couple of nice experiences at Stanstead and Bristol airports in the UK.
At both these airports the security check is **before ** immigration - I was pinged both times with a SAK in my hand baggage (doohherrrr)
However in both cases I was allowed to go back through security: Once to post the SAK back to myself, once to pop back to my car and leave the SAK in my car!! Bristol is a tiny airport and the CP is right opposite the terminal - **FAB!! ** :)
This option was not open to me in Sydney as security is **after ** immigration - So technically you'd have to re-enter the country to get to a letter box or car park - and they weren't having that!!So SAKS, tools, scissors, knives etc etc get confiscated....
As for me - I am also a passionate re-cycler/mender/fixer - So again like many have said - if these tools can be bought and recycled - great - If that money goes to a good cause like the chapel - even better. Even if it goes to the airport - It could benefit us in the long run - reduced fees/costs for flights etc!! Or am I just too naïve .Yes I am very sad for the original owners - But better a new owner than in the skip.
And don't trash your rubbish Tosh - If you do not need it - Who cares if someone else benefits....
-
@Huntsman said:
And don't trash your rubbish Tosh - If you do not need it - Who cares if someone else benefits....For the record, I'm generous to a fault, I'm always giving stuff away to friends. But I won't be taken for a mug, and line peoples pockets. Sorry but I do draw the line at that point. If it's for charity or other good causes or simply someone actually wants my unused stuff - fine. But not to simply be re-sold, especially with the high handed attitude that these guys often give.
No, where they and the likes of them are concerned they'll get bugger all from me!!
That's the way it is. Sorry if anyone is offended. -
Not me, i understand you.
When there is something that i don´t need anymore and it´s still working, i ask around if someone can use it - or knows someone who might use it.
But if i find noone, person or organisation, who really has a use for it (not selling or making profit, just use it in it´s intended way), then i scrap it. And when i scrap it i take care that it´s unuseable.I don´t fly often, and if i would forget to go without MT, and they want to seize it - i probably would bend/break whatever i can. No interest in hearing again storys like "You paid what for yours? I know someone at the airport, sometimes he brings me stuff he got from the boxes of the seized stuff. Before its scrapped or auctioned they were allowed to have the first choice if they want something."
No, Sir, not with my stuff. When i gonna give something, then it has to be my free choice,
-
Had a Leatherman taken by TSA.

On more than one occasion since then, I have arrived at the airport unintentionally carrying a multitool, and have hidden them in the airport. Amazingly enough, they were there when I returned.
Not recommended though as I imagine there are more and more cameras in airports.
-
Aha - Nice one :D
Me too - Realised, with a sick feeling in my stomach, as I got off the train at the airport station (no going back)
Hid it - and likewise it was there when I returned a couple of days later :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login