What tool did you carry today?
-
I am not mad so please don't take it that way. I am thinking on this point we are going to have to agree to disagree.
It´s in the middle between 2 effective systems, no good in each direction. That´s not it´s fault, it´s just that the way of a war is not the same as when our fathers/grandpas were soldiers.
It´s not only my opinon, i heard the same from US troops - the fighting ones, not in the back.
I am a US Troop 11B Infantryman who has been in the think of it since this whole mess started.
For close combat - higher firing rate, smaller caliber would be OK (if not to small like the toy 5,56),
Agree with you about this. That is what we have the 240B for.
or for more range 2cm or above for fast moving troops.
Not so much on this point. More range then a M2 .50? What weapon system are we talking about. The 25mm on a Bradley fits this description but only with a advanced optic system. As it stands now I can shoot almost as far as I can see with the M2.
Additional small and light vehicles with bigger bangs for fast response where needed, with direct sightline firing HE, HEAT, AP, .... capable against fast moving targets and a high firing rate (at least double of the small guided missiles).
Again something like the 25mm Bushmaster? For the limited vehicles used in this era of fighting the M2 is beyond effective. Will go though a truck front to back including the engine block.
Off course my opinion is infantry biased, but i would prefer 2 other old weapons combined - the german 7,62 MG3 for the high firing rate, and additional the M40 recoilless rifle (or something that way). Light, moveable by infantry, versatile and effective.
I am also Infantry biased. We have the two weapons you speak of already being used everyday. 240B GPMG or MK 48 and the Carl Gustav, AT-4 and SMAW.
To sum up my thoughts on the M2. It is a heavy vehicle or defensive mounted heavy machine gun that plain ends fights and has the range and round to be effective in the mountains of Afghanistan.
Again I enjoy talking guns and am in no way upset you don't care for the M2. Just in my 19 years of doing this never had a Soldier say they don't care for it. Well maybe humping it up a hill you might here some complaining, never in a real fight though.
-
The whole thing is so complex, i would prefer to go through it over a evening with some beverage and bbq - and in my native lanquage. ;)
With "more range" i didn´t mean more than the M2, just "More than the smaller 7,62 deliver". And additional bigger punch. Yeah, compared to a bushmaster, but not on a fat and heavy Bradley (iirr it´s over 30 tons?). Modern IFVs seem to be perfect to transport the infantery accompanying the main battle tanks in free field battles, but on the other hand to bulky/heavy to keep up with the walking troops in tigher spaces (same problem with our Marder/Puma).
The guns are only a part of what´s wrong in my opion, the whole todays concept is more for a real war between reg. troops - but i don´t see this happen in the next time again.
Imho it´s wrong to send the boys out with mostly light weapons, and then relying on calling the airjockeys. It´s like poking with a stick first, and then burn everything - to random effects. What i´m missing is the equipment to deliver always and every second massive direct fire, prefered from a light tankette that´s able to drive through tight streets. Like our "Wiesel", or something as a modern version of the US M50 Ontos. Light crafts that could engage a combined movement with soldiers taking cover around/behind him AND deliver some serious rounds. It has to fit in a CH53 for fast deployment. The cold war with army against army in open battles is over, it´s time to go from big hammers on to more versatile ways to fight in irregular wars.
But it´s hard to discuss that in a foreign language.
-
Had to Google what a Wiesel was.
This is a subject close to my heart being that I am currently in a Stryker Cavalry unit. Is something like this what you had in mind.

Or something a little smaller and more basic like this?

-
Damn, i had a long text - and frakked it.

As a ex-paratrooper i like fast response - so i would take the second one, if no Wiesel is available. (It just needs a bigger gun) ;)
But some Stryker MGS as a backup sounds good, too. :D
-
@Lichtbote said:
Damn, i had a long text - and frakked it.
As a ex-paratrooper i like fast response - so i would take the second one, if no Wiesel is available. (It just needs a bigger gun) ;)
But some Stryker MGS as a backup sounds good, too. :D
Heck yes! Spent 13 years and 4 combat deployments with the 82nd Airborne Division. Nice to meet fellow paratroopers.

I have the Gold Schutzenschnur I earned while at Fort Benning. Some of your officers came and ran the qualifications.
-
I carried my BO ST200 and my OC red Pioneer today.
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
Heck yes! Spent 13 years and 4 combat deployments with the 82nd Airborne Division. Nice to meet fellow paratroopers.
"Glück ab, Kamerad!"

1st Airborne Division, formerly 27th and now renamed to 31st Brigade.

@HarleyXJGuy said:
I have the Gold Schutzenschnur I earned while at Fort Benning. Some of your officers came and ran the qualifications.Cool. I never made gold myself, as i always had a problem with fulfilling my MG targets.
:D -
Skeletool, Style cs, PW2

Sak's rule !
-
Rogueneer and Flik again today

-
MP1, Style CS. Big fat fail for TBT !

Sak's rule !
-
^^ Cool pic!

I'm carrying my SwissTool and OC red Pioneer today.
-
Original Supertool and Rogueneer today

-
PST, Black/Red Pioneer, and Manager.
-

MiniChamp on my keys and Juice in my coin pocket
-
St300 and Vic Explorer. Put them both to work. At same time...
-
Im carrying B.O. rebar, normally i make it a point 1 model / tool for 1 week like for the past week, its Spirit, this incoming week, i will carry Rebar.
Sent from my iPad R Mini using Tapatalk
-
Charge, Crunch and Super Tinker.
-
@jspalaroan said:
Im carrying B.O. rebar, normally i make it a point 1 model / tool for 1 week like for the past week, its Spirit, this incoming week, i will carry Rebar.Sent from my iPad R Mini using Tapatalk
I had the same type of rotation for a while, but it became too much to keep organized once I added more multies to it. Now I just carry whatever strikes my fancy each day.
-
Someone is still in recovery from the SAK challenge? Either that or building a house maybe.
So I am still rocking the Wave I bought from Joel. Thanks again buddy.
Now if one of you can guess what my Wave is sitting on I will give you mad props. Not sure I could guess what it is and I have been doing this Army stuff for like a long time.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login