Combo tool vs opener layer
-
Well if you can't decide, then just carry a SwissChamp XAVT or XXLT. They have a combo tool AND normal opener layer. :D
-
Ok I am thinking it comes down to opening layer being two tools or combo tool being one but needing a inline or back phillips to cover the same bases. Ends up being two tools either way but one can be located on the back layer for a thinner knife. Granted both the back phillips and combo tool give up some function and reach.
The rub is if you combine your SAK with a multi tool. If lets say I carry Little Boy then I could grab a SAK with no combo tool or opening layer. Heck I could also drop the knife, file. saw, awl and pliers.
Why am I bringing my SAK again?

Sheeple frendly and back up? Well I will carry one for the love of gear but I question a real need.
-
Opener layer. The openers do better than the combo tool and they're more versatile too.
Another point to consider is that the opener layer adds heft to the SAK. Also, I love how I can use the bottle opener combined with the main blade for augmented control.
-
Opener layer all the way for me!

Although I would love to get my hands on a Yeoman!

-
I have never tried the combo opener from Vic. Maybe I need to rectify that in the future.
-
I voted for the opener layer... because I really like having an awl (and a small blade).
-
I voted for the opener layer as that's what I normally carry with my Rogueneer. However, the more I think about this, the more I think I'd be just fine with the combo tool instead. I rarely use the opener layer for anything at all, and it would be the same idea for the combo tool. On top of that, I pair my SAK with an MT, so there's always an opener of some sort there as well. I think I just like the potential versatility of the separate opener layer. Although if I were only carrying a SAK alone, I would prefer the opener layer just in case.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I have never tried the combo opener from Vic. Maybe I need to rectify that in the future.There's a can opener out there that Lynn never tried? :ahhh
-
@enki_ck said:
There's a can opener out there that Lynn never tried? :ahhhIt IS kind of frightening, isn't it? :D
Also, I've never tried the OLD SAK army knife version (pre-61 Soldiers)... the one that looks like a medieval torture implement.Donations of either kind would be greatly appreciated, and thoroughly tested. :D
EDIT: Huh... also never used the Wenger V-shaped one either. Man, I'm really slacking.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
@enki_ck said:
There's a can opener out there that Lynn never tried? :ahhhIt IS kind of frightening, isn't it? :D
Also, I've never tried the OLD SAK army knife version (pre-61 Soldiers)... the one that looks like a medieval torture implement.Donations of either kind would be greatly appreciated, and thoroughly tested. :D
EDIT: Huh... also never used the Wenger V-shaped one either. Man, I'm really slacking.
The old ones work great. Take a minute to get used to them. One you do, they rip open a can pretty fast.
-
This thread got me thinking what about none of the above?
I almost never need bottles opened that don't have twist caps. (Guess I am cheap)
Once in a blue moon I need a can opened while I am not at home.
So what,we miss out on the sort of drivers on the end of the opening layer tools? I guess there is not a flat driver tool and if you put it on you might as well get a free opener? On second thought I suppose you don't really save anything unless you go with no drivers.
In my experience my use of drivers competes with blade use at the top of the heap so that is a no go. Unless of course you are carrying a Rebar or some such then you don't really need drivers at all. Well or a SAK when it comes down to it.
Ok so ramble complete and nothing figured out.

-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
Ok so ramble complete and nothing figured out.
??? :ahhh :o
You're still in learning process, so there is no need to blame yourself ;)
Here is helping hand :D
... figured out that you "NEED" both of them
>:D -
Ok so ramble complete and nothing figured out.

??? :ahhh :o
You're still in learning process, so there is no need to blame yourself ;)
Here is helping hand :D
... figured out that you "NEED" both of them
>:DMaybe that is why I can not get that Alox Pioneer out of my head? OC Red, Blue oh and a Green one. Wait forgot the Black with Red cross model.
-
Ok so ramble complete and nothing figured out.

??? :ahhh :o
You're still in learning process, so there is no need to blame yourself ;)
Here is helping hand :D
... figured out that you "NEED" both of them
>:DMaybe that is why I can not get that Alox Pioneer out of my head? OC Red, Blue oh and a Green one. Wait forgot the Black with Red cross model.
You got a point ... :D
That's the SAKnight's most painful struggle, would say the real crux
-
Its really best to have one of each model you think you might need just in case. Better more than enough SAKs, then NOT enough SAKs. :D
-
Colours on alox is nice, plain silver works best for me though

Not to mention there's the nail polish approach too... :P
-
Thanks for all the responses guys, appreciate it. Good to see that so many of you out there prefer the separate openers too.
@50ft-trad said:
To be honest, it depends what else I'm carrying.Not being a "SAK only" person, I can usually get away with a combo tool as I have other tools to back it up. However, if I'm only supporting the SAK with something like a Dime, then I'll want the full opener layer
I think that this may be the way forward. Proper multi tool, SAK with combo. SAK on its own, opener layer. I do really like having the small blade as well though. Maybe I need a Pioneer Settler. :)
-
These combinations are driving me crazy! Since getting my Spirit, I have doubled up on all of my favourite tools except the mag glass.
In a way I'm glad the Spirit isn't properly legal carry here otherwise I'd have 'real' problems!

-
After an incident at my house I deemed the combo tool insufficient for my needs and would now be happy with having both openers in a layer specifically for the separate driver sizes. The shower knob in the master bedroom restroom cracked leaving the knob uselessly dangling on the screw that actually opens and closes the water valve. Happy to use my combo tool at the time I whipped out my newly ordered Compact and put the driver in the Phillips slot....nothing! It was just a little too large to fit. I was demoralized and had to seek assistance from my (gulp) Leatherman. After fixing the problem I went out and brought my farmer to the scene and retried the small driver aka Philips and lo and behold it was a perfect fit.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login