Your EDC for a lifetime
-
It is against the law to carry a tool where you are from? They are afraid you might fix the smurf out of something?
It´s in the greys - we are allowed to carry tools, and we are allowed to carry knives. But some sort of knives are prohibitted, and one of them is every knife that has a oho and locking blade. Oho or locking would be OK. And it´s OK if you have one of the reasons listed in the law, for example if you need it for work, not accepted is "i want to be prepared when i might need it".
So in case of a control it all comes down if they classify it as a tool, or as a knife. A construction worker, or a mechanic, will have better chances to get it accepted as a needed tool than a banker, accountant, or schoolbusdriver, ....
This makes me a sad panda.
Why? Its a pretty sensible law, helping to prevent the escalation of violence.
-
It is against the law to carry a tool where you are from? They are afraid you might fix the smurf out of something?
It´s in the greys - we are allowed to carry tools, and we are allowed to carry knives. But some sort of knives are prohibitted, and one of them is every knife that has a oho and locking blade. Oho or locking would be OK. And it´s OK if you have one of the reasons listed in the law, for example if you need it for work, not accepted is "i want to be prepared when i might need it".
So in case of a control it all comes down if they classify it as a tool, or as a knife. A construction worker, or a mechanic, will have better chances to get it accepted as a needed tool than a banker, accountant, or schoolbusdriver, ....
This makes me a sad panda.
Why? Its a pretty sensible law, helping to prevent the escalation of violence.
So if it takes two hands to open my knife there is no way I could use it as a weapon? Maybe someone has a forcefield that only repels lock blade knives?
Lets say for the sake of this discussion I am a criminal intent on doing nefarious things. Maybe felony robbery, oh wait it is against the law to carry a oho lockblade combo knife so I would not want to break the law? Well at least that one law but the rest of them I have no issues ignoring?
-
Many knife laws don´t make much sense the way they are.
For example - a 1,5" blade would be illegal here if oho and locking, but it´s OK to carry a fixed 4,5" blade (as long as it´s no 2 sharp sided dagger).
Most prohibiting knife laws don´t affect the crime planning criminals, but they do keep a lot of usually law abiding people from carrying knives - which minimizes the chance that they will act drunken or in anger, and later have to regret a stupid moment for the rest of their life. You notice that it works due to the main portion of knife attacks is made within the family/friends range, and with kitchen knives.
-
[quote author=HarleyXJGuy link=topic=55833.msg992956#msg992956 date=1417493186]
It is against the law to carry a tool where you are from? They are afraid you might fix the smurf out of something?It´s in the greys - we are allowed to carry tools, and we are allowed to carry knives. But some sort of knives are prohibitted, and one of them is every knife that has a oho and locking blade. Oho or locking would be OK. And it´s OK if you have one of the reasons listed in the law, for example if you need it for work, not accepted is "i want to be prepared when i might need it".
So in case of a control it all comes down if they classify it as a tool, or as a knife. A construction worker, or a mechanic, will have better chances to get it accepted as a needed tool than a banker, accountant, or schoolbusdriver, ....
This makes me a sad panda.
Why? Its a pretty sensible law, helping to prevent the escalation of violence.
So if it takes two hands to open my knife there is no way I could use it as a weapon? Maybe someone has a forcefield that only repels lock blade knives?
Lets say for the sake of this discussion I am a criminal intent on doing nefarious things. Maybe felony robbery, oh wait it is against the law to carry a oho lockblade combo knife so I would not want to break the law? Well at least that one law but the rest of them I have no issues ignoring?
[/quote]
Problem 1 is that if a weapon is easily available its going to be used, so a drunken altercation will easier end with blood. Domestic violence ends in murder.
This applies to about 95% of murders where the victims are women or children.A bunch of gang members goes to a party. Police stops them and decided that they don't need kitchen knifes etc. at a party and confiscated them.
Escalation of violence prevented.Further applications for the criminal not keeping to the law:
You steal a wallet = theft.
You steal a wallet while carrying anything that could be considered a weapon = armed robbery.
Again, preventing escalation of violence. -
There may be some valid points about drunks and crimes of passion. So what is the plan for law abiding citizens who are the target of violent crimes?
As far as making some misswired unit decide to not do a crime because of the increase from robbery to armed robbery seems unlikely.
In some states in the US the penalty for murder can be death. A pretty serious penalty on the face of it yet people in them areas still commit the crime even with the knowledge of the penalty.
"A bunch of gang members goes to a party. Police stops them and decided that they don't need kitchen knifes etc. at a party and confiscated them.
Escalation of violence prevented."This assumes the police have some reason to stop them in the first place. Are random searches without cause allowed where you are from?
-
I'm with Harley on this one.
In my opinion laws like those mainly hurt the law abiding citizens and act as a way to control the law abiding population however the government sees fit.
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
There may be some valid points about drunks and crimes of passion. So what is the plan for law abiding citizens who are the target of violent crimes?In my opinion there is no difference for those. (The same i think for guns, concealed or open carried.)
They are untrained, the fake safety feeling might even lead them to stand a attacker where they better would have run or let them have all your money. And watching some youtubevids regarding knifefighting, then train in mommys basement, is nothing that brings any good for anyone in such a situation.
Robert, we both know that there is a difference in being one of those mighty range cowboys who´s shooting planned (in the meaning you´re knowing what´s coming) on harmless targets ("hey look how close i´m to the ten with all my shots"), and being in a sudden situation where you really can be killed. And such above is nothing like being covered by your group/platoon if you have a weak moment of freeze.
-
@captain spaulding said:
In my opinion laws like those mainly hurt the law abiding citizens and act as a way to control the law abiding population however the government sees fit.And for sure you can explain that to me - why do you think a law, that forbids a small knife (just cause it´s oho and locking) but allows a big fixed knifes, hurts the law abiding citizens?
It´s just a stupid law cause it only/mainly refers to the way the knife is working, but not it´s damage making size.
-
First, Harley congratz on 1k
.I think in the USA, violence already has escalated.
Factors like population density, poverty, alcohol abuse, but also the people themselves etc. so there are regional factors that make a system work, or not. So, not everything that works for Europe works for the USA and vice versa.@HarleyXJGuy said:
As far as making some misswired unit decide to not do a crime because of the increase from robbery to armed robbery seems unlikely.Well, it works in many regions of the world, but as stated above not everything works everywhere.
-
@captain spaulding said:
In my opinion laws like those mainly hurt the law abiding citizens and act as a way to control the law abiding population however the government sees fit.
And for sure you can explain that to me - why do you think a law, that forbids a small knife (just cause it´s oho and locking) but allows a big fixed knifes, hurts the law abiding citizens?
It´s just a stupid law cause it only/mainly refers to the way the knife is working, but not it´s damage making size.
Oh no I did not mean that at all. What I mean is limiting folders and allowing large fixed blades is stupid.
I love that they allow a good fixed.
I was talking about laws that limit what a law following adult citizen can carry hurt the same type of citizen and in no way discourage or stop the bad guys.
-
That´s why i wrote 2 different answers with quotes to 2 different peoples. ;)
You just answered to my question regarding captain spauldings post. :D
As usual these laws are not simple, they all have those "If" and "when" things build in - so you are allowed to carry a lot of generally prohibited blade types if you really need them for work, just not for fun of "i want".
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
Oh no I did not mean that at all. What I mean is limiting folders and allowing large fixed blades is stupid.I love that they allow a good fixed.
Well, the rationale behind this law is, that a folder can be carried concealed and if it is OHO, it can be deployed very fast and surprisingly, reducing the ammount of time the other side has to react. A fixed blade or a THO folder can not be deployed as fast and thus is less dangerous.
IMHO this law would be fine, if it would include an additional blade size requirement for the folders. Because lets face it, I am not going to go stabbity stab stab with my Spyderco Manbug.
-
A fixed blade is the fastest to deploy. Or am I reading that wrong?
-
@ducttapetech said:
A fixed blade is the fastest to deploy. Or am I reading that wrong?True, but if it has a certain size it cannot be carried concealed that easily.
Also, to carry a fixed blade, you need a reason (work, dagger-fighting-class, hunting etc.). You cannot carry a fixed blade without a reason, especially not when going to a bar for a beer. -
Mostly likely I would EDC a Swiss key for the rest of my life.
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
Oh no I did not mean that at all. What I mean is limiting folders and allowing large fixed blades is stupid.I love that they allow a good fixed.
Well, the rationale behind this law is, that a folder can be carried concealed and if it is OHO, it can be deployed very fast and surprisingly, reducing the ammount of time the other side has to react. A fixed blade or a THO folder can not be deployed as fast and thus is less dangerous.
IMHO this law would be fine, if it would include an additional blade size requirement for the folders. Because lets face it, I am not going to go stabbity stab stab with my Spyderco Manbug.
I am going to assume you are joking when you say a knife that is already open is slower then one you have to open to deploy.
You are also messing with me when you say you can not conceal a fixed blade knife? That is prolly ture I mean you can not conceal a pistol or sub machine gun either. I am being sarcastic about that whole last bit by the way.
-
@Etherealicer said:
Also, to carry a fixed blade, you need a reason (work, dagger-fighting-class, hunting etc.). You cannot carry a fixed blade without a reason, especially not when going to a bar for a beer.Dagger-fighting-class, I loled.
-
A fixed blade is the fastest to deploy. Or am I reading that wrong?
True, but if it has a certain size it cannot be carried concealed that easily.
Also, to carry a fixed blade, you need a reason (work, dagger-fighting-class, hunting etc.). You cannot carry a fixed blade without a reason, especially not when going to a bar for a beer.Haha! In Germany we can carry a fixed blade whenever we like. As long as it has a blade below 12 cm. And as long as we do not carry it in specific public environments.
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
I am going to assume you are joking when you say a knife that is already open is slower then one you have to open to deploy.You are also messing with me when you say you can not conceal a fixed blade knife? That is prolly ture I mean you can not conceal a pistol or sub machine gun either. I am being sarcastic about that whole last bit by the way.
Sadly, I am not joking. This is what was said by one of our members of parliament, who was part of the creation process of said law.
-
I am going to assume you are joking when you say a knife that is already open is slower then one you have to open to deploy.
You are also messing with me when you say you can not conceal a fixed blade knife? That is prolly ture I mean you can not conceal a pistol or sub machine gun either. I am being sarcastic about that whole last bit by the way.
Sadly, I am not joking. This is what was said by one of our members of parliament, who was part of the creation process of said law.
And here I thought America had the market cornered on dumb lawmakers. Seems that is not the case.
Good to know, but I still want to visit Germany someday.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login